• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent was the SS a "state within a state"? How powerful was the SS?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

To what extent was the SS a "state within a state"? How powerful was the SS? The role of the SS in Nazi Germany was very important. Many historians, such as Schoenbaum, have argued that Himmler created an organisation which, "potentially superseded the state and perhaps even the party as well." Its members were totally dedicated to the supreme virtues of Nazi ideology, loyalty and honour. They saw themselves as the protectors of the German way of life and the defenders of the people against agitators, the criminal classes and those they saw as being responsible for the Jewish-Bolshevik threat. They also saw it as their duty to supervise the process of gaining lebensraum or living space and the successful German colonisation of the newly acquired territories. However. Although it is true that the SS' power came from Hitler it is also true that the power of the SS lay in the fact that it was a symbol, of fear and terror. By 1941, the "SS state" was a reality. Schoenbaum said of it, "in one form or another the SS made foreign policy, military policy and agricultural policy." The power the SS gained began after The Night of the Long Knives in 1934. Himmler had demonstrated his loyalty to Hitler and thus gained his favour. This gave Himmler the "carte blanche" to create a racially pure SS empire. Himmler received preferential treatment. He had the pick of the cr�me of the German youth and the German army to use as he wished. ...read more.

Middle

Within a few years Himmler had organised a "Second Army" which took the form of the SS reserve troops, the core of the later Waffen-SS, which challenged the delicate balance of power between the political and the military powers in Germany. In the early years of its growth Himmler deceived army generals with its small size and this deceit was not realised until 1938, when the troops numbered 14 000, because it was under the belief that it only had police-like functions. However, by 1938 it was a military force, as many of the officers had been trained by former army NCOs. The loss of beck and Fritsch in 1938 removed two of the most significant opponents to the rise of Himmler's new force and the SS exploited this situation rapidly. Himmler gave the SS Reserve Troops a "mobile role as part of a wartime army" and later it developed into a full-time division. The Waffen-SS rapidly grew into a separate army, though it did not challenge the power of the Wehrmacht until 1943. Himmler created an elite, politicised warrior caste. He wanted the SS to supplant the army to take over the policy of lebensraum. However, this changes to become units of elite troops because the war starts earlier than expected. However, the Waffen-SS was a small part of the army. In 1941, it had just over 900 000 men, 1/10 of the army. As a response to the July bomb plot the leadership of the army was purged and by 1945, due to the war losses, the SS had become diluted losing its elitist standing. ...read more.

Conclusion

Thus he stressed even more the common ethic ideal in the education of young Nazi leaders, in order that they would be the glue which would keep the whole together. The SS had emerged during a period of political and social convulsions between 1933 and 1936 and Himmler was concerned that any stability might undermine the development of his organisation. However, domestic turmoil was soon replaced by external violence and, inevitably, then war, enabling the SS to continue to evolve and flourish. Indeed the outbreak of the war gave the SS a unique opportunity to maintain its momentum and even extend its influence beyond German borders. Thus the war became a condition sine qua non for the further evolution of the SS as envisaged by Himmler. By the end of the 1930's the influence of the SS was extensive and varied, but it had its limits. The old elites remained, apart from the police force, and this meant that the SS reached the limits of its power when it had to compete with old or new leadership groups without having Hitler's backing. The SS was also hampered by the fact that they were accountable to Hitler and if he disagreed with the policy they wanted to pursue then there was no way it would go ahead. Himmler had to compete with other Nazi officials to gain Hitler's favour, which he eventually did. Thus it is not surprising that Himmler reached the zenith of his power at a time when the German defeat was no longer in doubt. Kirsty Field 13C The SS - A State within a state? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Germany 1918-1939 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Germany 1918-1939 essays

  1. To What Extent Was Nazi Germany a Totalitarian State 1933-1939?

    whether they like it or not". Although the Nazis had a great deal of success with the youth, they did not have total control over this area. This is a contradiction over what a totalitarian state is. The creation of the Hitler youth organisations aimed to offer the young with a variety of activities that were fun as well as being indirectly geared towards military training.

  2. The Nazi Police State

    Germany into loyal Nazism, guaranteeing Hitler of a solid following well into the later years of the Third Reich. THE JEWS AND ANTI-SEMITISM Anti-Semitism, by definition is 'hostility to, or prejudice against Jews'. The Third Reich was very much an anti-Semitic regime, lead by Hitler's belief that Jews were potentially communists in disguise.

  1. Was Germanya totalitarian state?

    The German people had to do what they were told, they had no choice. There's no one who'd say 'Would you like to kill Jews? Would you like to accept our final solution for Jews? Would you like to...'. All what you can do, is to listen to what the

  2. To what extent was the Nazi state a propaganda state?

    For Hitler himself, his aim for Germany was to create a Volksgemeinschaft, a new German nation sharing his Weltanschauung. One can argue that by the mid-1930s, most people regarded the regime positively, and on the surface, people appeared to respond to attempts to unify the German community eg.

  1. What is the tradition of animosity between racial groups in Europe during the Twentieth ...

    The tradition of animosity in Europe in the Twentieth Century between different racial groups has evolved across the century, largely due to the actual examples of genocide which occurred in the Twentieth Century in Europe. At the start of the century many people where intolerant of others and it was

  2. Hitler - Totalitarian State

    As well as being anti-semitic he was also very anti-communist. Infact they were his number one enemy. He noticed that most communist leaders were Jewish and he thought they were out to cause trouble. Because he was so anticommunist, Hitler was admired by many businessmen and bankers, who feared that communism was going to take over Germany.

  1. The NaziState, Economy and Society.

    (Hans Mommsen's position). Ian Kershaw has combined the two positions - with Hitler refraining from instigating policy, and acting rather as a mobiliser and legitimator of policies dreamed up by competing subordinates. This also allowed Hitler to appear above the factional struggles of his leading associates and to evade responsibility for failed and inhuman decisions.

  2. World War Two - The Police State

    They were run by very violent men, flogging was common and 25 strokes was the normal. At Buchenald 280 men had one water tap between them which could only be used for 15 minutes on getting up. Food and drink were very sparse and the Jews would only be given half of the rations of other prisoners.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work