• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

There has been a significant Palestinian refugee problem for the last fifty years. Do these sources allow you to come to a firm conclusion about who or what is responsible for this problem?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

There has been a significant Palestinian refugee problem for the last fifty years. Do these sources allow you to come to a firm conclusion about who or what is responsible for this problem? Since the formation of the state of Israel, Palestinians have left their homes and villages in order to escape, what they believe is, a corrupt and illegal Government. The Palestinian refugee problem has come in waves, with Arabs initially leaving after the Deir Yassin massacre, and then more leaving after the Six Day War in 1967. This was because as Israel extended its borders Arabs, who had previously been living in the South of Syria or Sinai, did not want to live under Jewish command and so fled the country. This means that a lot of people have been born and grown up in refugee camps and also hate the Jews, even though they were not directly involved in the original crisis. As the Palestinian refugee population has grown, so has its power and military strength. Many refugees are now recruited into guerrilla groups and attack Israel in various ways as they want the wider world to remember their fight for their homeland. At the 1978 peace talks at Camp David, Israeli and Egyptian Presidents agreed that Israel would withdraw from Sinai. ...read more.

Middle

This is probably a primary source, though we have no proof as a date is not given. It is likely to be biased towards the Arab point of view, though it does stay relatively neutral by admitting the UN tried to help them. This would make it quite reliable. The source has use as it allows historians to see another view of why the Palestinians stayed as refugees. This reason is that the majority of them refused to go into houses provided for them, thereby making them refugees by their own choice. The source was created from an interview with refugees so it is unlikely to have a hidden agenda, though it may do as the comments are made by Palestinians. Source E is a primary source and is a record of a speech given to the UN by the Israeli ambassador, Abba Eban, in 1958. Mr Eban says that the Arabs are only refugees because other Arab countries had had an economy boom and did not want to share their wealth with the refugees. He finishes by saying that although there is room in the Arab world for the refugees no one wants them, not because there is not room. This source is biased from an Israeli point of view as it is a primary source, meaning that the situation has only just begun. ...read more.

Conclusion

In conclusion, although a variety of sources have been presented for evaluation, it is hard to make a clear decision on who is to blame for the crisis. The only sources that can be considered are sources C and G, as biased sources cannot be used in making a fair judgement. However, the fact that source G does not reach a conclusion means it cannot be used. Therefore, only source C can be used to answer the question. This means a firm conclusion cannot be made as information from more than one source is needed. Although the Jews could be blamed, as they forced the Arabs out of their homeland, so too could the Palestinians who refused to settle in other lands or other Arab countries who may have refused them houses. Another problem on deciding who to blame for the crisis is the amount of bias in the sources. As the conflict has been going on for so long, the majority of the sources cannot be fully believed as the writers will have had interest and feelings about the conflict. As the crisis continues even to this day, it is likely that a mixture of causes (both long and short term) made the Palestinians evacuate their homeland, and so no one factor can be completely blamed for it. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE International relations 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE International relations 1945-1991 essays

  1. Sociologists and views on family structure.

    Stage 1: the preindustrial family. In this period the family was a unit of production, the members working together, mostly in agriculture. Examples of this stage can still be found today in farming areas. Stage 2: the early industrial family.

  2. Decolonization of India - analysing the sources.

    discuss' that India has faced many political issues. Source E details that, "most burning issues were the riots between Hindus and Muslims." Before Independence, India was governed by a foreign body and did as it was told and there was some sort of stability, peace and balance amongst Hindu's and Muslims but since Independence, the variant communities are with dfferent identities have been demanding rights for their community.

  1. How did the village of Deir Yassin come to be fought over in 1948?

    However this is not to say that the Haganah was not also aggressive, they attacked lots of Palestinian villages that where on the road into Jerusalem, they could attack this road with no problems because it was open to the Jews as their only way of supplies into Jerusalem.

  2. There has been a significant Palestinian refugee problem for the last fifty years, who ...

    This source does not talk about the Israeli policy of clearing out villages and it is trying to justify to the UN why it was not the Israelis fault about all of the refugees and does not give enough evidence from both sides for us to come to a firm conclusion using this source alone.

  1. How did the Village of Deir Yassin come to be Fought Over in 1948 ...

    This meant that Britain controlled Palestine and so allowed Jews into Palestine, whilst also helping the local Arabs people. Yet Britain could not predict the numbers in which Jews would immigrate into Palestine, and in the first 10 years of the mandate 100,000 Jews had immigrated.

  2. Cold War Short Essays - Questions and Answers.

    A further key feature was that many people risked their lives trying to cross the border from East to West Berlin. Any escapees were shot and up 200 people were killed. Those that escaped were welcomed by the West. Briefly explain the key features of the events of the crisis about Berlin in 1961 (6 marks)

  1. The Massacre at Oradour-sur-Glane

    This sign post reads, "Place of torture. A group of men were massacred and burnt by the Nazis. It then reads, "Quiet Thoughts." At the same time that the gas bomb exploded in the church, the SS fired their machine guns into the men crowded in the barns.

  2. Cold War Summary, quotes and revision notes.

    - Breakthrough contact with the communist world, US President Nixon visited China before the USSR * Dramatic improvement in Sino-American relations was an added incentive for Soviets to improve their relations with the US Impacts: 1) The Sino-Soviet Split led to an improvement in relations between the US & China 2)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work