• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Source based Questions on 'Womens suffrage: the debate - 'What similarities and differences are there between the ideas in these two extracts?

Extracts from this document...


Source based Questions on 'Womens suffrage: the debate' What similarities and differences are there between the ideas in these two extracts? The two extracts are obviously different in that one is anti suffrage and the other is pro. Because of this, A lot of the ideas in the separate points directly contrast each other, "politics and economics go hand in hand" argues against "questions of peace and war, which lie outside the legitimate sphere of women's influence." Here it can be seen how different the extracts are - the Against Suffrage extract bases its main argument on that women are incapable of defending their country with physical force, therefore they should not be entitled to full citizenship, "the physical nature of women unfits them for direct competition with men." However, this would be untrue since the WSPU group etc prove the fact that women are physically capable of exerting force and gaining public attention through it. The women are obviously passionate about getting the vote and would go to any lengths to achieve enfranchisement. They also show in the extract how the reason they are not "capable of contributing" is "BECAUSE all the more important and lucrative positions are barred to them, and opportunities of public service are denied." ...read more.


This may possibly be referring to ideas that women propose to their men at home which they discuss, but it is more likely that it is referring to how men like to come home from a hard days work and relax, while the woman cooks, does the housework, takes care of the children. This, Anti-suffrage supporters would argue, is the 'sphere' of a woman. This, is how women support their country and support their husbands - by ensuring that everything in the home is alright, so that all the men have to concentrate on is their job in serving the countries needs. It seems, therefore a bit ironic that in the pro-suffrage extract, one of the reasons listed for why women should have the vote is : "BECAUSE women will be better comrades to their husbands, better mothers to their children, and better housekeepers of the home." This quote seems to me to re-in force the idea that a woman's job is to merely be a comrade to her husband, and a housekeeper and a mother. It does not give any reference to how women should be allowed to have the right to stand on their own two feet and have their own rights. ...read more.


However, it is possible to imagine a woman as a minister of war - it just has never been done before! In this then, I think that the men are not so much opposed to a woman being minister of war for the reason of her physical incapability, but they are scared of other changes and also scared of losing their power. This is shown in other quotes such as in that they thought it would undoubtedly weaken their countries power and status in the eyes of the other dependent countries. Men previously, have dominated the physical side in every aspect of society. In sport, in war, in public service and in important employment, women do not have a place. Suddenly these conventions are being challenged and the men are scared that they will lose their power and ability to be 'superior' and the more important class. The writer finishes his quote on this subject "and many similar absurdities." This tries to imprint into the readers mind how it is completely ridiculous to even contemplate any ideas of equality that the women's suffrage campaign may put forward. It encourages traditional, conventional ideas that have always had their way in the past, suggesting that women are wasting their time because what has been, will always be. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Britain 1905-1951 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Britain 1905-1951 essays

  1. "Evacuation was a great success" Do you agree? Source based work.

    "Evacuation was a great success." This statement is true in some areas but not in others. It was a success for evacuees living in slum areas because it focused the attention on poverty. Country people were shocked to see the suffering from a lack of nutrition, clothing and cleanliness, so the government successfully distributed food

  2. Evacuation during WWII - source based questions.

    The fact that Miss Evans turned bright red in her reaction to Carrie's reply, shows that she is short tempered, and probably feel she could be better off without the hassle of caring for two evacuees. A reason for this could be that she is not married because she is

  1. Source based questions and answers - The suffragettes.

    a good argument as to why women should have the vote and it's also a good example a peaceful and clever protest, which proves that they weren't, as publicly viewed, only violent. This tactic of posters and other peaceful methods did not seem to make an impact on the government

  2. Women's Suffrage Sources Questions

    This ranged from mocking cabinet ministers, chaining themselves to the railings of government buildings, window smashing, and the destruction of anything which may been seen as a symbolic of male dominance, such as the greens of golf courses which the Suffragettes applied acid to.

  1. Gallipoli Questions

    Source E tells us how there was complete lack of communication, which is summed up completely by telling us that two fifths of the British and Anzac force outnumbered the entire Turk force. The force at S beach sat around and relaxed all day whilst the forces at V beach were slaughtered by machine-gun fire.

  2. Votes For Women 1900-28 Source based work.

    are seen as housewives and mothers and were thought of as to have children that can vote rather than actually vote themselves. The source also continues, 'It cannot be denied that women suffer great injustice at the hands of men.

  1. Votes for women - source related questions.

    families properly is intended to make people think that women would not be able to vote if they cant even do the jobs they already have. When the author says 'votes for women is the shrill cry of a number of discontented ladies' she is really suggesting is that that

  2. Why did a campaign for Women's Suffrage develop in the years after 1870?

    This can be seen in Source I that is from a history book entitled 'Women At War, 1914-1918 ' which was written in 1977, so it was written some time after the era it is talking about with hindsight. The source says that the work women did greatly contributed, but wasn't the only factor.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work