• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent was the Weimar constitution flawed?

Extracts from this document...


To what extent was the Weimar constitution flawed? The majority of people believe that it was the Weimar constitution which was fundamentally flawed and that this damaged the long term prospects of the Weimar republic, although strong points can be identified in the constitution which support the argument that the constitution wasn't to blame for the republics downfall. From this some historians have determined that the role of the constitution in the downfall of the republic is exaggerated. There were a wide variety of things that played a part in the collapse of the republic; one of these was the problems linked with proportional representation. There were two main problems with proportional representation the first is that in this kind of electoral system its much easier for extremist groups to gain seats in the Reichstag. In the first past the post system a certain number of votes does not guarantee a party representation in the Reichstag. This means that there is a limited number of parties in the Reichstag, making it easier to gain an overall majority thus meaning fewer coalition governments and a more stable power base. ...read more.


The reason this was seen as such a failure was that Hitler used this article to take control and set up the nazi regime during the 1930's. Other evidence indicates that that having this article in the constitution was not such a bad idea because as long as it was used in the way it was supposed to i.e. in time of crisis such as when Erbert's government was under threat from the Spartacists. The reason Hitler was able to get away with bypassing the government was because large number of the population didn't support government or democratic methods therefore Hitler came up against no real opposition when he became chancellor. In most modern democracies referendums can be used to get the publics view on a proposition by vote i.e. whether Great Britain should join the euro or keep the pound. Although referendums are possible they are rarely used in today's society. In the Weimar constitution it was possible for referendums to be used for certain circumstances much like today. This it self was not a problem, it was the way they were used by extremist groups such as the nazis to gain influence and present their views to the general population. ...read more.


The constitution was not the main problem; the extreme right and left used loopholes in the constitution to gain support and destabilise the government. The biggest example of this was that Hitler was able to use article 48 to take control of Germany and install himself at the head of a dictatorship. Economic problems were also a big factor as each successive government was more worried about keeping the people happy rather than making the changes necessary to sure up the economy. Increased inflation over the years did nothing to reinstate the people's faith in democracy. The main reason the constitution failed was not because the document itself was flawed but because the German people were not ready or prepared to make such a sudden change from autocracy to democracy. Other reasons were that people like Hitler were able to take advantages of loopholes such as article 48, but this again wasn't the fault of the constitution more the people who had put Hitler in the position of chancellor. The constitution was not truly flawed because it is likely that the same constitution would have worked well under different circumstances, but the other factors involved in Germany at this time made it impossible for it to operate successfully. Sam Roberts 3 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Germany 1918-1939 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Germany 1918-1939 essays

  1. What were the main features of the Weimar Constitution?

    Around 600 communists were killed in the process. The Kapp Putcsh was one of the two opponents of the Weimar from the right. In March 1920 Dr Wolfgang Kapp led 5000 Freikorps into Berlin in a rebellion known as the Kapp Putcsh.

  2. How and why do Historians approaches to the MunichAgreement differ from each other?

    Therefore, Kissinger feels it was the agreement that began the war. Conversely, Hobsbawm blames not only the Munich Agreement but also other milestones on the road to war. Eric Hobsbawm and Henry Kissinger agree that Britain had an apparent unwillingness to act both singly and in conjunction.

  1. Modern World History Coursework - Reichstag Sourcework

    Hitler used the fire to his advantage by accessing the emergency powers available to him and therefore passing the Enabling Act on the 24th March 1933. This allowed him to immediately pass laws and decrees without interference or involvement from any other party. This legally made Hitler the F�hrer (dictator)

  2. Weimar constitution coursework

    It became very difficult to establish stability or even get new laws passed. Because of this the situation in Germany was worsening every day. The republic claimed that it could no longer afford to meet reparation payments required by the Versailles Treaty and the government stopped making some payments.

  1. Was the Weimar constitution flawed?

    black and white, a lot of unforeseen grey areas were to arise in the early years which would have no doubt set the confidence of the people in the Weimar constitution into disillusionment. The Federal System The centralisation of power through a new constitution devised and developed by Hugo Preuss had its good and bad points.

  2. Nazism and the New Age.

    to see anyone portray then-President Roosevelt as a similar "war criminal" for his refusal to get involved at a much lower risk.] [Four points about "The Deputy" which reflect on the NA-Nazi connection: (1) This play focusing on Pius XII to the exclusion of many other silent "Deputies" was introduced

  1. Was the constitution of the weimar republic fundamentally flawed or was it manipulated by ...

    When judging the defects of the constitution of the Weimar Republic we need to keep in mind that there were at least four fatal defects in the Weimar Constitution. All of them were used to destroy the Weimar Republic, but all of them could have been corrected.

  2. Why were successive Weimar Governments able to sustain Democracy during the period 1919-1933?

    This Policy ended passive resistance in the Ruhr and announced that Germany would comply with the Treaty of Versailles. With the Ending of passive resistance Germany could now seek to remedy hyperinflation. With this, the economy started to rebuild itself as people started to go back to work, and foreign relationships started to flourish.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work