• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
Page
  1. 1
    1
  2. 2
    2
  3. 3
    3
  4. 4
    4
  5. 5
    5
  6. 6
    6
  7. 7
    7
  8. 8
    8
  9. 9
    9
  10. 10
    10
  11. 11
    11
  12. 12
    12
  13. 13
    13
  14. 14
    14
  • Level: GCSE
  • Subject: Maths
  • Word count: 3147

Maths Statistics Coursework on the Readability of a Tabloid Newspaper Compared to a Broadsheet

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Maths Statistics Coursework on the Readability of a Tabloid Newspaper Compared to a Broadsheet

Introduction

A newspaper is a publication containing news, information and advertising, usually printed on low-cost paper called newsprint. It may be general or special interest, most often published daily or weekly.

A Broadsheet is a largest type of newspaper that is aimed at the more educated reader typically reporting on such stories to do with politics and typical thought of as ‘higer quality journalism’. It stereotypically appeals to a  older more educated reader due to its type of articles it reports on and due to the complexity of the language.  Whereas a Tabloid tends to be a smaller more compact newspaper reporting on more local interest stories and tends to emphasise sensational crime stories, gossip columns repeating scandalous innuendos about the personal lives of celebrities and sports stars, and other so-called “junk food news”. This is obvious that this type of newspaper will appeal to a less educated reader and are just looking to be entertained instead of informed about current affairs.  

For this assignment I was asked to compare the readability of articles from two newspapers: a tabloid; and a broadsheet. I selected three pairs of articles each pair covering the same story. I selected the Daily Mail and The Times as my two newspapers.

Hypothesis

  • The average word length in Broadsheets will be longer than Tabloids giving us an indication to the complexity of the language.
  • There will be a bigger percentage of picture and title in an article in the Tabloid as it is designed to engage the stereotypical reader a Tabloid newspaper hopes for i.e. people who want to be entertained rather than informed about the news and would rather look at big pictures than read in detail about what happened.

Plan

To evaluate the readability I compared words from three articles from each newspaper. I selected three articles from the broadsheet then found the same three in a tabloid in order to make my evidence as reliable as possible. I will find one sport articles and two news articles that are covered in both papers. The two newspapers I compare will be of the same date to make the investigation as fair as possible. I will asses the readability of both papers by-

  • Comparing the word lengths in each article of the first 100 words therefore giving us an indication of the complexity of the language and seeing which one has more, long words, giving us a hint at which one would be harder to read. I will take a cluster sample of the first 100 words as it is easier to take the first 100 as it takes less time that having to take a random sample every 7 words for example. I will take a sample of 100 words as it is a suitable percentage of the whole article and a good range of results that we can plot suitably on a bar chart.  I will display this data in a frequency table and then into a bar chart for each of the articles I will then use various other graphs to help prove my hypothesis. I will then work out the mean of the four articles in each paper at the end and display it in a bar chart for easy comparability between the two papers. I will then comment on the standard deviation and mean of both the graphs.
  • I will also find out what percentage of the article is picture and title and what percentage is text by working out the area of the article that is covered in pictures and the title and then the area of the article that is covered in the actual text. This will hopefully show that the Tabloid newspaper has a larger percentage of its page devoted to its pictures and title than the Broadsheet again supporting my hypothesis that the less educated readers would rather have their news served up to them as entertainment. I will display this data in a table and then show my results in a pie chart for each pair of articles. I will then find the percentage of the three articles put together and display it in another pie chart which will make for easy comparability between the Tabloid and the Broadsheet.
...read more.

Middle

1

7

2

14

2

11

3

15

∑f = 100

3

21

∑f = 100

4

11

∑fx = 518

4

13

∑fx = 478

5

10

∑fx² = 3341

5

7

∑fx² = 2941

6

11

Mean = 5.18

6

14

Mean = 4.78

7

15

Standard Deviation = 2.565

7

10

Standard Deviation = 2.562

8

11

8

10

9

4

9

3

10

3

10

2

11

2

11

2

12

0

12

0

image01.png

This graph shows us that the Broadsheet article has less smaller words i.e. words containing 1 to 6 letters but more larger words i.e. 7 to 12 letter words than the Tabloid article. Also again similar to that of the first article the means might be close but again the Broadsheet’s is higher meaning on average that the Broadsheet had larger words, which is evident from the graphs. Unlike the first article these two articles have a much closer standard deviation but even so the Tabloid’s is smaller meaning that more of its words are closer to it mean of 4.78 and the Broadsheets words are more spread out.

Again this evidence supports my hypothesis as this article proves again that the Broadsheet has larger words due to its more complicated language and the Tabloid has smaller words due to its simpler language as it is aimed at the less educated reader.

Article 3- Alonzo’s Future Uncertain

Broadsheet

Tabloid

Word length

Frequency

Word Length

Frequency

1

1

1

2

2

16

2

15

3

22

3

24

4

11

∑f = 100

4

14

∑f = 100

5

12

∑fx = 512

5

8

∑fx = 502

6

14

∑fx² = 3347

6

8

∑fx² = 3349

7

11

Mean = 5.12

7

10

Mean = 5.02

8

5

Standard Deviation = 2.694

8

7

Standard Deviation = 2.879

9

4

9

3

10

6

10

1

11

2

11

4

12

0

12

3

13

1

13

1

...read more.

Conclusion

In order to achieve more thorough results I would have liked to look at more articles in order to get a wider range of results making them more reliable as it is I only had enough time to assess three from each paper. Suitable extensions could have been to count the number of word in each article but you would have needed to get more articles for that as three is not enough in order to prove or disprove your hypothesis you would need a suitable sample size of about 30 articles out of each paper to assess that properly. Another very good extension could have been to compare the age of readers and the education of the readers as this would tie in neatly with the rest of your project as you can actually state who the newspaper is read by giving you an idea of the reading skills of those types of people and from that assessing the readability of the newspapers themselves.

From my results in this project I have proved my earlier hypothesis stating that the Tabloid is easier to read than the Broadsheet as it has less complex vocabulary and more pictures; causing the Tabloid to appeal to a younger reader or a less educated reader and a Broadsheet to appeal to an older more educated reader.

By Joe Sharp UVP

...read more.

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Comparing length of words in newspapers section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Comparing length of words in newspapers essays

  1. Compare a modern romantic comedy with a very old romantic comedy - Compare word ...

    post-office 10 323 34 10 comparison 7 135 17 7 assured 7 195 34 12 floated 9 102 26 10 dejection 9 230 27 12 favourite 9 Bridget Jones' Diary by Helen Fielding-word sampling page line word no word length 46 11 4 the 3 161 32 16 tender 6

  2. Assesment of Reading Difficulties in Patient AM Following the Development of Vascular Dementia.

    The text was placed in an A4 size transparent pocket file and AM as well as 6 age matched controls were given 2 minutes in which to read the text and highlight using a red marker pen the target words when located in the text.

  1. Mathematics statistics coursework. The aim of this coursework is to compare the length of ...

    We will both look at and record in our own separate tally charts the lengths of the first 100 words from each article from our newspaper. When obtaining my first 100 words I will only count letters and numbers and I will ignore all other kind of punctuation.

  2. Comparison between tabloid and broadsheet newspapers.

    The number of letters in each word between the tabloid and broadsheet newspaper. The bar charts (for both of the tests) are in a natural distribution and show most of the points in the mid-point range. The result show that the sentences have more words in the broadsheet newspaper and also that the words get longer in the broadsheet newspaper.

  1. Consumer responses to wine bottle back labels

    the winemakers, and if consumers do not recognise the attributes mentioned therein, then any differences could be explained by variability in human sensory perception. Tasting notes vary appreciably between people, and the fact that what is written on the back label may not coincide with any one person's opinions would, in this context, not be a matter of major concern.

  2. "Broadsheet newspapers have a longer average word length than tabloid newspapers"

    7 15.2 Conclusion My results using the FOGG test of readability relates to my hypothesis, showing that the broadsheet newspapers I tested have a significantly higher reading age than the tabloids. My results showed that highest reading age of 21.6 years was from a broadsheet (The Guardian)

  1. Differences between a broadsheet newspaper, such as the Daily Telegraph, and a tabloid newspaper ...

    TABLOID No. Of Letters in Word (x) Frequency (f) No. X Frequency (fx) Cumulative Frequency 1 1 1 1 2 7 14 8 3 21 63 29 4 17 68 46 5 20 100 66 6 11 66 77 7 8 56 85 8 6 48 91 9 7 63 98 10 1 10 99 11 1 11 100 TOTALS: 100 500 QUALITY No.

  2. GCSE Statistics Coursework

    adverts however we can tell from the composite bar chart that the Daily Mail has more adverts because it has more articles than the Daily Mirror. Hypothesis Two: - "The Daily Mail will generally have longer words." I believe the Daily Mail will generally have longer words because it has

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work