• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Evaluation of Murder

Extracts from this document...


Homework- Evaluation of Murder A good law should be clear so both the judge and jury can apply it in a reasonable way, this makes it easier for the jury to follow and provides a consistent outcome. It should be consistent, if not one person could do exactly the same crime as another and they could have completely different sentences. Consistency makes the law fair which is another important element of a good law. The law should reflect the degree of fault and punish the defendant in a suitable way; this also provides justice for the family within the law. It should also provide a defence this also makes the law fair and also provides justice for the defendant as it will reflect the degree of fault. A good law could also be flexible. The actus Reus of murder involves the time limit. The law reform act abolished the original year and a day rule and introduced a new time limit. ...read more.


spite) or aforethought (i.e. planned or premeditated). The Mens Rea for murder is interpreted as an intention to kill or cause GBH. This is a common law definition and is subject to change, making it flexible but also causing uncertainty. There are problems with intention also because it has never properly been defined and cases like Moloney and Hyam only set out guidelines and judges tend to alter between the two. This causes confusion and uncertainty and leads to jury's verdicts being unfair and inconsistent. It also means that the decision is opened up and leads to members of the jury being influenced by personal prejudices. The mens rea of implied malice means a defendant can be convicted of murder and given a life sentence without either intending to kill or foreseeing death as a virtual certainty. This has been strongly critisised in Moloney as unfair because two people could be convicted of murder even though their crimes are completely different. ...read more.


In A-G's Reference (No.3 of 1994), [1997] a man stabbed his pregnant girlfriend. The shock brought on labour and the baby was born 8-10 weeks prematurely and after 4 months, the baby eventually died, as a result of the premature birth. The defendant was charged with the murder of the baby. This brought about the question of whether a foetus is a human being. One possible reform would be to include a foetus as a human being but have separate legislation setting out rules over abortion. Altogether I think the law on murder is satisfactory. However I think certain proposals for reform should be taken into consideration to make the law better. I think English law should follow the example of American law on different degree's of murder as personally I believe it is morally wrong and unfair to treat certain cases of murder like that of R v Cox in the same light as R v Brady and Hindley (1966) for example, who tortured and murdered several children for no apparent reason. I also think the wording of the mens rea should be changed to make it clearer and more consistent. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Law section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Law essays

  1. Should Capital Punishment be enforced

    They believe that even if such executions have occurred, chances are very slim. Imprisoning innocent people is also wrong, but it is impossible to empty the prisons because of that minimal risk. Due to the thorough systems of appeals through numerous states and federal courts, they believe that the execution of an innocent individual today is almost impossible.

  2. The Law Relating to Negotiable Instruments

    time is called a Muddati or Miyadi Hundi-the time bill of exchange. * Shah Jog Hundi A shah means a respectable and responsible person, a man of worth, and known in the bazar. A Shah Jog Hundi is payable to or through a shah.

  1. Using actual situations describe the elements of actus

    there is an honest belief based on reasonable grounds that force is necessary. Forcible resistance may not be carried to the point of taking life when it is otherwise possible to retreat safely from the assailant. If more force than is necessary is used to repel the attack, the person will be liable both civilly and criminally for assault.

  2. Law in association with the criminalisation of certain drugs.

    Legalisation could also promote the message that drug use condoned- this alludes to moral issues, and whether it can ever be justifiable to live in a community where the intoxication of illicit substances is tolerated. However, as Wodak and Moore emphasise, it is inconceivable that legalisation 'would ever gain community

  1. The common law offence of Murder has witnessed a complicated development in its definition ...

    Initially juries were directed along rather narrow lines in Vickers9, put simply, if the jury were certain the defendant intended to kill, or cause GBH, they were to return a guilty verdict10. Whether the tomes of jurisprudence, and academic debate, have advanced such a direction is debatable and will be picked up later in the essay.

  2. Criminal Law (Offences against the person) - revision notes

    judge said it was different to Nedrick because there were 2 pieced of evidence relating to the AR. 1) Initially denied all knowledge (Had guilt in his mind) 2) Then confessed Criminal Justice Act 1967 - 'Jury must consider all evidence ...

  1. Discover whether, in the criminal law, negligence ever breaks the chain of causation and ...

    if A and B, independently of each other, shot at P and hit him, simultaneously, in the head and the heart, they would both be held to have caused P's death. The rule that the act must be a sine qua non of the event is only a starting point.

  2. One of the greatest tragedies in life is the murder of a beautiful theory ...

    Had they responded to his call as they would have to a similar call from a woman, the whole tragedy might well have been avoided. The police should now take on board the reality of Home Office Report 191 and be prepared to act on the fact that women are equally as violent as men.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work