• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Were the Peace Settlements after World War One Justified?

Extracts from this document...


Were the Peace Settlements after World War One Justified? The end of 1919 saw several peace treaties. Designed by the Allied leaders, the 'Big Three'- Georges Clemenceau of France, David Lloyd George of Britain and Woodrow Wilson of the United States, they dealt with the nations defeated in World War One. They were created to ensure a lasting peace, and to reward the victors of the war; however, were they justified? The Treaty of Versailles. This was accompanied by several controversies, for it was considered to be the harshest of the post-war treaties. It was a peace settlement designed to deal with Germany, and it imposed several unsympathetic restrictions and burdens upon her already frail shoulders. For example, the 'war guilt' clause that infuriated so many Germans. Germany was obligated to accept sole blame for initiating the war. This term was unfair; it was preposterous to blame a single nation for such a huge iniquity, especially a new government that was trying to replace the old Kaiser's regime with a democratic rule. Furthermore, several countries had shown signs of aggression during events leading up to 1914. Thus, it was unreasonable to accuse Germany for exclusively beginning the war which ravaged the lives of so many. Germany's disarmament was another term of the Treaty of Versailles. Her army was limited to a mere 100 thousand and her armored vehicles, aircraft and submarines were seized from her. ...read more.


Hence, Germany was outraged that, whilst her empire was no longer in existence, Britain's empire was expanding. This is seen as unjust by most, as Britain was thriving on Germany's losses. Perhaps the severest term of the peace settlement was the 'reparations' clause. Without consulting her, the Allies agreed to have Germany compensate France with �6.6 billion in reparations- a colossal amount that she could not afford. Her economy was already crippled; people did not have enough food or drink, and many were homeless. Furthermore, because she no longer controlled the Saarland or her overseas empires to support her finance, it was inequitable for the Allies to demand such ludicrous amounts of money. However, perhaps there were some justifications for Clemenceau's wish for such a large amount. It must be considered that France had been ravaged by four years of war; her industrial and residential areas wrecked and her landscape reduced to debris. Along with the Treaty of Versailles, four other treaties were created. The Treaty of St. Germain-this dealt with Austria-was formed in 1919. It proclaimed that Austria and Hungary would now be separate nations; this was to the joy of many. It forbade a union between Germany and Austria; this was not justified, because there were German speakers in Austria. Several Austrian territories were handed to the new states of Czechoslovakia and Yugoslavia, as well as to other countries. ...read more.


There were several positive outcomes of the peace settlements after World War One. The most significant one was the establishment of the League of Nations. This was the first-ever world organization of its kind; it aimed to discourage aggression for any nation, to encourage nations to disarm, and to improve the general working and living conditions of people. Britain, France, Italy and Japan were permanent members of the League. Surprisingly, USA was not involved in the League, although it was Woodrow Wilson who preliminarily mentioned such an organization in his 'Fourteen Points.' However, Germany was not invited to any meetings of the League, and therefore this incensed her. Other positive outcomes of the treaties include the self-determination of several countries, once again initiated by Wilson. The dreams of peoples who had been part of former empires finally came true; they gained independence. For example, the Czechs were overjoyed to finally be liberated, free from the clutches of the former Austrian Empire. The new state of Czechoslovakia was especially significant because it was created by the Allies for the future security of Europe. Although the Treaty of Versailles is usually depicted as relentless, it must be taken into account how challenging it was for Clemenceau, Lloyd George and Wilson to create an impartial treaty whilst meeting public demand for revenge. In conclusion, it is evident that the peace settlements after World War One can be perceived as both just and unjust. Reja Nadeem 10A Tuesday 14th October 2003 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE International relations 1900-1939 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE International relations 1900-1939 essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Was The Treaty Of Versailles Justified?

    5 star(s)

    The Germans objected that this treaty was, as was pointed out earlier in this passage, an act of revenge which, when and if Germany recovered, would result in an act of aggression in return. This was justified because if someone is not punished for committing a crime then they are likely to do it again.

  2. Summary of John Maynard Keynes' "The Economic Consequences of the Peace".

    Keynes regard the whole position "is in the highest degree artificial, misleading and vexation. We shall never be able to move again, unless we can free ourselves from these paper shackles".

  1. "Was the treaty of Versailles fair?"

    Aircraft carriers were also being developed with greater commitment. Submariners were trained abroad - Versailles did not cover this, so it did not break the terms of Versailles - only the spirit. * No air force was allowed. This happened but as with submariners, potential pilots were trained abroad or using gliders in Germany to educate them in the theory of flying.

  2. Why has Prussia replaced Austria as the leading Germanic power by 1870?

    However, other historians disagree. Some historians argue that Bismarck was in the right place at the right time, and instead of having a set plan for proceedings, he was swept along like the rest of the population. Although no-one can really argue against the fact that we was able to use the growth of

  1. were the paris peace settlements fair

    Germany's army was reduced to one hundred thousand men and were not allowed tanks. She was not allowed an air force, six naval ships but no submarines. Austria's army was reduced to thirty thousand men. This was due to the fact that the size of the country was reduced massively.

  2. Questions on World War One.

    "The feeling of Bismarck with regard to France explains the whole of his foreign policy." Discuss. Explain "the feeling of Bismarck with regard to France" Bismarck worried about a. war of revenge after France's revival b. republican/revolution tradition of France How did Bismarck's foreign policy reflect such feeling?

  1. The year of 1919 had Europe's feet placed firmly on the ground. It was ...

    The Triple Alliance then gave them the opportunity to "agree." In 1894, France and Russia signed a defensive alliance in an attempt to help each other in case a war was to break out. Britain would not sign the alliance due to its creed of splendid isolation, so France agreed for them to sign an entente that also included Russia.

  2. Why did international peace collapse in 1939?

    without the treaty taking Poland into Germany was in Hitler?s plan, and no matter what happened with the USSR he was still determined to get rid of communism. The Nazi-Soviet Pact was a short-term trick so he could safely take Poland into the Reich.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work