• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Was the Weimar Government destined to fail?

Extracts from this document...


Anna Baldes VCE 20th Century History, Essay 3 20/05/2007 VCE 20th Century History, Unit 1 Topic Question: Was Weimar Government destined to fail? 1918-33 Word count: 1 522 Politics in Germany between 1918 and 1933 was volatile, as the Weimar Government struggled to keep control. The democratic Weimar Republic was from its inception doomed to fail. Beginning its regime with signing a fiercely unpopular peace treaty, this did not just cause a great number of problems for the newly instated Government, but ensured the distrust of its people for the duration of its lifespan. It struggled with problem after problem trying to maintain its rule over a country that not only was severely inexperienced with democracy but whose leaders and other significant figures were from day one aiming to destroy Weimar and the very system it was based on in its entirety. The constant demand for the destruction of the Weimar system meant that a place for extremist groups and parties was always ensured in German society, placing it in a position where it was constantly at threat. Weimar could have never survived. As Kaiser Wilhelm II fled, a great change took hold of Germany, one which would set into place a system and way of life which could never have survived let alone thrived. ...read more.


This did not only cause great economic problems, by brutally hindering her production of goods and resources, the majority of which were previously exported for profit, but caused an unimaginable and embarrassing blow to the identity of the general German population, who were fundamentally nationalistic. Secondly, the Treaty placed another strain on the proud German identity by placing inconceivable restrictions on the German military, calling for the destruction of both the air force 2 The German Century, Michael Sturmer, Weidenfeld & Nicolson, p.110 3 Weimar Sympathiser, Hugo Preuss, Democrat, 1923 and navy, in their entirety, and limiting its army to a tiny 100,000 men. The final and most critical blow came in the form of a forced acceptance of fault for the war and agreement to pay, a firstly an unset amount of reparations to the victorious Allied powers. Never before had there been such a unanimous outcry by the public who still believed that they could have emerged victorious, fiercely unforced censorship laws, until now, keeping them na�ve to their losses. This embarrassment had to be blamed on someone; the military instantly denied responsibility, 'The German army was stabbed in the back. No blame is to be attached to the sound care of the army...It is perfectly clear on whom the blame rests.'4, placing the blame on the only other logic party, the Weimar Government. ...read more.


Their views were easily made public, the general blame of Weimar for losing the war rising from these powerful individuals, '...let them eat the broth they have prepared for us.'9 Adding to Weimar's threatened state was the constant presence of extremist parties, made possibly by the lack of public support for Weimar. The numerous uprisings which occurred during Weimar's reign created constant unrest and ensured instability. The most extreme of these came in the form of the Kapp Putsch, for the right and the Spartacist Uprising, for the left, in both casing entire German cities were captured and held only to flee and return power to Weimar, not when Weimar intervened but the opposing extremist party of Weimar's behalf. This further proved to the German people Weimar incapability, not to mention drew support for the strong capability of the extremist parties. In conclusion, Weimar's collapse was ensured from its formation. The survival of a democratic system lies with the support of the people. The support which Weimar 9 Supreme commander, General Ludendorff never had, the fundamental hate for Weimar not only rooted in the German peoples personality and history, but caused by the injustices of Versailles, the confusion surrounding the constitution and the extreme opposition which threatened Weimar from every angle. Weimar could have never survived. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Germany 1918-1939 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Germany 1918-1939 essays

  1. Why did the Weimar Republic Fail?

    German citizens had to blame someone and they blamed the republic for everything, for loosing the war and the financial situation they were in now. The German people thought all the bad things that had happened to them and their country was a result of the Weimar republic.

  2. "The Weimar Republic Was Destined To Fail From The Moment It signed The Armistice ...

    There was also a loss of many German colonies; this meant the loss of many economic regions and negatively affected Weimar. The terms of The Treaty of Versailles was believed by the majority of Germans to be unfair, however many under the impression that they were fighting a purely defensive war.

  1. Did the Weimar Republic have a good beginning?

    Royalists didn't support the Weimar Republic because they wanted the Kaiser back. They didn't respect or trust the government because it was the Social Democrats who told the Kaiser to abdicate his thrown. Consequently they blamed Weimar for the downfall of their country and their Kaiser.

  2. Why did the Weimar Republic fail?

    Although proportional representation appeared to be very democratic, it provided weak coalitions who did not agree on everything. Therefore when Germany needed to act quickly in times of crisis, decisions could not be made effectively, for each party had their own ideas on how the country should be run.

  1. What is the tradition of animosity between racial groups in Europe during the Twentieth ...

    The Gypsies occupied a special place in Nazi racist theories, as they were so different to all over peoples which the Nazis had to deal with. According to a report submitted to Heinrich Himmler in 1941, there were some thirty nine thousand Gypsies in their empire, twenty eight thousand Gypsies in Germany, and an additional eleven thousand in Austria.

  2. Was the threat to Weimar greater from the left or from the right?

    There were other minor revolts from the left-wingers like the Sailors and Soldiers protests in Kiel, Bremen, Berlin, Munich, etc., Berlin Spartacist rising, Later strikes in Ruhr, Disturbances in Saxony and Thuringia, Joining of USPD with KPD and the strikes in Hamburg.

  1. Was the Weimar constitution flawed?

    By breaking up the nation into smaller sections Preuss hoped than power would be given to regional and local governments. Therefore Germany would be transformed into a unitary state - the states, due to their separation would be more reliant upon the centre.

  2. History Revision Notes. Key Topic 1: The Weimar Republic 1918-1933.

    The regular army was in no shape. So They turned to the Freikorps. The Freikorps were demobilised soldier, returning from war, who had refused to give their arms back. They were anti-communist and worked with the regular army. With the help of the Freikorps the Weimar government was able to put down the Spartacist uprisings in the early 1919.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work