• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Source work on prohibition

Extracts from this document...


Source work on prohibition 1. how useful is source A for studying the spread of prohibition in the United States? Source A is useful for studying the spread of prohibition in the USA but not in the period I am studying in which is the 1920's. This is because the map only shows the spread of prohibition from 1845-1915, which is 5 years out. It is also not that useful because, it is missing some information, for example it only shows what was happening on the east side of America and only a few parts of the west coast. Another thing that is missing on the map are some states, such as South Dakota, Texas and Florida. The map is not very clear about what prohibition is so it would not be useful to a student who knows nothing about prohibition. There is also a mis-match in dates because the title states, "The spread of prohibition, 1845-1933," and the keys says, "States entirely dry by 1915," this would not help me very much because I am studying prohibition in the 1920's and the map only shows the spread of it up to 1915, which is 5 years out, but I know that prohibition carried on through the 1920's. However the map is useful in some ways, such as it tells us when prohibition began, in 1845 which can tell us that it was popular before I became a law in 1919. Also it can be useful for a student who was looking for some background information on prohibition, for example where it started and in which state/s or areas. ...read more.


But source E was produced after the end of prohibition so this would suggest that the artist of the photo would not have anything to gain by drawing a biased picture. It can be useful for showing what happened in a raid on a "speak easy" but because the artist never saw a raid he can only guess at what would happen in a raid but if he had researched it then maybe he could have based it on a few pictures, then it would make the picture quite useful. Also this picture shows the agents destroying the illegal alcohol, which is completely different to source D where they are just standing by the seized alcohol. I think that source D was produced for show in a magazine or newspaper to show that the government is handling the problem, as I know that there was a big problem with illegal alcohol. So it would have been produced to show the public. But I think that source E has been produced to give a GCSE student a rough idea about a raid or it could be produced to fill space in the textbook or as a cover. In conclusion I think that both pictures are useful in some way, because source D can how corrupt the police were or how the government used propaganda to strengthen their support, and source E shows that a completely different picture although the setting looks familiar. So it can be seen as a contrasting picture. 4. Source F gives very precise information. Does this mean that it must be reliable in evidence about the way that prohibition laws were enforced in the 1920's? ...read more.


Source D is a picture of agents with illegal alcohol after a raid on a speakeasy. It suggests that there was an issue because it was taken probably to show the public that the police and the government were able to handle the problem of illegal alcohol. But because it is the only source that is pro prohibition it may imply that there was corruption. The source suggests that corruption was a big problem because if the agents had made any arrests and convicted anybody, there would have been a decrease in the number of speakeasies around. Also the source is relevant to show how important prohibition was because it was taken in 1920. Source E shows a different picture of a raid on a speakeasy, because it shows the agents smashing the illegal alcohol on the walls and on the street. It is not very relevant because it is only one mans interpretation of the events and I am not sure whether it was about the 1920's. Source F shows how huge the problem was with the amount of arrests but also implies how big the problem of corruption was. It is very relevant because all the arrests are in the 1920's and they are linked to illegal alcohol. Source G was made in 1932 in Hollywood and implies that corruption took over the police force. It shows this because when one guy was arrested for murder he was released almost straight away. But it is not that relevant because it is not about the 1920's and only shows one side of the story. So in conclusion I think that prohibition was a big problem because most of the relevant sources are against prohibition and there is one pro prohibition, so this could imply that there was a problem with prohibition and corruption. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE USA 1919-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE USA 1919-1941 essays

  1. History - Prohibition

    He had a very high profile and was a popular figure in the city. Capone used a mixture of bribery and terror tactics. He was supported by a ruthless gang and once killed two of his own men, suspected of plotting against him, by beating them to death with a baseball bat.

  2. There are many contributing factors to why prohibition was introduced on 16 January 1920. ...

    the large sums of money that drove them to commit crime of these sorts. Although the manufacture, transportation, and sale of alcohol were outlawed, it was never illegal for a person to purchase or consume alcohol. This loophole was exploited and became a very big mistake in how the law was written.

  1. Why was prohibition introduced

    to be repelled because of the social chaos which was reported in the Wickersham report. 3a. WHAT OTHER INDUSTRIES BOOMED IN THE 1920'S AND WHY? During the 1920's many industries boomed in the U.S.A., this was because of tax cuts from the pro-business "Republican" Government.

  2. The USA

    But they opposed Roosevelt in the 1936 election at first place anyway. At first Father Coughlin supported the New Deal; over a short period of time he changed his mind and formed the National Union for Social Justice, saying that the New Deal was not providing social justice.

  1. American History Coursework

    largest of these being the Bank of the US - situated in New York. It has almost 400,000 depositors, all of which found their money gone once the bank failed.

  2. Prohibition. Sources A and B are from the same time period, the 1970s. This ...

    Many historians disagree that prohibition had any good points, however these posters caused families to be reunited. They both were for prohibition and both had similar approaches to show this. Concluding the question. The two sources were both for prohibition and both showed it in guild provoking ways.

  1. History prohibition background info.

    and the Volstead Act (passed October 28, 1919). Prohibition began on January 16, 1920. The 18th amendment was repealed by the Twenty-First Amendment on December 5, 1933. The 18th Amendment is the only amendment to be repealed by another amendment of the Constitution.

  2. History depth study coursework-USA 1919-1945.

    In conclusion, both the posters are for Prohibition and use devices to get the people to vote for Prohibition. They show that the men cannot do anything but go there and waste their money on themselves rather than their wives and children.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work