• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Why did it prove so difficult to find a solution to the Irish question during the period 1912-22?

Extracts from this document...


Why did it prove so difficult to find a solution to the Irish question during the period 1912-22? There were many different groups of people with different views representing the Nationalists, the Ulster Unionists and The British government during this time period. Nationalists consisted of moderate, normal Irish Catholics to extreme Irish Nationalists such as those in the IRA and Sinn Fein. The British government changed from Liberal to Conservatives and thus their outlook on Home Rule changed too. These factors, complicated by external ones, made agreements on how to solve the Irish problem extremely hard to reach. The Liberal Home Rule Bill that was introduced in 1912 contained flaws. The Liberal aim was to please both Republicans and Unionists. However this meant making the bill more moderate than Gladstone's previously proposed one, whilst assuming that the Unionist resistance was only superficial. Therefore the bill was too moderate for many Republicans and made without any real consent from the Unionists. Furthermore, Redmond needed to maintain his credibility as a nationalist Irish leader, whilst the stubbornness of the Unionists meant that they would not give way. ...read more.


This continued to be an obstructing factor to each attempt made by Asquith. This was also at a time in which the UVF were authorised to use arms and a civil war was drawing near. The amending bill produced by Asquith was dismissed by Carson as a 'stay of execution' and was in any case destroyed by the House of Lords. When the Home Rule Act was finally passed in 1914, its actual functioning was put on hold until after the war finished. Therefore the First World War only further delayed any overall solution regarding the Irish question from being made. The war dragged on much longer than the Nationalist's had expected and with the appointment of Carson and other leading Unionists to Asquith's coalition ministry in 1915, the implementation of the Home Rule Act seemed even more remote. This resulted in the extreme nationalist's actions in the Easter Rebellion, 1916. However this was only supported by the extreme nationalists themselves and many normal ant-unionists resented it and deemed it traitorous. In fact it only proved to be another obstacle to Home Rule and it frustrated Redmond who felt it only hindered Ireland's chances of obtaining Home Rule. ...read more.


The incidents of the Anglo-Irish war left the British government disillusioned with the IRA who were undergoing a murder campaign against the British troops. Lloyd George and his cabinet's refusal to recognise the war in Ireland, together with the IRA and Sinn Fein becoming proscribed organizations only increased tensions and the war to progress. The Anglo-Irish war brought nothing but deaths, and with Britain not prepared to carry out a full-scale war against the Irish, a truce was eventually reached in 1921. After much negotiation and discussion the British, the Ulster Unionists and even Sinn Fein agreed to the Anglo-Irish treaty of 1921. To conclude, it was very difficult to find a solution to the Irish question during the period 1912-1922 as there was always a lack of agreement between the sides involved. The aims and the extremity of the Irish Nationalists and the British government never seemed to be clear. Furthermore, external factors such as the Anglo-Irish war, World War I and the different organizations that emerged only complicated matters further. The 'solution' that was eventually established only took place after a lot of concessions made from both the British and the Irish. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Northern Ireland 1965-85 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Northern Ireland 1965-85 essays

  1. Parnell and the Irish Question Why did Gladstone fail to pacify Ireland?

    House of Lords, Home Rule was doomed to fail from the outset. Even many committed Gladstonians considered that 'to continue with it in such circumstances seemed...sheer perversity'4. The Bill failed and Gladstone resigned within months. Despite Gladstone's 'mission to pacify Ireland' he had failed.

  2. In what ways did the Irish Question change between 1800 and 1922?

    Most historians agree because J.C Beckett writes '1829 proved a more important turning point in the history of modern Ireland than 1800,' because at last some changes had begun to occur in order to pacify Ireland even though there was still a long way to go.

  1. "The Failure of the British to Solve the Irish Question Arises From Ignorance and ...

    This is what upset the Catholic minority. Looking back at this period, perhaps if Westminster had had more involvement the political and social injustices may not have become so entrenched over the next 30 years. Maters were getting progressively worse for Catholics in Northern Ireland.

  2. The Irish Question

    This was clearly evident when between 50'000 and 100'000 people attended the funeral of Bobby Sands. This particular upsurge in support for the IRA, meant increased support for their 'political voice' in Sinn F�in. The British government were not happy with this as they did not want the IRA to

  1. Why Did ‘Bloody Sunday’ Take Place? (Russian History Sources Question)

    Source I also agrees with the view that Bloody Sunday was caused by poor living and working conditions. It is a diagram of the growth of the industrial production in Russia from 1890-1900. It shows that there was a huge influx of workers into the cities as there was a

  2. How Effectively did Irish Catholic and Nationalist Leaders advance their Cause in the years ...

    John Redmond agreed to accept the suspension of the home-rule legislation for the duration of the war and declared his party's total support for the war effort. Carson and the Unionists did the same. Many Irish Nationalists were unhappy about Redmond's pledge of unconditional support and nationalism as a movement began to divide.

  1. The 1913 lockout, 1916 rising, the treaty of 1921 and the causes of the ...

    He was in charge of the political and the military wings of both. With this there the two were united which was very unusual. In early 1918 the British were seriously short on troops for the western front. The Germans had begun a bombardment 40 miles wide on France.

  2. the Irish question

    King James I who succeeded Elizabeth continued to do this throughout his reign too. This was bound to make the Catholic Irish nationalists resentful as the English Protestants were stealing their land, simply because they were Catholics. This land would have probably been in the Catholics' families for generations and would be their whole livelihood.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work