• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Stalin : Man or monster

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Stalin : Man or Monster? Questions: 1.Do these sources give similar or different impressions of Stalin? All three sources give very different impressions of Stalin. Source A shows Stalin and the results of his policies. The picture shows pyramids of skulls, which represent fear and its emphasis's that Stalin is being held responsible for all these people's death. This was all the people who were against his policies, which suggests that the majority of people who criticized him were killed or sent to labour camps and the reason why some people agreed was because of the fear of being killed or sent to prison. The slogan underneath reads "Visit the pyramids of the USSR". This illustrates that it is as if Stalin is giving a "welcoming" presentation to the public, looking proud of his personal achievement but at the same time showing the severe consequences of anyone opposing his policies. Source B is an official painting of Stalin with workers at a newly opened hydroelectric power station in the 1930's.It shows Stalin of being a pleasant man to be around, the men surrounding him seem happy and comfortable speaking to him. In fact, they are actually that comfortable that they are having a smoke with him. This source seems to be biased as it was painted by an official Soviet which was controlled by Stalin. ...read more.

Middle

This source suggests that the show trials had been planned beforehand meaning that the outcome of the trial had already been decided. Source J is also a cartoon showing Stalin's show trials. It was published in France in the late 1930's. In the courtroom, everything is controlled by Stalin. It shoes him as the judge, the barrister and the whole jury. This suggests that the whole trial was unjust, everything was under Stalin's control and no matter what the defendants would have said, they would have been executed as the outcome had already been decided. The two sources are very similar, they both give out similar messages and agree that the show trials were false and were completely controlled by Stalin. 6.Compare what these two sources say about Stalin. Source L is from a biography of Stalin published in 1983 in Britain. It is saying that Stalin was a very skilled and gifted politician but had a dark side to his nature. Source M is also from a biography of Stalin published in 1974 in Britain. "the explanation of his life is that he was corrupted by power. This statement suggests that Stalin was the way he was because of the effects of power. The source appears to be justifying the actions that Stalin took by saying "The terror was necessary, not only to keep men obedient, but even more to make them believe in him". ...read more.

Conclusion

Source K Stalin was very popular at the time, although he now appears like a monster the soviet public thought very highly of him. Stalin is a figure in history that creates conflicting opinions. Some historians think that he was a very bad politician whereas some think he was a gifted politician. Some think he was a monster and some think he was a hero. The sources give a good example of this as some sources describe Stalin as the greatest man that ever lived and some describe him dictator. The disagreement about Stalin id whether he was a good politician and whether he was a monster. It is difficult to know the whole truth about Stalin as the use of censoring and propaganda in the USSR at the time he was in power means that the reliability of the sources is questionable. Some sources which were published are also likely to be biased especially ones which were written by exiles who will say things against Stalin. In conclusion the sources suggest that the disagreement about Stalin is because of the differing accounts of Stalin's time in power, some portray him as a monster where some show him as the hero of the USSR. Stalin did many evil things but also did many good things for the USSR. He was also very paranoid and felt the need to kill anyone who was a threat to him. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 essays

  1. The Policies of Joseph Stalin 1928 1953

    Source I is an example of the control Stalin had over the Soviet people. He created a cult of personality which masked the truth and showed Stalin as a God-like figure. Though both sources are biased, they give an accurate view of the Show Trials.

  2. China 1945-90 - source based questions.

    Demonstrations in Tiananmen Square took place at the annual Qing Ming Festival. On the surface they were wreath laying ceremonies in honour of Zhou Enlai - a genuinely admired politician. However, the occasion was used to display banners critical of the Gang of Four, and in praise of Deng.

  1. Stalin: Man Or Monster?

    people to be on his side, even when he was already in total control. He also attempted to undermine people he believed to be his enemies so that more people would not choose to follow them. These are the people he refers to as "our leaders" in the sources.

  2. " Stalin was an evil dictator whose rule did nothing to improve Russia".

    Looking at all the sources it is difficult to decide whether Stalin's dictatorship did anything to improve Russia. In Stalin's dictatorship, the area most highlighted was the number of murders throughout his rule. The evil dictator had the right idea (to revolutionise Russia and bring it into the modern world)

  1. How did Stalin control Russia from 1924-1953?

    This is how the cult of personality helped him control Russia, because he brainwashed Russian citizens into believing that Russia would collapse if he were not in power. Stalin also circulated many posters of him and Lenin together. Lenin was seen as the father of the Revolution and (along with Trotsky)

  2. These three sources do not all give the same impression of Stalin. Source A ...

    Russia, but by using the knowledge I have, I know that this couldn't have been the case. Knowing that he was the creator of the purges, how can this source be the truth about him? He needed to make himself look good to the public to cover up his plans and to represent himself after the war.

  1. Stalin Man or Monster

    No where in source B is there an indication that the five year plan cost Russia 127,000 workers and 10 million people. Similarly, no where in source A is there an indication that there might have been a successive aspect of the 5 year plan.

  2. Source A comes from a cartoon published in Paris in the 1930s. It shows ...

    He is trying to say that Stalin is a rash, ruthless and narrow-minded man. Buhkarin did not really like Stalin, so he would not say anything good about him. Source F is more reliable, as it has not been censored.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work