• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Was the Treaty Of Versailles a Harsh Treaty?

Extracts from this document...


Was the Treaty Of Versailles a Harsh Treaty? When the peace armistice was signed on 11th November 1918, no plans had been made for a peace settlement so it was decided that one would be drawn up in the New Year. Representatives from Great Britain, France and USA were among those attending. Each had different ideas of how to treat Germany, and to what extent she would pay for the war. After the treaty of Versailles was agreed, the Germans were upset by the terms; as they felt it was too harsh. The treaty was harsh but could have been a lot worse. Who can say for sure whether the Treaty of Versailles was fair or not? The answer depends on your point of view. From the French perspective, the Germans deserved to give up everything in order to make amends for the destruction they caused in France. Therefore, the treaty wasn't punishing them enough. From where the American and British point of view, it seemed impossible to place the entire blame on one country, so the Clause 231, which stated Germany must except the blame for the war must have seemed quite harsh, but the treaty was a compromise - no one got everything they wanted, but more importantly, no one was completely short-changed, not even Germany. ...read more.


They had also forced the harsh peace treaty of Brest-Litovsk on Russia in 1918 without worries. It could seem that, in their rage about having all the guilt on them, the Germans set out to make the treaty look much worse than it really was. Clemenceau's wishes for revenge had only been halfway fulfilled. He had wanted Germany broken up into small states and to pay much more in compensation for the destruction and death which had taken place in France. Of course, one must consider that he had to negotiate with Wilson, who was much more concerned with a 'just peace' and self-determination. The treaty weakened Germany more than Wilson had wanted, but the American president had been forced to negotiate in a position of weakness and to make far-reaching concessions to his allies in order to secure a peace treaty at all. He tried to conceal his failure to the American public by condoning the peace treaty as a just punishment for a bad criminal. Wilson first of all wanted to make sure that Germany would not succumb to Bolshevism; in the long run, he wished for an integration of republican Germany into a liberal community of nations. ...read more.


All three British historians have different views as the sources written earlier may not have had as much information to research from. I don't believe that the Germans can blame every failure on the Treaty of Versailles, Germany's economy was weakened by the reparations and the army was limited and the Weimar republic was not as good as it should have been but Germany was still a large country and had the potential to become economically strong again. It depends from which point of view you look at it though the Germans will always say the treaty weakened them which it did, but was probably blow out of proportion, if you look at it from a British point of view it doesn't seem harsh enough and the Germans just wanted something to complain about. If the German government had not been so insecure and ineffective Germany may have been able to re-build itself a lot quicker. In the short run, the treaty significantly weakened Germany and gave the victors economic benefits and more power. In the long run, however, nothing spoke against a German recovery at least in economics. After the ?? ?? ?? ?? Minh Pritchard ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE International relations 1900-1939 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE International relations 1900-1939 essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Was The Treaty Of Versailles Justified?

    5 star(s)

    During the war many French coalmines had been put out of action so while they were being repaired France was to receive coal from the German mines in the Saarland. Also during the time that Adolf Hitler was in power in Germany he spent more than the Allies demanded in reparations on weapons and rebuilding the army.

  2. Marked by a teacher

    Was the treaty of Versailles too harsh on Germany?

    4 star(s)

    England wanted Germany to be punished but not so severely. England also lost men but thought that the treaty of Versailles could bring problems for the future. The USA wanted the treaty to be softer, they thought the treaty was too harsh and would cause a future war in years to come.

  1. Peer reviewed

    Why did the treaty of versailles provoke widespread hostility among Germans?

    4 star(s)

    not on the foreign powers, but on the 'November Criminals', who had initiated the armistice talks and, on any politicians or groups who believed in the efficacy of slow but sure revisionism by way of working with the foreign enemy powers.

  2. How fair was the treaty of Versailles?

    Clemenceau argued strongly that the rich area called Rhine to be a new country. However Clemenceau had to make a compromise as it had not got what it had want and said that the French will occupy the Rhine region for fifteen years and no German soldier is allowed to enter the Rhine.

  1. Why was the Treaty of Versailles so Controversial?

    Instead of a negotiated peace in which Germany would be a significant, if not equal, partner, the treaty gave practically no room for German input and resembled more a dictate than a real peace settlement. Instead of admitting the new democratic Germany into the community of democratic nations, the Allies ostracized the vanquished nation.

  2. To what extent was the Treaty of Versailles justifiable?

    was Britain who had the largest Empire in the world and to achieve this massive feat, their international policy must have been excellent to keep the Empire under control. The quote is useful as it shows the beliefs in this time and also the arrogance which the British showed when

  1. "The Treaty of Versilles was far too harsh on Germany." To what extent do ...

    They lost lots of their Empire and all of their colonies in other parts of Europe but mostly civilians lived there and there were a vast number of British or French colonies there to fight them, if they rebelled. From the Germans point of view there was an act of disgrace.


    army 50 kilometres from the border of the controversial Rhineland as well as allowing French and British armies to occupy around the river Rhine. This antagonised the Germans as the last thing the wanted was to effectively 'give' an important land to their victorious to sit and watch their every move- they wanted them out!

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work