• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Was Pohibition bound to fail Question A

Extracts from this document...


Was Prohibition Bound to fail? a) Sources "a" and "b" are extracts from 1970's history books, discussing prohibition in the USA in the 1910-20 period. Both extracts agree on the causes of prohibition but develop different points in detail. Firstly, "a" and "b" both agree that the influence of the Women's Christian Temperance Union (the anti-saloon league) was strongly linked to prohibition. They were a pressure group that intended to make every state in the country "dry" (alcohol-free) by getting the government to introduce prohibition. Source "a" cites the "influence of the anti-saloon league" as a reason for prohibition and "b", concurring with this, states that the cause was aided when the "Women's Christian Temperance Union...joined the crusade". Source 'a' and 'b' agree that the anti-saloon league were actively involved in the prohibition coming into place. ...read more.


Both sources agree that the preservation of grain is important but source 'b' takes this point further as it tells us the anti-saloon league wanted grain to be banned completely, whereas 'a' only says there was a 'concern'. But essentially both sources are in agreement that the preservation of grain was a factor contributing towards prohibition. Also popularity of prohibition could have created a 'domino effect' in America, as 23 states were already dry in 1917, the neighboring states to the ones already alcohol free, may be influenced. Source 'a' supports this popularity by stating '23 states had already introduced a ban on alcohol' and 'b' simply says 'nation-wide campaign' meaning the whole of America was in support of this. The popularity is agreed by both sources. As feeling towards Germans would be negative due to the war, many Americans would not want to buy a German Beer and be seen as un-American, the majority of beers were German. ...read more.


It states '30,000 speakeasies in New York' Speakeasies were secret bars, selling illegal alcohol. Gangsters were also a problem as the 'bootlegged' (smuggled illegal alcohol across the US border). Gangsters like Dutch Schulz and Al Capone. Source 'b' has explained the causes in more detail, 'a' has only explained crime occurred but not stated any particular crimes. In conclusion, both sources have agreed in many ways for example, both agree the anti-saloon league, Preservation popularity and immorality are causes of prohibition, but 'a' goes further with giving more reasoning and opinion on all factors bar Grain preservation, in which 'b' explains this issue with greater reasoning. Also both sources agree that an effect of prohibition was crime, 'a' states this in a clear, to-the-point way with use of fact, but 'b' gives more factual insight and explains further what crimes were taking place. Both sources agree on prohibition, but 'a' has a better insight. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE USA 1919-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE USA 1919-1941 essays

  1. Prohibition bound to fail?

    All sources have some element of truth in them and they are all useful to a historian studying a particular period in time. But some sources are less reliable than others due to numerous factors, such as the time period they were written in and by whom they were written by.

  2. Why did prohibition fail? - Gangsters, Widespread illegal drinking, lack of support, impossibility of ...

    It injured and killed many, proving the ASL's argument about a happier, healthier, more productive workforce completely wrong. Lack of public support was definitely quite a major reason for the failure of Prohibition, which is not closely linked with gangsters taking control of the illegal alcohol industry.

  1. Roosevelt Sources Question

    because source J is made by a business speaking in 1980 he says that Roosevelt gave to people rather than teaching them how to gain. He says that people then got used to not having to work so hard and so they just expected to get from Roosevelt.

  2. The USA: Was prohibition bound to fail?

    The cartoon in source I shows a web of corruption, as people of power who should be taking part in the enforcement of the law are holding their hands out behind them, signifying "taking a back-hander" - a bribe.

  1. To What extent was Prohibtion doomed to fail from its inception?

    President Hoover put together the Wickersham Commission into Prohibition in 1929, despite the fact it supported the idea of prohibition it claimed that it was almost impossible to enforce it. The commission took surveys of all states and found that almost every state was more 'wet' than 'dry', this appears

  2. Was Prohibition bound to Fail

    The numbers in the table seem to contradict each other, which therefor makes it a less reliable source. The source comes from the Philadelphia police department, showing the number of arrests for drinking related offences, 1920-25. The results of the table based by the city of Philadelphia and not around

  1. Was Prohibition Bound To Fail?

    In the smaller tableau it portrays the despair and suffering of their families in a way that makes the viewer feel pity. Source D uses a more "tug on the old heart strings" way of saying the same thing. Men spend their wages in saloons instead of on their families.

  2. Was Prohibition Bound To Fail?

    B) Sources C and D are both in support of Prohibition. Source C was a poster published in 1910. The artist has produced the posters from the point of view from someone supporting the anti-saloon.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work