• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"The Tsarist regime collapsed in 1917 due to its failure in the First World War" How far do you agree with this statement?

Extracts from this document...


"The Tsarist regime collapsed in 1917 due to its failure in the First World War" How far do you agree with this statement? There are two views on this, the first one says that the Tsarist regime was doomed from the start with the increasing strikes, poor conditions for the majority of the population and that the war only speeded up the process but did not cause it. The second view is that the Tsarist regime was basically stable up to 1914 despite the problems as it was slowly making progress to becoming a modern state, but the war stopped it dead in its tracks. The first view says that from the beginning of his reign the Tsar said himself that he knew nothing of how to rule an empire so large. From the chaos of Bloody Sunday the Tsar had a chance to reform his ways and share out his power in the Duma. However it soon became obvious that the Tsar still believed that he should own all the power. ...read more.


To make matters worse when the Tsar left to take control in the front line he left the Tsarina in charge. She was an even worse ruler than the Tsar and was disliked because she was German. Even worse she was influenced by a peasant from Siberia called Rasputin who helped her son survive haemophilia. Rasputin dismissed well abled ministers and replaced them with his friends messing Russia's condition up even more. After the Tsar left Rasputin became even more unpopular as rumours of him having affairs circulated. The second view is that the war brought the collapse of the Tsarist regime. This is said because at the outbreak of war millions of peasants trying to get out of their normal job go and join the army creating a shortage of labourers on the land. This caused food prices to rise but the wages kept the same and other materials like armaments were in shortage for both troops and civilians. The Tsar still refused to listen to the Duma at the time about the formation of a "Government of the Public Confidence" The shortage in materials meant that even more people went to the already overcrowded towns and cities to work in the factories. ...read more.


Rasputin who helped her son survive haemophilia was unpopular with the nobles because he was a peasant and after the Tsar left it was rumoured he had all sorts of affairs and wild drunken nights. I would conclude from what I have seen that despite the hatred towards the Tsar it was shown that the army stayed loyal to him and while he had the army he could keep control. While Russia was slowly changing though no real progress was being made. Russia had lost against Japan, the workers and peasants had no rights and that despite all the efforts of the Duma the Tsar still had complete control. Uprisings were on the increase before the war and all the tension being built up just needed something to spark it as in the 1905 revolution where Bloody Sunday caused the spark to start the revolution. I conclude that as all the tension built up and the slaughter of the army continued the Tsarist regime became further and further under threat until the Tsar abdicated after a series of strikes and finally the loss of the army who joined the demonstrators. ?? ?? ?? ?? Mitul Patel 5P ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 essays

  1. How far did the 1905 revolution weaken then Tsarist regime?

    The Fundamental Laws passed in April 1906 decreed theta the Tsar had absolute power and the last say in all matters, hence, the Tsar had not lose any of his power and with his absolute authority, he could do all that he can to secure his rule.

  2. Why did the Tsarist regime fall in 1917?

    This would suggest that they all knew they were having their photo taken, and subsequently could have posed for the camera. This raises suspicion as to whether the 100 men we see in the photo really were part of a larger crowd - if there were only 100 men mutinying,


    A good railway system also offered significant military and security advantages. The Trans -Siberian Railway was constructed between 1892 - 1902. This was intended to migrate workers, and connect remoter regions of the central and eastern empire. This all paid off as extraction of resources tripled during the ten years that Witte was Minister of Finance.

  2. How and why did the Tsarist regime survive the 1905 revolution?

    On February 8 the Japanese attacked Port Arthur, and the Russo-Japanese war had begun. A quick easy victory was expected. But the Japanese at Port Arthur smashed the Pacific Fleet, and a poorly equipped and badly led Russian army was heavily defeated in the important town of Mukden (March).

  1. Russia 1914 To 1917: Coursework : Sources Question

    The people were shocked by this as they began to realise that victory was not guaranteed and especially not as quickly as they had supposed. Source C, a photo taken in 1914 of a Russian field hospital, demonstrates just how ill-equipped and under prepared they were.

  2. "Tsarism in Russia had been made secure by 1914." How far do you agree ...

    The soviets did not threaten the Tsar too. The first soviet only lasted 50 days and its influence outside St Petersburg was almost negligible. Therefore, by granting further concessions, the Tsar was able to win over groups of his opponents who only wanted reforms for a better life.

  1. Which of the following factors was the most important in the collapse of Tsarist ...

    These rich nobles owned some 25% of all of the land in Russia even thought they only made up 1% of the population. Some people farmed their land successfully and made an honest profit whilst the lazy ones sold land to pay for their rich lifestyles.

  2. How far were things improving in Russia before the First World War?

    These included landowners, industrialists, bankers, traders and businessmen. Before the industrial boom, Russia only had a very minute middle-class that consisted of doctors, lawyers, shopkeepers and university lecturers. The capitalists increased the size of the Russian middle-class. The growth of the middle-class was particularly prominent in the cities and towns

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work