• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What Reasons Did The HSCA Have in 1979 for Suggesting That President Kennedy Was the Victim of a Conspiracy?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

What Reasons Did the HSCA have in 1979 for Suggesting That President Kennedy Was the Victim of a Conspiracy? President John Fitzgerald Kennedy was the 35th president of the USA, an ex-soldier from Brookline, Massachusetts who was born on May 29th 1917. He beat Richard Nixon in the 1960 election by 120,000 votes, a very narrow victory. He was an idealist, and a controversial figure. He was the first Roman Catholic to be elected into office, and came from a privileged background, which meant many viewed him with mistrust and outright hatred. His policies were in start contrast to those of other presidents, and he had very different ideas for two of the most controversial topics at the time: The Soviet Union and Civil Rights. At the time, the USA and USSR were in the midst of the 'Cold War', and each side fought to control and dominate the others sphere of influence. This competition was reflected in the race for arms and to explore space. As well as conflict outside of its borders, there was unrest inside the USA. Black citizens had been oppressed for centuries, and sought to gain equal rights to the white population. They were led by iconic figures such as Martin Luther King and Malcolm X, Rosa Parks and W.E.B. Du Bois. These figures advocated peaceful protest and tolerance, which rendered any action by state-sponsored forces or civilian mobs to force protesters to disperse useless. On both of these topics Kennedy wished to pursue a path of peace and change. He offered wheat at the USSR as a gesture of peace, and proposed a new civil rights bill to congress. His actions sparked hatred amongst white supremacists and people in the southern states of America. Aside from the bigger issues, there were other important problems facing the Kennedy administration: unemployment was soaring in rural regions, crime was high in urban areas, there was no state benefits of care plan system for pensioners and the education system needed a re-vamp. ...read more.

Middle

He had a difficult childhood, as his mother married and divorced, he attended three different schools and it took him over 3 years to complete the third grade. His two brothers joined the Armed Forces, and from the age of twelve he lived alone with his mother. His continued bad behaviour at school led to him undergoing psychiatric treatment. Reports described Lee as 'seriously withdrawn, detached and very hard to reach'. But Oswald's mother would not comply with the authorities requests for sending Lee into psychiatric care, and they moved back to New Orleans. Around this time Lee became interested in Communism and he wrote letters to communist societies. Six days after his seventeenth birthday he joined the US Marine Corps and received basic weapons training. He came under court martial twice; once for abusing an officer and again for possession of an unregistered weapon. For a time, Lee lived in the Soviet union, where he married Marina Pruskova. He then returned to America and got a job at the Dallas Book Depository. Oswalds turbulent childhood and communist ideals suggests that he could have had strong reasons to kill the President, but his background also gives the impression he would have made an excellent fall-guy for a conspiracy. His life fits the profile of a deranged, lonely murderer perfectly. His weapons training would account for his ability to shoot Kennedy, but his affiliation with communist groups suggests it was unlikely he would have been working alone. The most suspicious part of the case involving Oswald was his death at the hands of Jack Ruby. The HSCA took down eyewitness reports that suggested that the two men knew each other. One witness said that they had seen the two men converse in Rubys nightclub, and two eye witnesses described a man who could have been the short, heavy set Jack Ruby standing on the same floor Oswald supposedly stood during the assassination. ...read more.

Conclusion

Their conclusions were 'four shots, over a period of 7.91 seconds were fired at the Presidential limousine. The first, second and fourth came from the depository, the third came from the grassy knoll.' This fits with the Zapruder film, and contradicts the Warren Commissions findings, compromising any theory of there being only one gunman. There were doubts over the Warren Commissions findings that needed to be addressed, and to an extent the HSCA confirmed that there was indeed a conspiracy. But the committee never found who the conspirators where. This highlights the reasons why the committee was set up, to help public relations. Its findings conflicted with those made at the time of the assassination, and this eased the public's suspicions. But still, no complete closure was ever made, with the only real suspect dead, and with most of the key evidence and witnesses gone forever. Evidence aroused suspicions of who the conspirators could have been. There have been several prominent ideas: 1) The Russian Communist Theory: the idea that the KGB had plotted to assassinate Kennedy, with help from double agents inside the USA. 2) The Pro-Castro Theory: The assassination was planned by Cuban intelligence, in conjunction with Fidel Castro. 3) The American Intelligence Theory: members of Americas own intelligence agencies had plotted to assassinate Kennedy. Some have also suggested that agencies and factions had worked together to kill Kennedy, but this is unlikely, as some would never have worked together ie Cuba and America. However, the conclusions made by the HSCA have their faults. The investigations were undertaken 13 years after the Warren Commission, and by that time most evidence, some very crucial, had been lost (eyewitness deaths etc). This would have made any investigation difficult and the findings less accurate. Also there could be unfair bias in the findings of the HSCA, as the whole purpose it was set up for was to ease the public's suspicion of the government. A new verdict confirming the public's doubts over the Warren Commission would be highly convenient, and so the neutrality of the investigation is questionable. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE History Projects section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE History Projects essays

  1. Discussing John Fitzgerald Kennedy.

    Although he did not state this in the letters. JFK was quite famous for his celebrity lifestyle, where he was seen as a fashion icon and he had a very admired wife in the public eye. The main cause for the fame of JFK was his assassination and the conspiracies

  2. Comparing Martin Luther King Jr. & Malcolm X

    When Martin Luther King Jr. took the stand in front of the Lincoln Memorial, on August 28, 1963 during the March on Washington for Jobs and Freedom, he affected audiences by storm. With his speaking style and content, he had helped inspire other blacks and whites; he informs humanity about the segregation and the issue.

  1. Do you agree that Martin Luther King was the most important factor in helping ...

    On other peaceful protests like the Selma to Montgomery March and protests in Alabama also helped the cause because of the actions of men like Eugene 'Bull' Connor and sheriff Jim Clark who treated the crowds of innocent peaceful protesters so badly and cruelly that their actions were looked down

  2. Roosevelt's New Deal

    Explain your answer. Sources H and I are both from the year 1936. The year 1936 was an election year and Roosevelt's supporters were trying their best to campaign for him by publishing letters and making songs. Source H is a letter published by Roosevelt's supporters as part of his campaign in 1936.

  1. Kenedy assassination

    Also 30 people heard the shootings come from the Depository where Oswald was at the time. Being 30 people makes the evidence of the shooting seem very precise so it would be hard for it to bee wrong with so many witnesses .There were also many witnesses that testified that

  2. From the evidence available, trace the development of the Jewellery Quarter in the ...

    An 18th century master jeweller would recruit an apprentice by advertising in a local newspaper or journal. These adverts would receive replies, and the master jewellers would pick apprentices from there. An advertisement in Aris' Birmingham Gazette, 22nd March 1756 states: "A person in Birmingham in a very clean trade

  1. Cause of Andover workhouse scandal?

    The workhouse form stated "Crush half a bushel of bones by hand through a quarter if an inch sieve" the form also stated "No such person should be detained against his or her will" This means that workers are expected to crush bones by hand through a sieve that was

  2. History of plastic surgery; how plastic surgery became a usual thing in Korea

    This is due to fact that Koreans tend to put big value of the western culture. They not only want to eat and buy the things from the western but also have the wants to even look like them. Well it does seem strange to me that Asians are born

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work