• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"The Indian National Congress had, in the first twenty years of its existence, been a dismal failure." Evaluate this assessment in light of the INC's objectives, and discuss reasons for its failure and/ or success.

Extracts from this document...


YR 1 HARI QUES: - "The Indian National Congress had, in the first twenty years of its existence, been a dismal failure." Evaluate this assessment in light of the INC's objectives, and discuss reasons for its failure and/ or success. ANS: - The Indian National Congress (INC) was formed in 1885. It comprised primarily of rich Indians whose main aim was putting forward their complains to the British. In order to answer the question as fully as possible I will examine a few of The INC'S objectives and see whether they were successful or not in light of the events that took place during the period 1885- 1905. I will then on the basis of the evidence I present evaluate whether The INC was a failure in its first twenty years. The INC initially was comprised of about 85 people. One of its aims was to have Indians "get to know each other better". ...read more.


The INC saw itself as a base to discuss problems around India and solve them by presenting them to the British, who they hoped would solve these problems. Looking back at this aim we can see that it was truly a "dismal failure" as the British did nothing to help solve these problems. The British viewed The INC as a "body" (not even a party) that would help keep the "government in touch with public opinion." Indians would pay the British government money. This money paid by Indians would be used by the British to fund their army or be used as pensions for retired army officers. The INC wanted to stop this "leakage" which was known as "home- charges". As a result of these home charges the Indian economy further suffered. In truth the Indian government were paying for British retired officers. These home charges did not stop during the first twenty years of The INC. ...read more.


The INC from the start never managed to capture the imagination of the people of India, as many men disliked the idea. The party was never secular, as Hindu festivals were celebrated. This particular factor obviously created a sense of isolation amongst Muslims (in particular)- and as a result no real unity was ever formed. The INC did not always reflect the views of people. Some of the problems/ prepositions put forward to the British were aimed to benefit the wealthy instead of the poor. The INC wanted the British to change certain policies of theirs- such as the "home charges" and less money spent on the British military. The British did not change these policies and as a result the Indian population suffered and as a result The INC could not move forward. However, though The INC was a failure during its first twenty years what it did do was sow the seeds for a revolution that would take place later. The first twenty years established for the masses a group that could be supported as a way of fighting the British. ................................................................................ ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE History Projects section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE History Projects essays

  1. With what success has the Britain government tried to deal with the Irish Troubles ...

    on May the 28th power sharing was forced to come to an end. The British Government were made to go back to Direct Rule and the Protestants were extremely happy. I believed that this reaction showed how little the politicians in Britain new about the situations going on in Ireland as this reaction would mean more fighting from the Nationalists.

  2. What were the causes of Indian Independencein 1947, and was partition inevitable?

    It also made the British appear as more stubborn and unwilling to change, making the Indians feel that nationalism and pushing for independence themselves was the best way to gain dominion or independent status. Because of this, the 1919 Montford reforms were actually very important; they were the first major

  1. Just like previous attempts to bring peace to Northern Ireland, the Good Friday Agreement ...

    development because The Real Ira were believed to be the plotters of Omagh bomb so they announced a ceasefire after the Omagh bomb is a massive development. Also another development on 22.8.1998 where another splinter group INLA announced ceasefire however the Continuity IRA did not ceasefire and they carried on doing bombings.

  2. Evacuation was a success

    Student Number Year Group Years Months Gender Height (m) Weight (kg) Body Mass Index (BMI) 4 7 12 2 Female 1.61 45 17.4 7 7 12 7 Female 1.65 45 16.5 51 7 12 1 Female 1.56 43 17.7 63 7 12 11 Female 1.41 40 20.1 104 7 11 11 Female 1.48 37 16.9 119 7 12 2

  1. On balance the league of nations proved to be a failure in the 1920(TM)s. ...

    The League dealt very effectively with smaller nations, and showed this during the Greek and Bulgaria dispute. The border between Greece and Bulgaria had become source of tension over the years. After a series of violent incidents, Greeks invaded Bulgaria in October 1925.

  2. Free essay

    History Assessment

    I feel that this was extremely ill-mannered and chauvinistic. However, Jesse Owens carried on going even though there was a lot of prejudice. Another example, I noticed, was that he wasn't allowed on the front of the bus and had to go through the back door or he couldn't go

  1. Critical assessment of the last days of the Tsar

    The Tsar had the absolute power, meaning that he had to take all the decisions, as Russia had no Parliament. By 1917, as a cause of national distress caused by the First World War, hunger, unemployment and many other reasons, the Russian nation looked forward to a change in their country.

  2. Why did a campaign for womens suffrage develop in the years after 1870?

    The election held in 1865 is the first historically recognised push for women's suffrage; John Stuart Mill used women's suffrage as part of his election address. The following year Mill presented a petition in favour of women's rights, and despite that petition being unsuccessful, suffrage committees soon formed.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work