• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Studying sources F, G, H and I and using my own knowledge I will show why there was so much controversy over the workhouse system in the 1830's and 1840's.

Extracts from this document...


Studying sources F, G, H and I and using my own knowledge I will show why there was so much controversy over the workhouse system in the 1830's and 1840's. In this essay I will be studying sources F, G, H and I and using my own knowledge to show why there was so much controversy over the workhouse system, in the 1830's and 1840's. Now that there was no outdoor relief paupers had to go into the workhouses, like Gressenhall. The workhouse clothed and fed the paupers. The paupers were treated unfairly and lost their liberty and freedom. Due to these conditions many people had different opinions about the system, whether for or against, and this caused a lot of controversy. Firstly source F " The rights of the Poor to Liberty and life" written by Richard Oastler in 1836. Richard Oastler was a Yorkshire writer and a member of the anti- poor Law campaign. This source is against the workhouse system. The evidence for this is in the first sentence stating "hellish poor law bastilles." This word "Bastilles" is French for prisons. This shows that the writer thinks the paupers were kept in and treated like they were in a prison, like criminals. Also an additional few words keeping this view with being against the workhouse system are: "my wife torn from me, because I am poor, I will burn the whole pile to the ground.' ...read more.


This source also tells us 'the aged, infirm & sick continue to receive outdoor relief, and in some cases the amount they receive has increased.' By linking this statement and the last, this tells us that the writer believes that only the deserving poor should get the outdoor relief. This system of relief allowed the poor to remain in their own homes. As attitudes changed, the poor were often viewed as idle, and it was believed that employers paid deliberately low wages knowing that the parish or Union would make them up. It was felt that expenditure on outdoor relief was too high and under the New Poor Law changes were made which almost abolished this system of relief. Additional evidence that this source is supporting the workhouse system is that it says,' one of the main advantages of placing destitute families in the workhouse in that the children are educated.' This shows that the writer believes that putting poor families into the workhouses also help their children by giving them an education. The educational policy of the workhouse was summed up by the master of the Ennistymon workhouse in his report to the guardians on the 14th June 1844 ". The aim is, children to be useful and respectable members of society, the course of education such as that will require is not limited to reading, writing and arithmetic, but it likewise comprises careful moral and religious instruction as well as training in habits of industry. ...read more.


Bone crushing became the focus of a case, which was reported extensively by The Times and was followed avidly by the public Edwin Chadwick emerged particularly well and reached the height of his prestige and power at this time. Andover was only the most notorious example of workhouse cruelty. There were several other major scandals and incidents, all recorded by the press in minute detail. Inflicted cruel punishments on those under his rule. Some inmates were forced to spend the night in the workhouse mortuary as a punishment. The report of the select committee found that the workhouse master was unfit. He was forced to resign. The Andover scandal was an extreme example of how workhouse system could produce horrific results. This case was unforgivable but was untypical. Many of the other alleged bad workhouses were other exaggerated. For this evidence I have found I conclude or that in my opinion that the workhouse was not a very nice place to be in. Also I can see why there was so much controversy over the workhouse system. I think that the workhouse was good in the sense that the children got a good education for the future, and taught the basic skills they would need. On the other hand, for the adult paupers life was poor, due to the living and working condition. Although there are reasons for both, supporting and being against the workhouses, I think that the reasons to be against the workhouse system outweighs the reasons for supporting it. Claire Lewis 11l ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE History Projects section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE History Projects essays

  1. Research Topic: Health Welfare of elderly in Shanghai

    The welfare scheme was one of the biggest and covered largest proportions. It had achieved best results. This nation-wide welfare scheme for the shanghai elderly was initiated in 2001 by the Ministry of Civil Affairs. It has resulted in an overall improvement in local welfare facilities.

  2. Boy in the Striped Pyjamas Review

    Moreover, such defences were far more superior and any contact with the outside world was not only prohibited but impossible to gain. Additionally, the F�hrer is far too vulnerable as a controversial leader to willingly attend a house meeting in this time of delicacy and the astonishing lack of security

  1. From the sources and your studies explain the origins and development of Watford Union ...

    paupers and their families only receive relief if they're prepared to enter the workhouse and workhouses should be more strict and in bad conditions so only people who had nowhere else to go, would go here as a last resort.

  2. Public Transport: How Did It Develop Between 1830 and 1930?

    The next big step was to electric trains, North Eastern Railway (NER) cracked all the speed records with a 90mph train in 1904. This was short-lived, however. Coal was still a much easier and cheaper way to power the trains, so NER soon reverted back to steam engines.

  1. How similar are the messages of sources F & G

    Due to the oppressive nature of the Nazis and the fact that any Jew sympathy provoked outrage from the Nazis shows they couldn't have done anything to stop the Nazis or speak out against them because of their fear of the government.

  2. How useful are the sources A-I to a historian studying the main causes and ...

    This source is quite useful in explaining the causes and events of Tiananmen Square. Source G, an extract from the book The Truth about the Beijing Turmoil was written in 1989 published in the People's Republic of China. This source reports that no one at Tiananmen Square was killed and gives the background to why the soldiers were sent.

  1. Why is John F Kennedy such a famous and controversial figure in history?

    This I believe led to Kennedy's assassination. These ideas in themselves were bound to cause a stir among the conservative dominated congress, but none so much as when he dared to tackle the issue of civil rights for African-Americans, specifically in the southern states.

  2. History of Grenada (How to write a short IGCSE essay: Plan, Evaluation of Sources, ...

    Since Grenada is so big on spices their country slogan is The Spice of the Caribbean. Grenada also make their own chocolate and export cocoa beans to the rest of the world. Grenadas flag as we know it today has 7 stars representing the 7 regions of Grenada and the nutmeg in the middle representing the export of nutmeg.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work