• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Sources D and E aren't about Haig and the battle of the Somme. How far do you agree that they have no use for the historian studying Haig and the battle of the Somme?

Extracts from this document...


Question 3 Sources D and E aren't about Haig and the battle of the Somme. How far do you agree that they have no use for the historian studying Haig and the battle of the Somme? Source D is a still from the TV series 'Blackadder goes forth' it shows 2 officers discussing an imminent attack on the Germans. This was written years and years after the war. Source E is a cartoon from a British magazine published in February 1917 at the time of the war, so automatically you know that source E is going to be bias source D is going to be bias in some ways as it is a comical and it takes the mick out of one of either the Germans of the English to make people laugh. In the first speech bubble in source D Blackadder says, "my instincts lead me to believe that we are at last about to go over the top." ...read more.


When it says about Haigs drink cabinet being 6 inches closer to Berlin, it is saying that he doesn't have a lot to do with what goes on at the front he just stays with his drinks cabinet at the back. Blackadder was doing 2 things when he said that, firstly he was making it clear to the audience who were watching the show what George meant by what he said before an secondly, he was making it clear about how they felt about it in a way. The whole point of the show 'Blackadder goes forth' is to make people have a picture in their heads of what it was kind of like in the war and to make people laugh. Source D doesn't really have much to with Haig and the battle of the Somme but it would tell the historian studying Haig and the battle of the Somme some things about it, like Haig stayed at the back all of the time, which doesn't help with the studying much. ...read more.


he replies by saying, "the absence of the General, Sir." This cartoon give the basic idea of what it was like in a rehearsal. For example, it explains that the General doesn't get involved with a real attack, and it shows how the men are dressed and organized. Source E would only tell a historian who is studying Haig and the battle of the Somme that the General is absent during an attack which isn't really much use. From the information that I have got, even though both sources aren't really on about Haig and the Somme, the information gives you a very basic idea of how things worked, I would say that source D doesn't give any good information for a historian on the battle of the Somme. Source E shows that the Generals were cowards because they wouldn't fight and they stayed about 20 miles behind the trench. I wouldn't say that either of the sources are very useful to a historian studying Haig and the battle of the Somme. Shannon Phillips ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Britain 1905-1951 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Britain 1905-1951 essays

  1. The Somme - source related study.

    The men's reaction to the treat of being shot by the MP's betrays the fact that they wanted to be there. They had joined up for this. This showed the presence of Zest and Idealism. However from the other sources describing the following day, we know that these "great expectations" would soon be squashed.

  2. The Battle of the Somme

    In total, a million and a half shells would be fired. The attack was planned to last five days. The 1st two would be concentrating on cutting the wire and knocking out the German artillery with shells. For the next three days destruction of the trenches and machine-gun posts was to take place in addition.

  1. Why did the Germans become involved in the Battle of Stalingrad?

    Another major factor in Germany's involvement in the Battle of Stalingrad was Hitler's hatred of communism. Hitler was a facist, he believed, in having one leader with 'all power'. He saw the equal ways of communism as a threat and he felt he needed to destroy this threat as soon as possible.

  2. Dunkirk and the battle of Britain.

    It is quite detailed. "The machine guns cutting through those columns of soldiers like a reaper slicing through corn. This is an eyewitness account of how the Germans seemed in control. This was also made public to show Britain's that they are in war and the dive-bombers might actually hit next time so this time it was a lucky escape.

  1. Field Marshal Haig.

    The bombardment failed to destroy either the barbed wire or the concrete bunkers protecting the German soldiers on the 16-mile front . The British lacked high explosive shells in their arsenal , the Germans remained safe in good defensive positions on high ground for the duration of the bombing .

  2. The Battle of the Somme

    The sight of an approaching cloud of gas was an effective terror weapon in itself, and the effects of the gas were more horrific. Exposure to poison gases caused temporary blindness, severe burns, choking, and sometimes death. It was, however, only an effective weapon if the wind blew in the

  1. These two sources are not about Haig and The Battle of the Somme. How ...

    He is dressed in his cavalry uniform and had a moustache. So they are unmistakeably implying that it's Haig they are talking about. We know that source D is potentially a very reliable source. As the show was filmed in the 1980's then I believe they will have quite accurate sources.

  2. Haig and 'The Battle of the Somme' - source related study.

    Therefore I believe Haig must have been misinformed, as the British front would have been around 15 miles long and as the telephone line had been cut, the limited communications would have caused Haig to miss out on and have very limited information.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work