• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'The First World War was the most important cause of the Russian Revolution.' How true is the claim?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

14) 'The First World War was the most important cause of the Russian Revolution.' How true is the claim? (GCE June 2003) With regard to the question, there are two schools of thought that we ought to consider. The first being the pessimist school of thought, which states that World War I (WWI) was a catalyst that sped up the failure of the Tsarist regime, and the second being the optimist school of thought, which is in line with the liberal school of thought, stating that the Tsarist regime would have survived if not for WWI. However, I would agree with the pessimist school of thought, and believe that while WWI was not the most important cause of the Russian Revolution, it was certainly one of the most crucial causes as it was the catalyst that accelerated the process of the failure of the Tsarist regime. Together with WWI came many adverse effects economically and militarily; WWI also caused the loss of prestige of the Tsarist government, proving that the autocratic ruler of Russia was indeed an incompetent Tsar. All of this together with the previous inabilities of the Tsarist government such as the lack and failure to reform culminated in the Russian Revolution of 1917 and the eventual fall of the Tsarism. ...read more.

Middle

to place much trust in Rasputin who was became the uncrowned king of Russia for a time, merely because he was able to exercise some healing power over her son Alexei. His place at court discredited both the monarchy and the Church, and was very much a grievance which Russians nursed against the Romanovs. However, other events and factors besides the war led to a loss of prestige. Governments are largely reliant on prestige and in the case of Russia; the Tsarist regime had basically lost its prestige mainly due to defeats in the Russo-Japanese war as well as the Bloody Sunday incident. When Russia went to war with Japan in 1904, there were many humiliating defeats as the war added to the unrest within Russia. Things worsened on Bloody Sunday in January 1905 when Father Gapon led a vast crowd of about 200 000 to the Winter Palace. It was a peaceful demonstration to deliver a petition to the Tsar for reforms but officials and palace guards panicked, and opened fire killing a vast number of innocent people. Apart from the effects of WWI itself, another important factor would be the lack of reforms. ...read more.

Conclusion

The million or so personal servants received no land and they either continued to work for wages or drifted to the towns in search of work in industry. The vast demand for factory production of war supplies and workers caused many more labor riots and strikes. In addition, because more factory workers were needed, peasants moved out of the country and into the cities, which soon became overpopulated, and living conditions rapidly grew worse. Furthermore, as more food was needed for the soldiers, the food supply behind the front grew scarce. By 1917, famine threatened many of the larger cities. This further motivated the Revolution. Hence, while WWI was a crucial cause of the 1917 revolution, other causes include events that led to the loss of prestige. WWI simply accelerated the process of the Russian Revolution that was to ultimately take place in 1917. Furthermore, since the approach to this question is based on the pessimist school of thought, it would be fair to consider that regardless of such events, the Russian Revolution that led to the eventual fall of Tsarism would happen anyway, since the Marxist view is that the autocracy will eventually be replaced by the aristocracy, the bourgeosis and eventually, the proletariat. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 essays

  1. To what extent was the First World War a cause of the Russian Revolution?

    In September 1915, when the Tsar took control of the Russian Army from his uncle Grand Duke Nicholas - even though the Tsar had no experience in battlefield warfare - he tried to lead Russia into victory. However, the German opposition, the best army at the time in the world,

  2. What were the causes of the Russian Revolution in March 1917?

    Railway workers refused to let his train into the city. In the train, on 15 March, the Tsar finally made his mind to abdicate. However, he still did not get the idea of no royal family ruling and decided to abdicate in favour of his brother Michael.

  1. Why did the Tsarist regime fall in 1917?

    This shows that it was the Tsar's attitude that was to blame for Russia's problems and not the situation (as suggested in source C). Sources C and D agree about some things and disagree about others. They agree that Tsar Nicholas II was not well suited to power and that he was intelligent, not stupid.

  2. Source based questions on the Russian revolutions.

    Also, source J doesn't not tell us or confirm that the family was killed in Ipatiev house, as sources C, D, E and I claim they were. This leaves the argument open to discussion. They could have been killed in the house, on the spot in the road or on their journey etc...

  1. 'THE TSARIST REGIME WAS SECURE BY 1905'

    These were unpopular as men were the providers for their families, so their families would also suffer because of their absence. Although the Tsars of Russia ruled autocratically and no political parties were allowed to exist, this did not mean that there was no organised opposition to their rule.

  2. How did living conditions change in towns as a result of the Industrial Revolution ...

    The acts taken were one giant step in the progress and benefits that the Revolution produced during the mid years onwards . The beneficial developments from the Industrial Revolution had mostly been in relation to technology and the way that it improved industry and the economy .

  1. Both Russian Revolutions stemmed from Russians' dissatisfaction with the Tsarist government's ineptitude

    In fact a large part of the petition presented to the Tsar on the infamous "Bloody Sunday" had to do with better working conditions and minimum wage for workers. The intelligentsia was discontent as well, finding the government ineffective and inefficient and clamored for reform.

  2. How far were things improving in Russia before the First World War?

    The aristocracyâs main fear would have been a revolt of the peasants, of which they relied on to live the privileged lifestyles. Due to increased pressure from many strikes my workers, peasants, the middle-class and some of the Aristocracy, the Tsar created a Duma (parliament).

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work