Page
  1. 1
    1
  2. 2
    2
  3. 3
    3
  4. 4
    4
  5. 5
    5
  • Level: GCSE
  • Subject: History
  • Essay length: 2030 words

The events that occurred in Derry on the 30th January 1972 became known as 'Bloody Sunday'. Why have these events produced such different historical interpretations?

Extracts from this essay...

Introduction

Victoria Harmer The events that occurred in Derry on the 30th January 1972 became known as 'Bloody Sunday'. Why have these events produced such different historical interpretations? In this essay I am going to try to explain what happened after 'Bloody Sunday' and why there are such different interpretations of the event. I am going to look at 4 different sources; 2 newspaper reports, an ITN news report and also a video of a BBC documentary. I will also use my own knowledge to interpret the sources. After the event an enquiry known as the, 'Widgery Report' came to a verdict that the army was not to blame for what happened where as Nationalists see the verdict as wrong and believe this is a reason which has stopped independence in Ulster. On the 29th January 1998 the Prime Minister Tony Blair ordered another enquiry into 'Bloody Sunday' which is still on going to the present day and is the 'Saville Report'. The troubles in Ulster had hit an all time high in 1969 and after that marches and parades were usually an excuse for violence and rioting between Catholics and Protestants.

Middle

The source explains that unlike the Widgery report new evidence has come forward to support that of the 14 people killed they had not been handling weapons which is why the British paratrooper's claim they had to shoot to protect themselves, it is something civilian witnesses have always said. The article also mentions that the Widgery Report states that Barnley McGuigan was shot through the back of the head by a 'dum-dum' bullet. This is a bullet which explodes on impact and once hit with there is little chance of survival, these are illegal under the Geneva Convention and therefore must have been from the IRA. But new evidence in the Saville report from John Martin, a forensic scientist, who carried out the original tests now says developments show the same findings could now be explained by contamination and there could no longer be a 'strong suspicion' that any of the victims held or were near weapons. Overall I think this source is very much in favour of the Saville Report, the sub-heading, "This backs up what we have been saying all these years: the victims were innocent", in my opinion proves this.

Conclusion

They signed what was known as the Downing Street declaration which started the peace talks. Ian Paisley a strong Unionists wasn't happy about what was happening and quoted, "Sold out Ulster to buy off fiendish republican scum". Again after a few years labour came to power and Tony Blair was Prime Minister in May 1997. After peace talks on the 10th April 1998 the 'Good Friday Agreement' was signed. Then finally after years of waiting, Nationalists hear the news that on the 29th January 1998 Tony Blair orders another inquiry into Bloody Sunday. I think these events will affect the sources I have looked at because after the Brighton bombing feelings towards Nationalists may have been hatred because of the plot which was believed to be the IRA. Also things which may have happened in Northern Ireland may have been asked by the government to keep quiet as peace talks were been discussed therefore the sources may be limited. Overall I think Northern Ireland will never be peaceful there will always be one debate or another and Bloody Sunday is one which wont be forgotten. The outcome of the Saville Report may help to determine whether Northern Ireland will become independent.

The above preview is unformatted text

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • Over 150,000 essays available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Over 180,000 student essays
  • Every subject and level covered
  • Thousands of essays marked by teachers

Related GCSE Northern Ireland 1965-85

  1. What was the impact of Bloody Sunday?

    and this group was always gaining new members so the terrorist activity increased. For example in 1973, two provisional car bombs exploded in London and 195 people were taken to hospital! The Violence even worked its way to Britain as shown in this source: "An IRA bomb in a Guildford pub killed five people and injured six.

  2. The Gunpowder Plot.

    Monteagle immediately had the letter seen by Robert Cecil, the Earl of Salisbury, and Secretary of State. Reaction was very slow, but the vaults beneath the House of Lords were searched on 4th November; first by the Earl of Suffolk, finding nothing evident towards the letter; and later the same evening by Sir Thomas Kynvett.

  1. Northern Ireland - The Good Friday Agreement was created in April 1998, and then ...

    as it helped James 'plant' his supporters in Ireland following 90 leading Ulster landowners fleeing due to the defeat of the Earl of Tyrone's rebellion. It was then towards the end of Elizabeth's reign that there was another rebellion in Ireland that was supported by the Spanish.

  2. Bloody Sunday and the Conflict in Ireland

    Bloody Sunday has had a huge impact on modern N.Ireland. The Failure of Power sharing was one of these. The idea was that if both Protestants and Catholics had equal power, then neither could complain that they weren't being heard, but there were problems.

  1. Northern Ireland - Bloody Sunday.

    On Good Friday 1998, Tony Blair announced a new settlement that was accepted by all the major groups. The plan is to create a new assembly that will take over the running of some government departments like agriculture and education.

  2. Biran Friel, Making History, Historical Background

    In resisting this advance, O'Neill managed to rally other Irish septs who were dissatisfied with English government and those Catholics who opposed the spread of Protestantism in Ireland. *The Pale - Area marked on map iii)

  1. Bloody Sunday - How useful are sources A,B,C and D to someone trying to ...

    Explain your answer using all the sources and your own knowledge. I think that it is possible to build up an accurate picture about what actually happened on 30th of January 1972 from all the sources. Sources A - D are all based upon subjective opinions for example 'A' makes

  2. What happened on Bloody Sunday?

    Bogside The Bogside is a Catholic area of Derry. It became a place were poverty and unemployment went unchecked. The local poet Seamus Deane once wrote: "Bogside was once a street. Now it's a condition". In the summer of 1969, a three-day battle with the police became so violent that the British Labour government sent in troops to restore order in this estate.

  • Over 180,000 essays
    written by students
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to write
    your own great essays

Marked by a teacher

This essay has been marked by one of our great teachers. You can read the full teachers notes when you download the essay.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review on the essay page.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review under the essay preview on this page.