• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Investigating Gender Differences in Helping.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Investigating Gender Differences in Helping.

Aim: To find out whether subjects will help opposite gender students faster than same sex helper would.

Introduction: Altruism is a form of pro-social behaviour in which a person will voluntarily help another at some cost to themselves. The primary motivation for altruistic behaviour is seen as a desire to improve the welfare of another person rather than the anticipation of some reward or for any other reason that might indicate self-interest. One of the major problems for psychologists has been determining what is truly altruistic and what might be better explained in terms of egoism. Batson et al.’s (1997) empathy-altruism hypothesis proposes that empathic concern evokes an altruistic motivation. Studies supporting this hypothesis have systematically varied whether individuals can only obtain egoistic goals by helping, or whether they can escape from the situation and obtain the egoistic goals without helping. These studies demonstrate that at least some people have helping intentions that are not explained by egoistic motivations, such as the relief of personal distress, escaping public shame for not helping, the relief of sadness, and the desire to make oneself happy. In one study, Batson et al. (1981) used a placebo drug which had no real effects but would led participants to interpret their reactions as high or low empathy. Participants then watched a female confederate (‘Elaine’) apparently receiving random electric shocks. After two trials the confederate appeared to become distressed.

...read more.

Middle

Both researches agree that when we come across someone in need we are likely to feel sad, and after helping them we are likely to feel happier. The difference is the reasons that we help for. Cialdini believes that we help for selfish reasons to make us feel better about ourselves, whereas Batson’s view is that we help others because the victim needs help and, by helping, we feel better about ourselves. In support of the negative state-relief model Cialdini found that when person feels empathy for another person, they also feel sadness. When the researchers manipulated these two emotions independently, they found that higher levels of sadness produced more helping, whereas increasing the amount of empathy was not accompanied by increasing likelihood of helping the other person. To explain these contradicting findings, Batson argues that we are more likely to feel empathic concern when we feel a close attachment with the person in need and it is possible that this form of altruism has developed as a result of kin selection, the tendency to help members of one’s kin because they carry many of the same genes as you. Research by Batson has found that people are more likely to help others when their similarity to the observer is stressed. On the other hand,

...read more.

Conclusion

Limitations are that the sample is too small, and females dropping the letters all looked different, which does not take into account that some females are more likely to be helped than others if they look more attractive or easily approachable. Another limitation is that the study is done at one time of day and in one small area. It could be that only certain type of people walk into town at given time and for example at 12 o’clock on a week day most people are likely to be working and so the people in the streets would most likely be unemployed or retired people which would make the results biased. It might be that those kind of people are less likely to help as they do not feel any empathy or close attachments to the young people or they have less stimulus overload and worries, so their need to alleviate negative emotions is less. As the study is done in one area, it might not be possible to generalise findings to other areas and cultures. It is suggested that individualistic countries are less likely to help than collectivist countries due to the values and beliefs of that culture. Research also shows that in big cities people are less likely to help, which could be attributed to stimulus overload.

Modifications would be to conduct the same experiment in different areas and at different times of day. The sample should be made bigger to get more reliable results.

References

Psychology for A2 Level, Mike Cardwell, Liz Clark, Claire Meldrum (2001)

...read more.

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Height and Weight of Pupils and other Mayfield High School investigations section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Height and Weight of Pupils and other Mayfield High School investigations essays

  1. The purpose of this research paper is to present our findings on how the ...

    Boys outperformed girls in science subjects and girls dominated in the humanities. More recent studies indicated that this trend continues (Morris 1991, Bailey 1997b, Clevannes 1999, Harewood 2000)" (Carrington, 2003, p.40).It has been said that differences in brain size, hemispheric dominance and hormones afford females better verbal skills and males better visual spatial skills (Carrington, 2003, pp.27-28).

  2. Show that different people have different reaction times according to their gender and the ...

    This shows a weak positive correlation of hand span to reaction time. Average (cm) Hand span (cm) Hand span Rank Average rank d d x d Female 01 16 20 21.5 12.0 9.5 90.25 Female 02 17 20 21.5 16.0 5.5 30.25 Female 03 16.7 20 21.5 14.5 7.0 49.00

  1. Is there a difference between male and female conversational styles in today's society?

    S.M: that is true J.B: no it ain't necessarily true because break ups do happen in arranged marriages S.M: but it's a fact that divorces (.) sorry I mean [S.B laughs] love marriages have more divorces J.B: yeah but some love marriages don't S.M: still J.B: no it's still some

  2. Explain the ethical problems facing anthropologists who are carrying out their research in cultures ...

    Questions such as, "Why do parents allow their child to go through these harsh procedures?" have been brought up before. According to a conversation between Dr. Nawal M. Nour and Claudia Dreifus, the doctor explained that, "People do it because of a deeply ingrained belief that they are protecting their daughters.

  1. I believe that women are less threatening and more polite in conversation with members ...

    The examples within this texts include, "...the fact that you were wrongly accused (.) You know (.) and I'm very sorry..." Conclusion From the data analysed there are some clear themes that have emerged. In answer to the question, who is more polite the answer is women.

  2. Ecology in biology, we set of for a week at Juniper Hall Field Centre ...

    I will pour 10cm� of ionised water and stir the soil sample with the ionised water until it is roughly dissolved good enough to be tested on 3) Then get an electronic PH reader and place in the mixture of ionised water and soil and take down the readings.

  1. The tragic story of Kitty Genovese, the young New Yorker, who was murdered in ...

    Men are seen as strong individuals who are more than capable to take care of themselves than women. This can be the reason why women are generally helped more than men and why women and men help different type of victims Women are regarded as the weaker sex.

  2. Examine the intersection of psychology and the media

    as Mercer writes; " Sex is confirmed as the nature of black male identity, as the polyester suit confirms the black man's failure to gain access to culture. Even when the Other aims for bourgeois respectability (the signified of the suit), his camouflage fails to conceal the fact that he

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work