• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

World War Two Evacuation Sources Questions

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

1) 2) Study Sources B and C. Which source is more useful as evidence about the start of the childrens evacuation journey? Explain your answer using sources B and C and knowledge from your own studies. Source B and source C both had advantages and disadvantages in relation with each other and sources in general, first I will evaluate them both and then reach a conclusion answering the title question. One of the main advantages source B has, is that it was taken (photo image) in 1939 at the time of evacuation during WW2, also the fact that it is a photo gives it advantages, but it also has flaws. The main handicap of a photo, is that it could have been posed for and their would be no obvious evidence to prove or disprove that it is a staged photo. Using my background information on evacuation during WW2, I think it is unlikely the picture is posed because during the start of the journey they thought it was just another trip with their class, with their friends. They were not informed and could not foresee that they would be split up and that they would be placed into an unknown environment. ...read more.

Middle

In my opinion source B would be more useful from a historians point of view if their were 2 or 3 photos at least of the beginning of evacuation. This would give a broader view, showing the historian more perspectives and perhaps and obvious change in emotions from the people in the picture. This would also help the historian see if the start of evacuation was well prepared or disorganised. Source B's main flaw is the time in which it was written, in 1988 after WW2 had ended. It also does not specify if the teacher actually experienced the war herself. Suggesting that she could have just made up the information given, or copied it form unreliable text; although from reading/studying many other evacuation sources I would say this is on the right lines of how evacuation began. As source C is a written source, it gets rid of a lot of the limitations a photo has, but it also encounters some limitations that a photo doesn't, such as its reliability. As it would be very difficult to tamper with a picture, yet it is easy to adjust a written source. ...read more.

Conclusion

Although it could mean the picture source shows a group of friends being evacuated as a class and source C describing a mix of people who do not know each other. In which case it would be unlikely that they would be talking as they have never met before and would be separated from them shortly anyway. Using my previous knowledge on the topic of evacuation, I would say source C is more useful, purely because it gives feelings and emotions about the occasion. Source B gives more information on how the children were assembled and what clothes they were wearing, this information is also factual and useful; but in my opinion not as useful as a proper account on how the journey to evacuation felt. Yet both sources are useful because I think they are equally reliable. Source B has the flaw of possibly being posed and source C has no dating. These flaws give the sources limitations, but makes them equally reliable because they both have one major defect. Source C also agrees more with my own knowledge, as I think it more likely the children would be distressed about going to evacuation; rather than joyous as they are shown in source B. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Britain 1905-1951 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Britain 1905-1951 essays

  1. Britain And The Western Front - Sources Questions

    They attacked to help distract the enemy from the French at Verdun and also to wear down the enemy as much as possible by attrition. Question 7: How might the advice given in source G have influenced Haig in the planning of the Somme offensive?

  2. Women's Suffrage Sources Questions

    Then in November the government changed its mind and instead introduced a Franchise bill, which did not mention women but aid that Parliament could add women to the bill if desired. When MP's said that it wanted to introduce women to this, they were told that it would change the

  1. Gallipoli Questions

    As we can see from the map, to gain control of the Dardanelles from being dropped off would involve around 100km walking, and at the same time dealing with attacks from the Turks. Had the plan been executed swiftly it would have succeeded I think.

  2. Why do sources A to F differ in their attitudes to the evacuation of ...

    The author would not want this as the purpose of the book is probably to make money and inform. Therefore the author would not have included any bad experiences of evacuation and would possibly have added in more pleasant experiences of evacuation.

  1. Free essay

    why do sources A to F differ in their attitudes to the evacuation of ...

    Source D is an advertisement issued by the government in 1940. The advertisement features a plea from the Secretary of State; who had been entrusted by the government with the conduct of evacuation, calling for more people in Scotland to offer their homes to house children that needed to be evacuated.

  2. How useful is Source G when examining the children's evacuation journey?

    However some of the information in the novel does back up my own knowledge, for instance the awkwardness between the families and foster children is underlined. Even though the information does back up my own knowledge, it is still unreliable because it is a made up story for children.

  1. Haig in sources

    The third book "The official history of the Great War", published by the British government (1938 edition). It reads "British and French losses 623,907 and German losses 680,000." To me these figures seem reasonable; Germany had lost the war and therefore should have the higher number of deaths.

  2. Why do sources A-F differ in their attitudes to the evacuation of children

    This is not a reliable source as it is fictitious and only the director's interpretation of what evacuation was like. None of the actors would have had any experience of the evacuation process and, like the director; it is just their interpretation.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work