• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What are the criticisms of the current law on Voluntary manslaughter?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

What are the criticisms of the current law on Voluntary manslaughter? Voluntary Manslaughter, set out in the Homicide Act 1957, was established as a substitution for murder in certain circumstances. If there is evidence of Diminished responsibility then murder may be substituted for manslaughter. Diminished responsibility can be a form of insanity an 'abnormailty of mind' which is somewhat advantageous if you can prove this, as would be evidence of Provocation, Infanticide or the participation of a Suicide Pact. If the defendant is convicted of Murder, there is a mandatory life sentence and will definitely be imprisoned for a term usually no less than 12 years. However, if convicted of Voluntary Manslaughter, which still embeds the Actus Reus and Mens Rea of Murder, 'malice aforethought', and the defendant may be sentenced at the discretion of the Judge. In some cases this has amounted to a full life sentence anyway, but there have also been a few where the defendant has been given a suspended sentence. Aside from this fact, is the current law on voluntary manslaughter satisfactory or is it too readily available as a defence against Murder, making the law too forgiving of serious crime? ...read more.

Middle

In Johnson 1989 the defendant made uncivil comments to the victim who then in return threatened the defendant with a glass bottle and Johnson then stabbed the victim with a flick-knife. The Court of Appeal allowed Voluntary Manslaughter, however at the first hearing of this trial the jury had disagreed because the Provocation was brought about by the defendant. Some people feel that self-induced provocation is very unfair, the defendants actions however will be looked upon by the judge as an aggravating factor and it is unlikely that they will get a greatly reduced sentence. Again more problems arose with one of the elements of Provocation to Voluntary Manslaughter and that was that 'a sudden loss of control' needs to be exercised. The problem with cases like Alhuwalia 1992 and Humphreys 1995, is that there was no 'sudden and temporary loss of control'. What is now considered and accepted by the current law is the 'slow burn' principle of Battered Woman's Syndrome. But there is no way to establish when exactly the line burns out or to what extent women's self control differs from men's. ...read more.

Conclusion

The criticisms that I personally raise on the current law of Voluntary manslaughter are that it doesn't help those that it always should. For example the policy on Diminished Responsibility is that this has to be ''abnormality of mind' not caused by drugs or alcohol. However what about those on prescription drugs such as O'Connell 1997. Should there not be a provision for these people or those who have been deceived and taken drugs or alcohol unknowingly? Also, a topic that should be considered is that when it comes to Voluntary Manslaughter it can be easy to be overcome by legal technicalities and to forget that it is there to prevent injustice. In Martin 2001 there have been comments that Martin Misused the law as he claimed that in protecting his property from burglars he shot them because of his 'Paranoid personality Disorder' this seems to have gone too far and that the courts may begin to disagree once more. Roe, Diana. Criminal Law, 2000, Hodder & Stoughton Roe, Diana, Criminal Law 2nd edition, 2002, Hodder and Stoughton Nutcases Criminal Law 2nd edition, 1999, Sweet and Maxwell www.ilearnatlewes.co.uk/LawWithFrames/Module4/module4_index.htm www.sprocket1.demon.co.uk/wendyhomepage/conclusion.html - By Wendy Hesketh www.lawcom.gov.uk www.stbrn.ac.uk ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Law section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Law essays

  1. Study the concept of Reasonable man and reasonability in tort law.

    difficult to decide when ether has been an intervening act of a third party, whether the defendants act has caused the damage suffered by the plaintiff. It is important to note that he issue of causation becomes material only afeter the failure of the defendant to take due care has been proved.

  2. Offences against the person act 1861; criticisms and reforms.

    Another criticisms is that although section 20 is seen as more serious than section 47, with 20 being GBH and 47 being ABH, they share the same maximum sentence of five years which doesn't reflect the seriousness of section 20 as a crime.

  1. Criminal Law (Offences against the person) - revision notes

    Was the aft aimed at the victim? Particularly in arson cases defendants would claim his act was only aimed at the building etc... however, as long as the victim dies, the law will include victim in the defendant's range of intention.

  2. What is an indictable offence and how is it brought to trial?

    Second, the United Kingdom is obliged to legislate to implement obligations arising from EU membership. Council Directive 93/104 requires all member states to introduce legislation restricting the working week to no more than 48 hours except in certain types of work or where the employee works additional hours voluntarily.

  1. Law in association with the criminalisation of certain drugs.

    Hence exaggeration and sensationalism are prevalent within stories, in an attempt to attract reader attention.19 4.0 - Enforcement of Modern Drug Policy Statutes have provided the police with increasingly greater powers in an attempt to fight the 'drug war.' In times of war, 'extraordinary measures' are needed, yet these are

  2. Property, Liberty, and the Law

    One very large debate comes out of the numerous patent cases involving this computer giant, is Microsoft insecure with its own technology that they must get rid of any competition. As my paper discusses earlier, one of the main reasons we need world wide patent laws is because we want

  1. The Age Of Criminal Responsibility

    the Ministry of Defence regarding the age of criminal responsibility and their views on the issue. The Guardian Special Report In 2001, in connection with the killing of James Bulger by two young boys, the Guardian compiled a special report.

  2. The Law Relating to Negotiable Instruments

    to all parties subsequent to the party, for whose honor tic accepts to pay the amount of tile bill if the drawee does not; such party and all prior parties are liable, in their respective capacities to compensate the acceptor for honor for all loss or damage sustained by him in consequence of such acceptance (Sec.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work