• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Who do you believe built Castell Morgraig?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Who do you believe built Castell Morgraig? Coursework Most castles in Wales have well documented histories, enabling historians to figure out who built them, where they were built, and what purpose they served. However, some castles remain a mystery with few or no written records such as Castell Morgraig. Over the years, since its discovery in 1895, Morgraig has been a subject of fierce historical debate. Due to the castle being in such a bad state of repair when found, many archaeologists found it impossible to determine who built it; and since then, many historians have come to their own conclusions. The castle was built right on the border between Welsh and Norman lands, and therefore could have been useful for both sides to have. For example, Thomas Gill states: "Either the Welsh or the English could have made use of a castle on this site". On balance, Most evidence suggests that Castell Morgraig was Wesh built because of the location it has been built in and its style of build. ...read more.

Middle

John Owen says, "The four flanking towers at Morgraig are typically Welsh D - shaped apsidal towers...Their presence at Morgraig indicates a North Welsh influence". Evidence also suggests that Morgraig was welsh built due to poor workmanship on the castle. This was usual for the Welsh but not expected of the Normans who had far better skilled craftsmen. J.G Owens says, "I find it difficult to believe that an English Mason would produce such poor quality". Most Welsh castles have ditches around them, but when Morgraig was Discovered there were none. This has been used as an argument to suggest the castle was Norman, but although a ditch would provide defence, it would also make constructing the castle very difficult, as Morgraig was built on the uneven crest of a ridge. Also, the ditches might have been never added to the site, simply because it was never finished. Castle Morgraig was built with Sutton stone and many historians debate fiercely that Sutton stone would have been impossible to transport from Norman controlled land all the way in Ogmore. ...read more.

Conclusion

Many historians also believe that the location would have been an ideal place to plan attacks and see invading Norman enemies from miles away; even across the Bristol Channel. There is a large possibility that the castle was built in order to defend the Welsh border and stop any Normans coming into Glamorgan. The castle could also have been built in order to control what goods left and came into Welsh territory. Many historians argue that Morgraig could have been built as a political statement, a symbol of Llewelyn ap Gruffudd's growing power or even as a symbolic statement to challenge the power of the de Clares who were great enemies of the Welsh and of Llewelyn at this time. J.Owens states, "In my opinion the establishment of a castle at Morgraig was a political statement by the Lords of Senghennydd to define their Southern boundary''. In conclusion, most evidence suggests that the welsh built Castell Morgraig. It is probable that Prince Llewelyn ap Gruffudd built it as a base of attack and to watch over Norman controlled Cardiff. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE History Projects section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE History Projects essays

  1. History - Castles Coursework

    When the castle became a home a lot of the defensive features were removed and replaced with non-defensive features, finally after the castle was used for defence, as an administrative centre and a home it then became a tourist attraction for people today.

  2. Warwick castle Coursework

    The first of these improvements at Warwick happened around 1450, which was the gatehouse being enlarged as well as the killing ground and the barbican being added. The next improvement took place around 1540, this was two towers being added to the walls.

  1. Was Oystermouth Castle typical of the castles built in Wales during the middle Ages?

    It was also built on steep slopes, which provided a good view to the sea and the east. It is located on the western of two ridges overlooking the southern end of Swansea bay and the town of Mumbles. The eastern ridge would have provided a better view of the sea, yet wouldn't have provided a suitable water supply.

  2. "The castle today is a ruin, it is therefore of very little use to ...

    totally transformed the castle more into how we know it today. He spent a large amount of money altering the structure and upgrading the royal chambers but his most lavish expense on the castle was an artificial lake which a thousand people worked on.

  1. During the Medieval Period why was it important for nobles to build castles?

    This was also fenced in with a wooden palisade and housed what was, more or less, a small village. In this way, a motte and bailey could almost be self sufficient with animal pens and such they could survive for an extended length of time if needs be.

  2. Objective histories.

    historical study, such as whether history is a subject of practical social relevance or whether history should be studied for its own sake as believed by academic historians such as G.R.Elton. Their argument is based on the grounds that 'relevant' history is incompatible with the historian's primary obligation to be

  1. Why was a castle built and maintained in York?

    this is the time in which York castle began to be seen as part of York's landscape. In 71AD the Romans situated themselves in York to build a fort. They saw York as a perfect place to settle as there were two rivers (Foss & Ouse)

  2. St.David's effect on Christianity in Wales

    Around the year 550, David attended a synod at Brevi in Cardiganshire. His contributions at the synod are said to have been the major cause for his election as primate of the Cambrian Church. He was reportedly consecrated archbishop by the patriarch of Jerusalem while on a visit to the Holy Land.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work