• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Beer Hall Putsch

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

The Beer Hall Putsch Coursework 1) Source A, which is an eyewitness account of events in the burgerbraukeller on 8th November 1923; note this man was a member of the nazi party but left in 1930. This tells us that Hitler was in control over all the people inside, and also that they were scared of him. You learn that people are excited, or at any rate, confused, when Hitler enters, shown by the huge uproar. We learn that Hitler had lots of protection with the steel-helmeted men and his heavily armed bodyguard. I think this passage shows what respect and control Hitler had over people. Hitler lead with aggression, firing revolver shots at the ceiling to demand silence and also 'elbowing his way through the crowd', he was a very powerful man. 2) A) Source B looks like a cool, calm, orderly meeting, with Hitler talking to a group of settled, attentive people. Everyone is seated and Hitler seems to have no big aggressive bodyguards. Source A on the other hands gives the impression of a big brawl of people all shouting, screaming and pushing around. Hitler appears to be guarded, armed and aggressive. In source A it seems as if he is trying to scare people, whilst in Source B he looks as if he I just talking to people and trying amicably to get across his point. B) ...read more.

Middle

The fact that it includes the quote of what he apparently said, makes it obvious that the source is strongly trying to influence you and make you think of Hitler in a good way. This is probably because it was written in 1934, and by the Nazi party. Hitler was still in great power at this time, and anyone saying a bad word about Hitler was usually killed, which would definitely influence the author. Sources G and H disagree with this representation of Hitler. Source G suggests he wasn't even planning to participate in the march, as he wanted to flee the country. It makes Hitler out to be cowardly. It suggests that he "Flung himself to the ground", and says that even after the march, it still, "did not prevent him from running", none of this is meant to make you look at Hitler in a good light. As it was published outside Germany, the author could be much more honest than the author of Source F. Source H is trying to stay unbiased, as it's written by a historian, and he is trying to stick to the facts. But all sources are slightly biased, and this one still says that Hitler shouted "Surrender", which could be interpreted as him being cowardly. ...read more.

Conclusion

I know this didn't happen, and the whole plan failed. Source E is very much in agreement with the statement, and he seems to say that he considers most men at that time in his position were very impressionable, and that Hitler's speeches mesmerised people, and turned them to his cause. This would suggest that the events did increase their influence. Source F suggests that Hitler was a courageous and amazing man, but doesn't really say much about how big a political impact it had. Source G suggests that the events didn't have much of an impact, as Hitler was planning on fleeing even after the events of the 8th, although, this source is probably not very reliable, as it was written by a member of an opposing party at the time. Source H is like source F in the sense that, it doesn't really agree or disagree with the statement, its pretty fair in its judgements, and is mainly just talking about the events, not their effects. Sources I and J are both from Hitler's trial, which I know Hitler used greatly to his advantage in publishing the beliefs of the Nazi party, and had a big impact on the influence of Hitler. Source K shows that 1 big effect of the Munich Putsch was to encourage Hitler to try and gain power through legal methods, as he finally realised, forced power wouldn't get him to high power. I know this approach eventually worked much better for him. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Germany 1918-1939 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Germany 1918-1939 essays

  1. Munich Putsch 1923 - Sources Questions

    The boy was still killed. Nazis usually tell this version. That day Hitler and Ludendorff were both arrested and put on trial. The Munich Putsch was over. Hitler was charged with high treason and the trial consisted for 24 days.

  2. The Beer Hall Putsch Sources Questions

    the rest of Munich and some of the figures in the bill may have been changed so that the bar owner could have got more money. Also even though it shows what they damaged and how rowdy the place must have been all the things that that were consumed may

  1. adolf hitler

    Jewish domination of Russia will also be the end of Russia as a state." To achieve this expansion in the East and to win back land lost during the First World War, Hitler claimed that it might be necessary to form an alliance with Britain and Italy.

  2. The Munich Putsch 1923 - source related study.

    Opinions are not capable of being true; an opinion cannot be used as proof. The example of an opinion from source C I have chosen is "at no point did he behave heroically". The reason I chose this is because whether a person is a hero or not depends on how a person thinks and feels.

  1. The Beer Hall Putsch Sources Questions

    Source A is an eyewitness report by an ex member of the nazi party who left Germany in the 1930s. Whereas source B is a 1923 painting of a reconstruction of the events that took place in Burgerbraukeller on 8th November and it is from a nazi artist's point of view.

  2. Beer Hall Putsch Sources Coursework

    If they had not singed the Treaty of Versailles, would Hitler have persecuted the Jews and Marxists while still being in power? Would he have strived to become a 'God-like' person? The answer to these questions can only be answered with hindsight.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work