• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Stalin: Man Or Monster?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

MEG GCSE Modern World History Coursework Assignment 2: Depth Study B: Russia, 1905 - 1941 Stalin: Man Or Monster? Question 1 Source A was drawn by one of Stalin's enemies, so it shows Stalin a bad way. It is a mock travel poster showing piles of human skulls and with Stalin inviting you to "Visit the USSR's pyramids" This is a rather macabre and sarcastic caption as the 'pyramids' are pyramids of human skulls. These are meant to show all the millions of people Stalin had caused to be killed. The 'pyramids' have black birds perching them, possibly vultures. These are traditional harbingers of death, and reinforce the image of Stalin as someone responsible for death. Stalin himself appears to be proud of his 'achievements' as we can see from his stance and the expression on his face. Source B was an official Soviet painting and was painted by someone with Stalin's approval. It shows Stalin standing in front of a newly built dam. This is a symbol of soviet achievement and Stalin is show in front of it to associate him with it. He is also shown with ordinary workers to associate him with them and make him seem like a 'friend of the people'. He is also shown as being better dressed than the workers, trying to show that "all men are equal, but some are more equal than others". Both sources show Stalin's power and control. Source A shows how he has power over life and death and source B shows associates him with the power and success of the dam construction project. The sources are different in that source B is supporting Stalin and his use of power and source A is saying he has abused his power. The points the two sources are trying to make are the opposite of each other. Stalin is also made to look more ugly in source A, to make the reader not like him. ...read more.

Middle

This is a very simplistic cartoon with only one main point. This is again showing how Stalin as acting as "Judge, Jury and Executioner". There is no chance of a fair trial as Stalin is deciding what is happening. Also the way Stalin is writing the transcript of the trial might be showing how Stalin liked to 'change the past' to make himself sound better. The cartoons are similar in that they both agree that Stalin had control over the show trials and they weren't really proper trials at all. They both show Stalin as the only person with any power in the courtroom. The two sources differ in that source J is only showing that Stalin is the only person in control in the courtroom whereas source I shows more details such as the way the accused admitted their guilt even when they weren't guilty and the gallows in the background showing how Stalin had already made up his mind. However this is not a very significant difference, they still both agree fundamentally that the show trials were not real trials at all and were controlled by Stalin. Question 5 In order to decide whether Stalin was a man or a monster I first need to define what I mean by monster. Once I have done that I can start to look at the information I have to decide whether he was a man or a monster. I would define a monster as someone with a lack of compassion and as someone who performs inhuman or immoral acts on a large scale without understanding how he or she is hurting people or without remorse for the suffering they have caused. However it could be argued that the things Stalin accomplished justified his inhuman actions. Did the ends really justify the means? I will look at sources and my own knowledge to decide. Firstly I will see if I can find evidence that Stalin was a monster. ...read more.

Conclusion

This is either a fake photo or he has carefully selected who he is photographed with from people loyal to him. Either way this is propaganda designed to associate Stalin with the women and make him seem like a man of the people. A historian, reading source D, might know that Stalin was exiled to Siberia and thus know that at least part of the source is true. However it seems hard to believe that the Stalin who ordered he deaths of millions really was so upset over one death (although as he said "One death is a tragedy, a million is just a statistic"). This source seems to have been written by Stalin to make himself sound better. But can we be sure? There's no real reason why the story could not be true and Stalin had changed over time. It is impossible to know for sure as there are no other records to cross-reference it with. Sources E and F are again sources that present opposing views of Stalin. Both of them use very emotive language and are clearly strong personal opinions. This is another factor that makes it difficult for historians to extract the truth from a given statement. Another problem is that these are both personal experiences, what Stalin may have seemed like to one person may be totally different to the way he appeared to someone else and no-one knew exactly what Stalin was like. Sources K, L and M all present a different view of Stalin. These are three viewpoints presented by historians and they all disagree. This is because they have all looked at different evidence and drawn their own conclusions. There may also be bias because of what the historian himself believes. For example source K was written in the USSR when Stalin was still alive so the writer may have been afraid to criticise him. So in conclusion the main problem is that historians have to judge sources that have been distorted by time and propaganda and avoid personal bias. That is why there have been disagreements. Because of that. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 essays

  1. How did Stalin control Russia from 1924-1953?

    Many huge dams were constructed to provide hydroelectric power, and many quarries and mines were also made. There were three Five Year Plans. The first ran from 1928-1932, and was focused on building up heavy industry like coal, steel, railways, electricity and machinery.

  2. 'The Five Year Plans brought glory to Stalin and misery to his people.' How ...

    Collectivisation consisted of grouping small, scattered farms in a given locality into a collective farm (Kolkhozy). The peasants would hand over their grain, animals, tools and labour for the utility of the entire community. The collectives had to sell most of their produce at low prices to the government.

  1. How did the rule of Stalin affect the Soviet Union?

    In its congress in 1934, Zhdanov told the members to only create Socialist Realism art. These were paintings, poems, plays and novels about ordinary people and about working lives.

  2. "Stalin was personally responsible for the Purges in Russia in the 1930s". Agree or ...

    Moreover, Lenin had handled opposition within the Party during his regime, as he made a decree on 'factionalism' to prevent party splits, which Stalin intended to achieve from the purges. I have considered a wide range of reasons which agree or disagree with the statement.

  1. 'The Five Year Plans brought glory to Stalin and misery to his people' - ...

    He set targets for the Russian industry to be fully capable of producing modern armaments so that Russia could defend herself from foreign attacks. Looking back at the idea of his aim of personal glorification, it is evident that the phrase "Stalin is the Lenin of today" had become a

  2. Assess the Impact Stalin Had On Russia and Its People Stalin came to ...

    GCSE Modern World History - Ben Walsh - Pg.134 The third period was between 1937 and 1941. By 1937, the purges had plunged the population of the Soviet Union into a state of terror. Everyone feared to be arrested by the NKVD (secret police), tortured, being executed or being put into Gulags (labour camps).

  1. History - USSR - The main reason for the February/March Revolution was The World ...

    The Tsar had still not delivered any of his other promises mentioned in the manifesto and it was clear that he was not prepared to do so. The people of Russia were now very disappointed in the Tsar. By this point, Rasputin had entered the picture.

  2. Russia 1905-1945 Stalin - man or monster - source based questions

    tell us how was Stalin in real life, however, we can construct in our minds an imige of what would Stalin do, in order to obtain what he wanted, this Source lacks of objetivity therefore can be classified as being biased.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work