• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The USA in the 1960s. Study Representations 1, 2 and 3 Choose the one which you think is best representation of the impact of protest on US society, explain your choice

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

´╗┐Part Bii: Analyse and evaluate Representations of history Study Representations 1, 2 and 3 Choose the one which you think is best representation of the impact of protest on US society, explain your choice. Use all 3 Representations and your own knowledge. Representation 1 is a transcript which is part of an episode from a documentary television series-?Vietnam: A Television Series? and was made in 1983.And it talks about president Nixon?s pledge anti was movement and the way in which the media portrayed it .Representation 2 is a book named ?coming apart? which was written by William L O?Neill, it was published in USA 1971, this representation tells us about the government, peaceful protest and the Media. Representation 3 is an article named ?pageant protest sparked bra-burning myth? which was written by Nell Greenfieldboyce and published on the 5th September 2008. Representation 2 is not totally objective for demonstrating how the impact of the protest was during the time of the civil Rights Movement. For instance: Representation two shows that ?On 28 May 1961, Robert Kennedy asked the interstate Commerce Commission (ICC) to end segregation of interstate buses, trains and facilities.?(2) This suggests that Representation 2 is a good insight into the time of the civil Rights because the Representation is showing a timeline fact and it is valuable for corresponding to the impact of the protest on US society, as it tells us what members of the government were attempting to end segregation. ...read more.

Middle

As a result the representation shows accuracy, just as it states facts and talks about many protests. Nevertheless the only thing it omits is violence in protest, but the intensity of accuracy is significant. The PBS did not keep their 4 promises (Undelivered and failed to keep).?The series will supply information for the historical record? ? they did not deliver this promise ?Only Kaleidoscope of images? which makes it inaccurate and creates a subjective view. Another promise that was failed to deliver was ?The series will provide an antidote to the misuses of history? ? this contributes to historical misunderstanding. ?The series will contribute to reality and to national esteem in the post war era? ?America are not proud, there is nothing g in the series that an American can be proud of. The fourth is? The series will contribute to historical methodology? ? this is undelivered and object lesson is how not to do it. Adversely with Representations 1 and 3, both Representations are rationally accurate and an example is that Representation 1 shows us that the Media are misleading ?Perhaps when we start looking to see who has misled us...in the studios of the TV networks in New York. It even shows us that it isn?t a good insight into the impact of protest on US society as it talks about the Media. ...read more.

Conclusion

An example:? One, two, three, four, tricky dick, stop the war!? (5) This tells us that the representation is not a good insight in the impact of protest on US society, because it doesn?t refer to key leaders of the n mobilization .Representation 3 once more doesn?t mention about the impact of protest in US society. It only targets on Media influence on US society. Hence both representation leave out important omission such as key leaders/protesters of the mobilization and on representation 3 of impact on Protest. Representation 3 is entirely different from representation 1 and 2, as it talks about the women?s liberation movement and the protesters used the civil rights movement protest approaches to gain suppoerters.So, representation 2 is the most complete representation, as it includes the least omissions; facts are true from my knowledge and talks about many protest events. In conclusion, as is historian one can say that the best representation has been representation 2 because it had been representing the impact of protest in US society as the authors purpose was to persuade and it kept that as its focus, this also has the least omissions, this representation is more accurate than the other two as it talks about more than one aspect which is media, government and protest which gives it an equal view. However, the only thing that is a restriction is the violence in protest. Overall it had good insight; it was valuable, had least omissions and it wasn?t completely objective, it was also more complete than representation one and three. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE USA 1941-80 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE USA 1941-80 essays

  1. why did the us drop bombs of nagasaki and hiroshima

    So the dropping of the bomb would help shorten the war as its devastating affect would rip the Japanese cities to pieces and they would surrender. That is because if they don't surrender they'll know more bombs like these would be dropped.

  2. Civil disobedience: peaceful or passive protest against a governmental body in rebuttal of some ...

    The use of legal manoeuvrings enabled the Danish government to prevent the Nazis from imposing anti-Jewish rule in Denmark.

  1. Choose any TWO stories you have read in Gullick's "Adventures and Encounters" and write ...

    The dark tawny complexion has no richness of tint... ("Ramble" 163). Just like other ethnocentric Europeans, Bird tends to measure and judge the people of Saigon by using the European yardstick. It was taken granted by Bird that anything or person that is not of European standard is considered ugly, revolting and unattractive.

  2. What happened at Sharpeville On 21st March 1960 - Massacre or Self defence: source ...

    that makes the report by the bishop unreliable because he wasn't there, so you have to believe the person who was actually at the event. Of course you don't know if Tyler is telling the whole truth because being a reporter, the government can control what Tyler can report.

  1. I have a Dream. Historical Background.

    In this paragraph King introduces the word you. He also says things like "persecution" and "trials and tribulations." This is King trying to get across an idea of his understanding of their suffering.

  2. "Religion's are notorious for promoting Racial Segregation". Discuss with reference to one specific historical ...

    In actuality it did not happen. Slaves were not freed in the remaining states until the passage of the "thirteenth amendment to the constitution", eight months after the war (1865). At the end of the civil was, the federal government moved to extend legal equality to African-Americans, by outlawing slavery with the 13th amendment.

  1. Apartheid - source related study.

    It was harmful for the blacks when the Group Areas Act took place. Thousands of blacks in Sophiatown were forcibly evicted into the reserves and Sophiatown became a white only area. Blacks had to go through the trouble of having to make themselves comfortable in a new area, in a new home.

  2. The USA 1941 - 80 : The Divided Union.

    * His two key bills of 1961, the Medicare Bill and the Education Bill both failed to get through the Congress and never became law. * These bills were blocked by Senators from JFK's own Democratic Party, opposed to his civil rights reform and his 'liberal' attitude to education and medical care.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work