• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

My Graduation Speech by Neil Postman, chair of the Department of Culture and Communication at New York University, describes two kinds of people, whom he compares with Athenians and Visigoths.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Arunee Kasemphaibulsuk Ms Goldspink ENG4U-02 November 9, 2005 The Dominance of Visigoths My Graduation Speech by Neil Postman, chair of the Department of Culture and Communication at New York University, describes two kinds of people, whom he compares with Athenians and Visigoths. The Athenians, who lived in Greece about 2,500 years ago, contributed many positive ideas still valued in the present. They believed in reason, beauty, moderation, and excellence. Postman also wrote about negative values, which belonged to the Visigoths in Germany about 1700 years ago. Visigoths did everything for their own benefits, lived only for overcoming others' culture and ideas; they were crude, brutal, destructive, and greedy. Since Postman wrote this speech, it appears that Visigoth values have become an even more dominant and powerful influence, as seen clearly from three media: the television program Extreme Makeover provides an example of the obsession with popularity and money; the movie Mr. ...read more.

Middle

Smith, the story follows a couple of assassins who do not know each other's secret career, and finally are hired to kill each other. The fighting, the violence, the cruelty are all Visigoth characteristics. Even though they are married, they lack the Athenian qualities of respect, consideration, and compromise between the two of them. For example, during a fight, Mr. Smith says "Come to Daddy." Mrs. Smith responds by beating him to the floor and says "Who's your Daddy now?" Mr. and Mrs. Smith always direct sarcastic remarks at each other. The characters in the movie, like the Visigoths, use rude, insulting language. Also, because Mrs. Smith says, "Oh, come on. It was just a little bomb," she shows her own Visigoth idea that using force is very trivial. This movie imprints the bad Visigoth idea of force, opposed to the good Athenian value of persuasion, onto the audience's minds. The concentration on the advertising of this movie in North American society and its success in the market show that people accept Visigoth ideas. ...read more.

Conclusion

From the evidence in two articles in The Globe and Mail, people in positions of power have self-centered, materialistic ideas as Visigoths did. They desired a luxurious life-style gained by no effort or wasted a million dollars without considering the Athenian ideas such as the sense of moderation, compromise, and dedication. The crude, selfish, and self-centered behaviour of Visigoths, which competes with the respect for beauty, reason, and moderation of the Athenians, is predominant in our civilization: the obsession with money from the Extreme Makeover television program, the violence in relationships in the movie Mr. and Mrs. Smith, and the self-interest of humanity in the Globe and Mail newspaper articles. According to Postman, the numbers of people who see the world in the Visigoth way appear greater than the numbers of people who think like Athenians, because the majority of people do things for money, lack the sense of community, are not temperate, reject tradition, use rude language, and learn to manipulate other people for their own power. The only hope for society, according to Postman, is that among university graduates "the Athenians mightily outnumbered the Visigoths" (Postman). ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Communications section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Communications essays

  1. OCR GCSE Business & Communication Task 7 Report

    Task 4c: Mail Merge Software: For my mail merge I used the programme Microsoft Word. This programme is suitable for my task as it supplies many tools which help to professionalize and establish a high quality email. This programme equips me with the justification tool.

  2. Organisational behaviour - The Royal Mail

    Mr Leighton said preliminary figures were also indicating that quality of service to customers during the Christmas period was among the best levels in at least a decade. Christmas trading figures show that for the first time, Royal Mail's revenue across the company exceeded �800 million in one month.

  1. Bussines and Communication Systems

    fax knows where it has come from and how m any pages are being sent. The first page of the fax is called the fax header. 3 advantages of using a facsimile machine are: * Messages can be sent quickly when compared with letters * Exact copies of the message,

  2. ICT Systems in Everyday Life: Your Local Community

    This is perhaps one of the pillars of current thinking in electronic exhibition. There are some one hundred and fifty trial digital cinema systems in the world today. These include installations in China, Singapore, and Thailand. Definitions being important, the term "trial digital cinema system" is carefully chosen.

  1. special needs

    were facing physical disability couldn't attend meetings if there current status was impossible for them to do so i.e. electronic wheel chair needing replacement. Therefore, these people will fill depressed because of the fact that they aren't able to work how a normal individual could have but thanks to the

  2. Free essay

    Impact of ICT in Community

    The signal bounces off whatever is in front of it and then sends the signal back to me. It might go to a foot on each side so you can use it to the left or the right and pick up things.

  1. Full Course howard health centre

    Also images can be inserted and edited and manipulated. There are also many useful tools like spell check which help the user create documents with accuracy. If this program did not suit the user they could replace it with programs like word pad or note pad but these do not have as many features as Microsoft word.

  2. An Investigation into Business Communication

    could be talking to Graham Smith (finance director) possibly about a new product. Diagonal communication takes place across the hierarchy between people at different levels. For example if there were several departments in a store and each department had a manager and many employees, in this case a staff from one department would communicate with a manager from another department.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work