• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Was The New Deal a Succes

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

WAS THE NEW DEAL A SUCCESS? 1. In 1932 people had started to give up on the economy and the government. The Depression was hurting the country all over. Many people who had wealth became poor overnight and the government was not in a position to help the situation. The people had very little confidence in themselves and the management of the country. Herbert Hoover, the President at that time, was a Republican who continued with the policy of laissez-faire, meaning that events were left to run themselves without government intervention. He didn't even try slightly to improve the current situation and therefore earned the scorn of the public and when Roosevelt went up and down the country promising to bring the country out of the Depression, a new life, with a New Deal that would help restore the economy and confidence of America, he gathered a great deal of support. Roosevelt attacked the Administrations policies as leading to 'Destruction, Delay, Deceit and Despair' and inspired the public as he went on his presidential campaign. He asked the nation to join in a 'crusade' to restore the country to its former grandeur. People were inspired to not give up hope: Roosevelt inspired the nation and they loved him for it. Roosevelt promised that he would help the Americans get back jobs and help protect their savings and property. He also promised to provide relief for the sick and to get industry and agriculture back on their feet. ...read more.

Middle

Herbert Hoover is depicted as a man walking away studying a timetable this is mocking him saying that he followed the normal and what was set rather than Roosevelt who initiated laws etc.. Hoover is holding a gladstone bag to signify that the cartoonist thinks that Hoover's policies were empty and he was a poor salesman. Roosevelt's rolled up sleeves are drawn to show that he means business and is prepared to take action himself. Source F is also pro-Roosevelt. First the cartoon shows Uncle Sam, representing American society, looking haggard and ill, sitting there in his pyjamas listening in to the 'nurse and the doctor'. The nurse, being Congress, is listening to the 'doctor' very carefully. Doctor Roosevelt is prescribing the medicines. This represents Roosevelt 'prescribing' all his different 'organizations' for the country to 'get back on its feet'. What the 'doctor' is saying that if the New Deal doesn't work (which there is no reason why it shouldn't) then something else will have to be prescribed to get America back on its feet. 4. Source H is more informative than Source G because Source G is just informing us about one old couple who were very grateful to Roosevelt for helping them, but popular song is made up to reflects what the public thinks or may be made to think to speak endearingly of the Democratic party, the song uses slang such as 'Martin' and 'donkey' which also reflects the public mood. The song also compares life under Roosevelt and life during the Depression where they were 'neglected'. ...read more.

Conclusion

Source C and D shows how people are dependant on the administrations and accuse them of naively giving their money to New Deal even though it wasn't working and was just sucking them dry. Sources E and F show that the New Deal was working and that Roosevelt was doing something unlike Hoover. Sources G and H praise the New Deal, there isn't one word which criticizes him in either. Source I is a criticism from a self-made man who believed that if he could pull himself up so should everyone. Source J was written by someone knew him well and admired and his principles and who helped him succeed. Even though Source I says that the New Deal helped people lose confidence in themselves, Interpretation 1 contradicts it and says that the New Deal actually gave people more confidence in themselves. Interpretation 2 is mostly seen in Source C and D where they show that the economy worsened and that Roosevelt was pumping away at the New Deal. Interpretation 1 is a stronger statement than Interpretation 2 as Interpretation 1 has more sources to defend its argument. The actual interpretation doesn't have so many facts but if we look for arguments for the New Deal then we would find more to defend it than we would to criticize it. On balance, balance it may be seen that where there was more positive reaction to the New Deal than negative. Perhaps Roosevelt's success was brought about by a combination of New Deal policies and US entry into the Second World War. ?? ?? ?? ?? Chavi Littlestone Year 10 31 August 2009 The USA - 1 - ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE USA 1919-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE USA 1919-1941 essays

  1. Why people supported Roosevelt in the 1932 election

    unemployment insurance and old-age pensions, and help for the sick, disabled and needy. By giving people money (FERA, HOLC...) and jobs (CCC, CWA...) it decreased the number of unemployed, gave people a sense of purpose and provided many families with an income.

  2. GCSE History Coursework Assignment B - Was the New Deal a Success?

    This source is definitely showing a positive view of FDR. Finally source G tells us that FDR is a conman, who because of his endless confusion cannot heal America but still ploughs money into his remedies in the slight hope they might work.

  1. Was the New Deal a success

    got the USA out of the depression because there a lot of jobs available for both men and women. Both these sources are against the New Deal because they both outline that the New Deal scheme did not help the Depression.

  2. Depression and The New Deal

    opposition to the New Deal and the way in which he carried out his policies. The Republican candidate, Senator Alfred Landon, stated that the New Deal was undermining traditional US initiative and self-reliance. There were many sections of society who supported Landon because they saw the recent legalisation as limiting their own power.

  1. History Coursework: The New Deal

    After the implementation of the New Deal, these figures reduced to lower than those during the boom years making it a great success. The GNP figures during the boom years were over $100 billion yet the depression caused this to go down $58 billion.

  2. Roosevelt And The New Deal

    Unemployed people were recruited to build dams, bridges and roads, along with many other projects. The writer also comments on how Roosevelt did not run the country as a dictatorship. He writs "The charge that Roosevelt has been a dictator is not true."

  1. Roosevelt and the new deal - source related questions.

    America that was previously suffering from 'depression and discouragement' which existed before the change in 1933. Source C, however, held the opposing view, implying that Roosevelt himself was responsible for the increase in unemployment, taxes and debt. By 1938, unemployment reached 11 million and it was the war that rescued the 'drowning man'.

  2. Was the New Deal a success? (Source based questions)

    However, the writer was not hired to write what he wrote and these are genuine words of content. This man represents the people who cannot afford to live their old life and have been forced to apply for loans, re-mortgage their homes, etc.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work