• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent can we describe Meiji modernization as a Westernization?

Extracts from this document...


18. To what extent can we describe Meiji modernization as a Westernization? Meiji modernization is a combined process. It combined the old with the West, the traditional values of the Japanese with the technology of the West. In short, westenization is a part, and only one part of the whole process of modernization. Westernization is taken in the following fields. Firstly, we can find westernization in the Charter Oath of 1868. The desire of the Japanese to borrow from the West so to strengthen the country could be clearly seen in the Charter Oath. There is the sentence in the Oath - 'knowledge shall be sought for all over the world' and thus shall be strengthened the foundation of the imperial policy. This statement was to be the basic philosophy of the whole movement. Japan was to be modernized and strengthened through the use of western knowledge. It was a surprisingly frank disavowal of the sentiment to ?xpel the barbarians'. The most conspicuous case of the Westernization was in the field of technology for a backward country like Japan, technological progress must be based upon imitation. ...read more.


Yet in each of the above areas, it is doubtful whether imitation of the West is a true Westernization. This can be shown in the following evidences. Military, although the soldiers had western equipment and military training (army based on Prussian model and navy based on British model), they were often reminded of the importance of the traditional samurai spirit (Bushido) and particularly, of unconditional loyalty to the Emperor. By this, it is not different from the past. The soldiers were just the samurai in the past. They just differed in name and appearance. In modernizing the educational system, only the 'form' was borrowed from the West. Thus the ultimate aim of the educational reforms was not to introduce these Western concepts of 'individualism' and 'freedom of thought' but rather to seek conformity and reinforce Japanese traditional values and virtues such as loyalty and patriotism. Thus only technical and practical training was based on Western lines but not moral training. Through indoctrination in traditional values, the Japanese would become a nation of patriots. Although there was the constitution of 1889 which framed by Ito, there was not a guarantee that democracy was promised in Japan. ...read more.


There was a growing intellectual resentment against blind and unreserved adoption of Western methods. They thought that western methods were not all right and good. Japan had to select some western methods that suited Japan and could help Japan become strong and to obtain status. Although Japan had try to modernize herself along western lines, the Westerners still refused to grant Japan better status. This led to a revival of anti-foreign sentiments. Hence, it is clear that Japan's real aim in westernization was only to obtain equal status with the West. When this failed, the Japanese could not bear. The trend of selective westernization was also accounted for by the fact that Japan discovered that western culture was not homogeneous especially as the Western nations quarrelled among themselves over their rival interests. As a result, Japan tried to be selective among the Western nations. Some people would go so far to say that the Meiji modernization is a sort of 'Japanization' rather than a 'westernization'. Anyway, Westernization is undoubtedly part of the whole process but, to stress again, it is only a part. Reference 1. Fairbank: 'East Asia: The Modern Transformation' 2. Richard Storry: 'A History of Modern Japan' 3. Beaseley: 'The Modern History of Japan' 2 2 Subject: Meiji Japan 18 Subject: Meiji Japan 18 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE History Projects section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE History Projects essays

  1. Liberal Reforms (1906-1914)

    More and more people found themselves being sacked which meant they wouldn't be eligible to receive the insurance scheme money. By 1915 around 2.3 million people were insured under this scheme. This act was successful as hundreds of unemployed people now received and were introduced into the insurance scheme despite

  2. To what extent wasBritain Romanised

    The result was a temple dedicated to "Sulis Minerva" at the waters in Bath. Left: the head of Medusa at the temple of Sulis Minerva, Aquae Sulis. This statue incorporates elements from depictions of both deities, showing how the two religions were combined. Source: "Roman Britain" by H. H. Scullard.

  1. To what extent was the Irish Famine merely an excuse for Peel to repeal ...

    and for a short period very few people were exposed to starvation. In the context of industrialisation and in support of the colonialist policies that had been applied in prior times one could argue that, economically, Ireland had always been a drain on English resources and money, as it had

  2. The Panchayat system as an early form of conflict resolution in Trinidad.

    The East Indian villagers were said to have been very cautious about the courthouse and its trappings so they implemented their familiar, speedy court of the Panchayat28. The Panchayat in Trinidad was more a process than a single event. It was a series of meetings or consultations with different members, with different degrees of privacy and different leadership29.

  1. The Emergence of Universal Medicare

    making Canadian citizens think twice about how universal Medicare is a defining attribute. The system is now going into a deficit and many Canadians are viewing universal Medicare as unsustainable due to the larger population of seniors and rising costs17.

  2. To what extent is it fair to conclude that Palmerston(TM)s foreign policy one long ...

    He was clearly and knowingly breaking international law which enraged the North Americans as they had enough to deal with while fighting with the South over the slave trade and then they had the South being given outside help by a 'neutral' country.

  1. The Atomic Bombings of Japan

    The governments didn't show the whole picture. During the 1950's the dangers of the nuclear arms race were played down. The USA wanted to stay ahead of the USSR; America had the resources to develop the H bomb. They wanted to see its effects; therefore they did tests in the Nevada Desert.

  2. Anne Frank Factfile

    There were some inconsistencies. In the diary itself as well, for example the noises. Those in hiding, we are told, must not make the least sound. This is so much so that, if they cough, they quickly take codeine. The "enemies" could hear them.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work