Obviously the good idea of a fair treaty for both sides was getting worse when they made
new borders. Germany lost important land for farming and industry, people who lived
in areas which were not anymore their home countries had to leave, when the
colonies became independent they were totally hopeless, they had no infrastructure,
education system and no experiences how to rule a country. East-Prussia
was cut of from the rest of Germany. Danzig was made a free city which confused the inhabitants. Romania, Greece and Denmark which were not involved in the war received all land from the defeated countries for no plausible reason. In conclusion in view on the countries was the treaty not well reasoned and unfair for the Germans. It was impossible for the winners to divide the land fairly.
The military ideas of the treaty were better reasoned and not that bad but still
badly done. Germany just was allowed to have an army up to 100 000 men and
this is not enough to protect such a big country like Germany in case of war. It also had to melt down all his weapons to scrap metal, this was one of the better ideas in this treaty because this material could be used for the industry. The idea that Germany was not allowed to have an airforce was as unfair as that Germany was not allowed to have submarines.The really small navy about 15000 men was as unfair as that Germany had to give up almost her whole trade navy . All the winner countries were allowed to keep their navies armies airforce and tanks. Germany and Austria were forbidden to make an alliance was definitely not justified and therefor unfair. Both were blamed and not able to fight another war anymore, it was just not necessary and blamed both countries as well. The military policy proved the total failure of the Versailles Treaty. It was just unfair that the countries who won the war were allowed to have armies and that the countries who lost the war were almost totally helpless without an army to protect their land in case of war or even riots.
An irrefutable evidence for a failed treaty was the confession(article 231) of Germany
that they had to accept the total blame for the whole first world war, that Germany were not allowed to take part in the treaty and the absolutely not justified amount of reparations. The winners were allowed to take all properties of Germany which was not anymore Germany. Germany was defeated for decades with the huge value of reparations, which was just not fair. In conclusion the criticism of Germany to the Versailles Treaty was totally justified because it was unfair. The losers were totally blamed and not able to protect themselves without an justified army. The colonies were absolutely helpless because they were just albatrosse of the winners. This treaty was an act of rage and unfairness for the German people, it was good for one thing, to show how hard policy can fail.