• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Beer Hall Putsch Sources Questions

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

THE BEER HALL PUTSCH COURSEWORK ASSIGNMENT 2 1.source A is an eyewitness account of the events in the Burgerbrauller on the evening of 8 November 1923. It tells us that at 8:30 in the evening the doors were flung open and steel helmeted men burst through, pushing Maxim guns into the hall. Then Hitler with his revolve went through the crowd and with two shots he demanded quiet and in an instant the silence was absolute. This shows that at the meeting after great calamity Hitler strode through the crowd and got immediate control after his shots, as they wanted to hear what he had to say also this shows us that it was easy for the Nazis to gain control. 2a. Source B is in complete contrast to source A in that source B shows a calm atmosphere with everyone intently listening to Hitler and there is no sign that there is no sign that there had been an uproar as everything seems to be in order in the hall with only one S.A. member in the hall. However in source A describes a completely different atmosphere, as when the many S.A. members stormed the hall there was a big melee with the door being smashed down. ...read more.

Middle

This agrees with source G in that there was a march and that they all linked arms. However source G disagrees in that it says that at the first shot Hitler flung himself to the ground where he sprained his arm and then he fled to the mountains. Source H disagrees with source G in that the march was at 11 o'clock and not 12. However the British historian is very objective on if Hitler behaved in a cowardly manner as he suggests that he could have been dragged to the ground or dropped to the ground like an experienced soldier at the sound of fire but the author does not go for one option. Overall I think that source H is the most reliable as it was published in 1970 so the author had time to balance up his evidence and he was not writing for any bias unlike F which was propaganda for the nazis and G that was written by an anti nazi. 5. Source I is a picture of Hitler with Ludendoff. In this picture Hitler is trying to show that he is a great man as he is a friend with the World War 1 hero Lundendoff and also to get more fame across Germany as with this picture being in the newspapers he would get the message of Nazism across Germany. ...read more.

Conclusion

Source E agrees slightly with this as from the speech in the hall it made him join the party but it does not show the impact on Germany and he left the partying 1936. Source F agrees this slightly as the biography would not have been written unless this had an impact on the rest of Germany but it does not show how this impacted Germany. Source G disagrees with this as the book was written as Hitler the pawn which shows that in the SDP the event was not accepted and that he was a coward in it. Source I agrees slightly as from this event it caused the trial that had newspaper coverage that was taken all over Germany but it does not show how this increased the influence of Hitler. Source K disagrees with this as form this Hitler knew that he had to change his tact if he was going to take over Germany and so he would have to take over Germany using politics. From my own knowledge I know that the change in tactics had more of an affect to show the influence as form this they put members in all the different parts of the country and the main thing that influenced the word of Hitler to get across Germany was the wall street crash of 1928 which caused the loans to be recalled and mass unemployment and hyper-inflation. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Germany 1918-1939 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Germany 1918-1939 essays

  1. Holocaust Sources Questions

    everyone "she dismissed all the whispers of atrocities as stupid, malicious gossip" Source G is the memories of Ines lyss who lived in Hamburg again written after the event so you have to be sceptical of what is said. Lyss says that in her older years she doubts what she

  2. IGCSE History Coursework Assignment B - Source Analysis of the Reichstag Fire

    However, common people don't think the fact that the Nazis could've used Lubbe as part of their plan. This also applies to many of the sources given. There aren't dependable proofs to prove that a source is accurate. It is the historian's decision to look at the provenance and to decide whether or not the source is accurate.

  1. GCSE Coursework Assignment 2

    that Hitler thought that Kristallnacht shouldn't have happened and that people responsible ruined any chance for peace with France, and this implies that Hitler was not to blame. So this does not say who was responsible but there is a chance some information was left out.

  2. Why Did Kristallnacht Take Place? (a) A ...

    Source G is another cartoon about Kristallnacht, published in a British magazine on 30 November 1938. As it wasn't drawn after the war, the artist obviously acted on an immediate response-, which makes it seem more reliable. The general sense of the image is that there is a very clear

  1. The Munich Putsch 1923 - source related study.

    Firstly he would need to find witnesses because witnesses are a very reliable source of Information. Because John Toland's written piece of information was published in 1976 It would be hard for him to find witnesses since most would be dead (humans live for about fifty to sixty years).

  2. The Beer Hall Putsch

    It also does not give off a very good impression of the Nazi party with 148 sets of cutlery stolen. Source D does not really help understand what went on inside because it only gives us what Hitler did/said and not what was going on inside or how the crowd reacted!

  1. Beer Hall Putsch Sources Coursework

    If they had not singed the Treaty of Versailles, would Hitler have persecuted the Jews and Marxists while still being in power? Would he have strived to become a 'God-like' person? The answer to these questions can only be answered with hindsight.

  2. Kristallnacht Sources Questions

    the truth about what happened because Germany was no longer oppressed by the tyranny of the Nazi's. It tells us that Goebbels was the instigator who planned that attacks to impress Hitler because he needed to get back in favour.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work