• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What were the gains and losses between 1861-1870 of the creation of Italy?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

What were the gains and losses between 1861-1870 of the creation of Italy? There are two main areas that must be looked at in order to explain the gains and losses between 1861-1870. These are Political unification, which is mainly to do with the domestic area and Geographical unification, which is mainly to do with Venetia and Rome. To start the idea of Political Unification D'Azeglio who was part of the Risorgimento said, "Italy is made, now we must make Italians." By this he meant that Italy needed to gain a sense of identity, seen as only two and a half per cent spoke Italian. There was poor communication due to the North and South divide as there were economic differences. The North was the urban part of Italy and was economically better then the rural south. There was a Piedmontese system imposed on the rest of Italy, which meant that the other states had to follow Piedmontese rules. The democratic idea was that there should be a constituent assembly, which would be composed of delegates from all parts of Italy and would decide on the format of the Italian government. Garibaldi had already proposed that Naples should gain a constitution. However after unification in 1861 the laws and the government of Piedmont were extended to all of the other states apart from Tuscany. Therefore the 'Statuto' of 1848 became the Italian constitution. From this it can be said that the creation of the new state in 1861 was more like an expansion of Piedmont than the unification of Italy. ...read more.

Middle

The other area that needs to be considered when weighing up the gains and losses of the creation of Italy is the geographical aspect. The Kingdom of Italy had been proclaimed in 1861, but still unification remained incomplete, as Rome was still run by the Pope and Venetia was still under the power of Austria. Cavour had already prior to this proclaimed that the kingdom should include Rome and Venetia and had already begun negotiations with the pope. However the Pope was disinclined to accept any of these requests, which made even gaining Rome difficult. In 1862 Garibaldi decided to take matters into his own hands and decided to march onto Rome. Victor Emmanuel who believed just like Garibaldi that they would have to take by force agreed to aid him. Garibaldi gathered 2000-3000 men and crossed over to the mainland to invade the Papal States. However their plot was revealed by mistake and so this meant that the Italian Government had to decide whether they would still go ahead with the expedition. Italy decided that it was not strong enough to appose the Great Powers and so to avoid a diplomatic blunder they disowned Garibaldi and allowed the Piedmontese army to stop him at Aspromonte. In 1864, two years later, the Prime Minister Minghetti was able by means of the September Convention to persuade Napoleon to evacuate his troops from Rome over a period of two years as long as the capital of Italy would be relocated from Turin to Florence and not Rome and that Victor Emmanuel would defend the Papal States in return. ...read more.

Conclusion

In 1870 France withdrew troops from Rome to defend the city of Paris, as they were in desperate need. In September Prussia had a decisive victory over the French at the Battle of Sedan. On the 8 September Victor Emmanuel sent a letter to the Pope requesting that they made an agreement that the Pope could still retain his religious position providing that he gave up his political power over Rome, but the pope refused. Consequently the Italian troops moved in on Rome, which was now unprotected by the French, as they had been required during the 1870 war. The Italian troops easily breached the walls of Rome and there were few casualties. On the 20 September Rome was annexed to the rest of Italy. Another plebiscite was held in Rome, which produced a positive result. This upset the pope and he decided to excommunicate Victor Emmanuel and the Italian Government, which meant that they were thrown out of the church. In conclusion it can be seen that there were many gains and losses to the creation of Italy. In my opinion there were more gains rather than losses as Italy had gained what it had set out to do, even though it may have taken some time due to a number of setbacks. The only major loss will have been to the Italian Government and Victor Emmanuel who had eventually been excommunicated from the church due their persistency to gain Rome and finally produce a properly Unified Italy. Rebecca Johnson Miss Garvie 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE International relations 1900-1939 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE International relations 1900-1939 essays

  1. To what extent was the unification of Prussia due to weaknesses of Austria?

    the setting up of the Erfurt Parliament by Prussia; this, again, added up to Austria's weaknesses, as now her Frankfurt Diet was rivalled by the Erfurt Parliament. Although the situation heated up between the two assemblies over the Hesse-Cassel dispute, forcing Prussia to abandon the Prussian Union Plan at the

  2. ITALIAN UNIFICATION

    his life would from now on be dominated by the ideas of a unified Italy. He then formed the movement Young Italy among exiled Italians. Unlike the Carbonari it would have clearly defined aims. His own political believes were based on believing that God existed, in the right of all

  1. To what extent was Austria the main obstacle to the unification of Italy in ...

    On the other hand Gioberti proposed an Italian confederation which would have the Pope as its president. Being a Papal Federalist he opposed the ideals of Young Italy and Mazzini. The effect of having such divided groups and leaders meant that the Italian nationalists could never agree and therefore could

  2. Why has Prussia replaced Austria as the leading Germanic power by 1870?

    ese two pieces of technology are small examples, but it shows how Prussia were progressing through reform and technology, whereas the 'stagnant Austrian Empire' was slow to industrialise, and therefore slow to build railways, and slow to discover new forms of weaponry.

  1. Describe the Different Stages to Italian unification between 1856 - 1871.

    The war ended with the Prussian victory at Sadowa. Austria acceded to the Geneva Convention three weeks later, on 21 July 1866. On October 3, by the Peace of Vienna, Venetia, which had been formally ceded to Napoleon III by Austria (due to the Treaty of Prague), was given to Victor Emmanuel 11.

  2. To what extent was Cavour a leader of the unification of Italy?

    With Napoleon sharing these fears, Cavour was able to invade the Papal States and successfully defeat Garibaldi and his army within Ten days of entry into the city of Naples. Cavour's interception of Garibaldi's 'Thousand' made the unification of Italy under the leadership of Piedmont and the government of Victor Emmanuel a reality.

  1. Unification Movements - Italian unification

    * German states called the Frankfurt Assembly (1848-49) to discuss the problem of unification. * In the Assembly, they tried to support Fredrick William IV to be the leader of the unification movement. * However, lots of problems emerged. * 1.

  2. To what extent does Cavour deserve his reputation as the architect of Italian Unification?

    Cavour's relationship with Garibaldi, which I will explore later is very much dependant upon Cavour's aspirations in Southern Italy. Certainly the above sources would suggest that in March 1860 Cavour is satisfied with what already is a considerable achievement for a small Italian states politician and diplomat.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work