• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What are the strengths and weaknesses of source A as an interpretation of the role of Roosevelt in the New Deal? Explain your answer using source A and knowledge from your studies.

Extracts from this document...


The United States 1919-1941 1. What are the strengths and weaknesses of source A as an interpretation of the role of Roosevelt in the New Deal? Explain your answer using source A and knowledge from your studies. Source A has many strengths and weaknesses as an interpretation of the role of Roosevelt in the New Deal. As historians, we have to remember when studying the source is that this is just one interpretation; one account of the role of Roosevelt in the new deal. This already suggests one of the main limitations of the source. As the source has been extracted from a textbook, it is more than likely to be an objective interpretation as its purpose is to provide information to children. Contained in the source are facts and details known to be true. From previous research and other sources that Roosevelt did actually take part in the mentioned "fireside chats". We also know from previous studies that Roosevelt was a very popular president, the fact that he received "avalanches of mail" shows that the source is trustworthy. ...read more.


Patterson himself, may have had unknown personal motives for writing so positively about Roosevelt. He, obviously, supported Roosevelt's opinions, and because of this, he could have had an unintentional biased attitude. To conclude, I believe that this source is partly reliable, to an extent. However, in order to develop a greater understanding about Roosevelt's role in the new deal, a wider range of sources needs to be consulted. 2. Sources E and F are both sets of statistics. Which of these sources is the more useful to an historian studying the impact of the New Deal on the USA? Explain your answer using Sources E and F and knowledge from your studies. Both sources, E and F are of value to a historian studying the impact of the New Deal, to an extent. Source E is clearly useful as it shows us the unemployment figures in USA between 1929-1939. It is useful as it shows us that from when Roosevelt was elected president and the New Deal was underway, unemployment rates steadily decreased. Clearly, alphabet agencies such as CCC, PWA, and WPA were in full action at this time. ...read more.


However, the company who produced this leaflet probably had a negative experience of the new deal; they were most probably a republican company. They may have been lead into financial difficulty following the successes of the New Deal for other "ordinary" people. One must be careful when interpreting this source as it clearly is a method of propaganda that is trying to tarnish Roosevelt's name. The republicans are displaying their resentment towards Roosevelt, so in this sense, we must be cautious when examining its reliability. To conclude, overall, source E and F is both, useful and useless. Source E does provide us with basic information about unemployment rates and source F does give us a sound perspective of anti-Roosevelt opposition at that time. However, both sources are limited in the way that source E doesn't teach us anything about the other New Deal successes, like education and health. Source F, likewise, has its limitations as it does not give us a true reflection of what he was actually doing at the time. Both sources are different as they were written by different people, from different sides of the political spectrum, which ultimately makes each source serve a different purpose. Bridget O'Reilly History C/W ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE USA 1919-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE USA 1919-1941 essays

  1. Source D shows a report from the Jarrow Public Health Committee, published in 1933. ...

    Most women are giving birth in their homes and if their homes are in the same state as the one described in source D there is a high chance of the mother dying during labour because of the poor hygiene.

  2. The United States 1919-1941 - Roosevelt and the New Deal. What are the ...

    Source E is a useful source because it reveals the impact of Roosevelt's New Deal on unemployment in America, by comparing pre-New Deal statistics with post-New Deal statistics. In particular it shows the success of it, because unemployment fell during the years of the New Deal.

  1. T.Roosevelt and the New Deal.

    Roosevelt had increased the role of the Federal (central) government in America. It became much more involved in people's lives. Most Americans now accepted that the Federal government had a role to play in making sure the weaker sections of society - the unemployed, the homeless, the old and the poor - were looked after.

  2. Use Source A and your knowledge of the period to explain why people supported ...

    In source B is states that the people of America still had the power of free elections "All power is still in the hands of the people. They can vote out of power governments they do not like." Whereas in source C it describes that Roosevelt was acting like a

  1. How successful was the new deal? Explain why Roosevelt Introduced the New Deal?

    This may sound difficult but all FDR had do was do everything in opposite to the downward spiral which had lead to depression in the first place. He thought that if the government created more jobs, this would give the people more money to spend; this would create a greater demand for goods.

  2. Use the sources and your knowledge of American history to explain why there has ...

    Source K further emphasizes the benefits from deficit spending by saying "people were desperate" during the Depression so deficit spending on the New Deal's agencies would give them "a better chance in life." However, Source K came from Frances Perkins, Roosevelt's Secretary of Labor and close friend; therefore, she would

  1. The USA

    Source F is only reliable to an extent, because it was a speech that John F Kramer the first prohibition commissioners said in 1920, when prohibition had only just started. The source is written in the future tense, so he did not know what is going to happen.

  2. Prohibition - source based questions.

    Source C shows that in Philadelphia from1920-1925 the amount of arrests for drinking offences rose from 20, 443 to 58,517 it could be argued that this is showing that Prohibition failed to meet its aims because of the amount of offences, which were occurring.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work