• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To investigate the ratio of Area:Perimeter for triangles (2) To investigate the suggestion made by students that a 40,60,80 triangle would maximise the above mentioned ratio.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Natalie Pinfield Williams

Aims

(1)        To investigate the ratio of Area:Perimeter for triangles

(2)        To investigate the suggestion made by students that a 40,60,80 triangle would maximise the above mentioned ratio.

(3)        Should the students hypothesis be un-sustainable then find out what triangle would maximise the ratio

Important facts about triangles

Simple formula for the area        Area = ½ base *height

        General Formula                        Area = ½ ab sin C                

        Interior Angles                        A+B+C = 180        

        Sin rule                                 a          =         b   _        =         c  

                                                Sin A                Sin B                Sin c

        Cosine Rule                                a2 = b2 + c2 – 2bc Cos A

Student Suggestion

We will Investigate the claim made by the students that a 40,60,80 triangle would maximise the ratio of area:perimeter

Angles

The students suggested that a 40 60 80 would maximise the area : perimeter ratio.

We will make an initial assumption that the 40 6080 refers to the size of the angle in degrees. We accept that they could have been referring to lengths.

Is our assumption possible?

Yes as 40 + 60 + 80 =180. The interior angles do sum to 180 which they must for any triangle so the students could have been referring to the angles.

Calculation

...read more.

Middle

c         =        (a sin 60)/(sin 80)        =        0.88

Perimeter = 1+.65+0.88 =2.53

The area        =         ½ bc        sin A = 1/2*65*.88 * sin 80 = .282 m2

The ratio of area:perimeter is 0.282/2.53 = 0.111

If the size of the triangle alters will the ratio alter.

The students did not give us a length. We assumed a = 1m. Will the ratio alter if we increase the length? If we consider that the length of side a = x m we can produce a general formula for the are of a triangle with angels 40,60,80

If a=x, then we can see from the previous section that b=.65 x and c =.88 x

The perimeter will then be  = 2.53x

The area         = ½ bc sin A

=        .65 x * .88 x sin 80

        =         .573 x2 sin 80

        =        .564 x2

The ratio is therefore

=         0.564 x2 / 2.54 x        

=         0.044 x

The important thing to see is that ratio therefore varies as or is proportional to x. So the larger we make our triangle the higher the ratio.

There is therefore no maximum ratio. The ratio simply increases as the side length increases.

For a comparison of the ratio, where we change the angles, we need to define the perimeter.

...read more.

Conclusion

2 must be positive x2-a2 must be less than x2 hence the largest area enclosed within a quadrilateral is when a=0,  this means all four sidses are the same length. In other words this is a square.

It appears form the above that regular shapes enclose more area than non regular. From the above it would therefore be sensible to assume that an equilateral triangle, being the regular form of a triangle would enclose the most area with a set perimeter and hence produce the best ratio of area:perimeter.

Equilateral Triangle

If the perimeter is set at 1m then each side =1/3m

An equilateral triangle has angles of 60 degrees so

The area is therefore  =        1/2 *1/3 *1/3 * sin 60 = .047

Which produces a ratio =.047

Conclusion

Which ever way the students were thinking they were wrong. An equilateral triangle gives a better ratio than either of the ways their statement could be taken.

Perhaps the students were misheard and were not talking about triangle or even mathematics as this discussion seems remarkable unlikely. They were perhaps talking about the distance to a party or the ratio of the number CD’s that they own.

Perhaps the students should pay more attention to their mathematics teacher.

...read more.

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Fencing Problem section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Fencing Problem essays

  1. Medicine and mathematics

    Q8. Now that we are looking at the time, after which less than 10mg of pencillin with be active after administration, we have to make y= 10. So the equation is 10 =300*(0.6x). But to get the time we have to make the exponent, so x the subject of the formula.

  2. Investigation to find out the number of matchsticks on the perimeter in a matchstick ...

    t = total number of matchsticks r = number of rows R 1 2 3 4 T 4 13 26 43 9 13 17 4 4 1st difference 2nd difference When the 1st difference is not the same but the 2nd difference is, the formula will follow the quadratic pattern:

  1. Graphs of Sin x, Cos x; and Tan x

    Remember Keep your answers in surd form or store them in the memory of your calculator. Using rounded values later on in a question will lead to inaccurate answers. You might also be expected to apply the sine or cosine rules to a three-dimensional problem. Look at the following example.

  2. Investigating different shapes to see which gives the biggest perimeter

    This is because the rectangle with the biggest area had a bigger area than the triangle with the biggest area. So for this reason I am now going to investigate polygons that have more sides. I am going to keep the sides of the next shapes, I am going to

  1. Geography Investigation: Residential Areas

    Over the course of my investigation I have found that my results often relate back to one of the theories. Each of my conclusions at the end of studying a hypothesis I have commented on whether my results prove or disprove my initial key question.

  2. When the area of the base is the same as the area of the ...

    4x4x4=64cm 5cm 2cm 20cm 4cm 5x2x4=40cm This table shows the results I got for the measurements of the 12cm by 12cm net. The formulas that I used were the same to what I used for the others. The maximum volume that I got for this tray was with the height

  1. Regeneration has had a positive impact on the Sutton Harbour area - its environment, ...

    Methods Identified Whilst on my trip to Plymouth, I will need to carry out methods that will aid me in reaching a conclusion about whether my hypothesis is right or wrong. I will do a tally chart to measure the amount of traffic and pedestrians passing a certain place.

  2. How can I make My local Area Sustainable?

    At present time there is little opportunity for people to recycle anything more than glass and paper - this facility is a necessity.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work