• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Which Tsar was more autocratic-Alexander III or Nicholas II?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Which Tsar was more autocratic-Alexander III or Nicholas II? Pobedonostsev, who instilled in them strong beliefs in autocracy and nationalism, which were reflected throughout their reign, tutored both Tsars'. When comparing the two Tsars', the impact on the political and social system is significant and hints at which Tsar was more autocratic. Alexander and Nicholas were both autocratic politically, but Alexander was keener to uphold Autocracy. This involved setting up the Okhrana, as well as tightening censorship laws. Nicholas on the other hand made a significant impact on Russian history by introducing democracy to the Russian people, through the October Manifesto. ...read more.

Middle

Yet, a deeper analysis of both regimes can lead one to conclude that it was in fact Nicholas who was more autocratic. By transforming Russia into a modern democratic state, he also made his opposition more active and demanding, especially since they saw the power of the monarch decrease gradually in the western countries. Their protests became more politically motivated and some, such as the Bolsheviks even called for the collapse of Tsarism. Alexander responded to this with further repression, for example, the execution of the Vyborg in 1907. The pessimist school of History agrees that revolution was inevitable since Tsar Nicholas became more counter-productive further into his reign. ...read more.

Conclusion

Nicholas' impressive reforms, such as the national insurance act, Duma and success in economy cannot be paralleled with Alexander's lack of reform. Subsequently, it can be deduced that Alexander was more autocratic than Nicholas. Additionally, Alexander's program of Russification and hostility towards the Jews suggests he was a vicious and despotic leader, who was bound to be overthrown. Historians have described Alexander's period as one of counter-reform and when compared with Nicholas, it suggests that Alexander was more autocratic. In conclusion, Alexander was more autocratic than Nicholas. Interestingly, Alexander announced that he would abolish further reform and maintain autocracy on the day he came to power. Therefore, a reign of ruthlessness and terror, propelled by autocracy was an inevitable consequence. K. Kiani (KofE) ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 essays

  1. Why and with what results did Alexander II abolish serfdom in Russia?

    Another popular explanation as to why Alexander emancipated the serfs was that he wanted to modernize Russia. Raising the productivity of the Russian economy was one of the main motives for embarking on the emancipation of the serfs. After the 1861 emancipation, he introduced many other reforms in the military,

  2. Tsar Nicholas II

    Also there would have been fewer ideas given on how to improve the attitude of the people living in Russia and to help the country to evolve. Also the laws created will have suited the Tsar as he runs the and everything that would affect the Tsar badly in any

  1. "Alexander III bequeathed Nicholas II a revolution" (Trotsky) Discuss

    Alexander III sought to strengthen and centralize the imperial administration and bring it under his control. All the internal reforms which he initiated were intended to correct what he considered as the too liberal tendencies of the previous reign. In his opinion Russia was to be saved from revolutionary agitation by autocracy and Russification.

  2. Why and with what consequences did Alexander II adopt more reactionary policies in the ...

    Many opposed the Tsar's reforms and urged him to stop them before causing a revolution, as Russia had more change in 10 years altogether, than in the 150 years before. During Nicholas I's reign, there had been repressed revolutionary movements, which after his death, where performed by the students themselves.

  1. Lenin's Role in History

    Late at night, on the 25 October, Trotsky's red Guards helped by the Kronstadt sailors took over the bridges in Petrograd and the telephones lines. They cut off Petrograd off from the rest of Russia. The Red Guards took over the Government buildings, the banks and the railway station.

  2. How valid is the view that the reign of Alexander II achieved nothing of ...

    This, although not overly harsh since they had to be paid for 49 years so serfs were secure in the knowledge that their lands would safely be passed on to their children, did have flaws - if a "bread-winning" family member fell ill or died and the family fell behind

  1. How successfully did Alexander III extend his authority throughout the Russian Empire?

    They held the Tsar personally responsible for their problems which resulted in many violent incidents erupting throughout the countryside and the support for the Tsar decreasing severely. By 1889 Zemstva justices of the peace had been replaced by Land commandants; landed nobility chosen by the Tsar to hold positions of

  2. How successful was Tsar Alexander 2nd in Solving the problems facing Russia During his ...

    It was not only the social aspects of Russia which were suffering, the agricultural Industry was at an all time low, with only 50% of all the farm production sold as surface goods. This low output of goods crippled the Russian economy, and as a result many Nobles were facing Bankruptcy.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work