• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"What interests Mansfield most is self-deception" Discuss this proposition with close reference to two of her stories

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

“What interests Mansfield most is self-deception”

Discuss this proposition with close reference to two of her stories

Self - deception seems to be the basis of both Bliss and Pictures; two short stories by Katherine Mansfield. In this essay, I intend to demonstrate how Mansfield conveys the theme of self - deception to her readers by exploring the imagery and language she uses.

The story Bliss centres around Bertha Young, a thirty year old woman who is extremely content with her life, especially her relationship with her husband Harry: “Really - really - she had everything. She was young. Harry and she were as much in love as ever, and they got on together splendidly and were really good pals.”

In Bertha’s opinion, her life is perfect. She has a baby, interesting and exciting friends and no financial worries.

The story Pictures was written during WWI and focuses on an overweight, unmarried middle aged woman - Ada Moss who, on the contrary, is extremely frustrated with her life. As a result of this, Ada Moss is failing as an actress and is left to fend for herself in a world very hostile to her.

‘Ten minutes later, a stout lady

...read more.

Middle

Ada Moss however, is not in control of her self - deception. Her behaviour is late and contrived.

“Cockroach! That’s what she is. She’s a cockroach!” Ada Moss is blaming the landlady for the failure of her acting. The word ‘cockroach’ is a childish insult which demonstrates her lack of responsibility. Ada Moss lives in a dream world to such an extent that she believes the outcome of the dream. Her childishness is also revealed when she describes the landlady as ‘pouncing’. She is adopting a childish mentality and cannot face up to the truth. If she hadn’t acted like a child and lied about the letter then she would not be in the position she is in. She is simply deluded - “the letter seemed to afford her peculiar satisfaction”. She has just been rejected yet she is satisfied. She has made the letter out to be a fantastic film contract, so fake that the idea penetrates into her mind and deceives her to believe her own lies.

 -

Bertha Young cannot help being a victim of  deception. She has no financial hardship and no idea of reality. Her life is undemanding, she has a nanny to help the baby and is less restrictive.

...read more.

Conclusion

One can argue that the grey cat could symbolise Pearl Fulton and that even the Bertha Young is seen more colourful, in the end Harry goes for Pearl Fulton because she has something to offer that Bertha does not seem to possess until its too late. And if you take the L off Pearl it leaves you with Pear - and Pearl Fulton is seen to be the symbol of the pear tree.

For Ada Moss, self deception is a way of surviving, she can’t deal with the reality of the situation that she is in. she is literally holding on to life which indicates that she is in a tough choice for business - acting. Rejection is all that she knows.

In this story, you can’t help but feel sorry for Bertha Young. She has deceived herself, but unlike Ada Moss, she is in control of her self deception.

Ada Moss knows the reality of her life and chooses to suppress it and deceive the outside world with a façade.

By Farah Nanji

10X

...read more.

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Pay Phone Problem section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Pay Phone Problem essays

  1. Problems that Ben faces in Deathwatch by Robb White.

    So when Rod orders them to work and they refuse, it turns into a bad situation. Rod demanded that they work by saying, "You'll have to fish or cut bait". This really ticks them off, especially the McGowan brothers. Bruce gets so upset and fed up by Rod trying to

  2. Show How Colin's Character Develops Through the Novel - Two Weeks With The ...

    Colin is thinking that he will go to South America but he is not sure that it will work. He is beginning to see sense. In the end Colin decides not to go to South America and he meets a boy called Ted and Ted is gay with a boy called Griff who is in hospital with cancer as well.

  1. The Framework Knitting Museum: An Accurate Reflection of History or Not?

    toys and only a single candle, the most decorative thing in the Framework Knitter's cottage were tiny plants upon the shelf above the fireplace. This dramatic difference between the two cottages was obviously down to wages; the Bag Hosier was only a working class man, but received a good wage,

  2. Arrian, The Anabasis of Alexander, together with the Indica, E

    general on their behalf better than himself, by putting it into the mind of Darius to move his forces from the spacious plain and shut them up in a narrow place, where there was suffficient room for themselves to deepen their phalanx by marching from front to rear, but where

  1. admin in business

    London * Go to Heathrow Airport We wanted to opt for something that wouldn't cause the group too much stress; conflict with anyone's roles and that could involve everyone in the group. We didn't want anyone in the group to be left out so we sought out the ideas that

  2. Deathatch By Robb White, a discussion.

    Forty-five miles to the left is the main highway and 15 miles to the right is the town. In the desert without clothes, food, or water Ben had to use what he knew about survival. Madec would be watching him from the Jeep with his .358 at his side.

  1. Perception - the interpretation of information.

    This way bower trained the babies to react in this way by rewarding them with a peek-a-boo game from the experimenter if they moved there heads when they were shown a particular cube. Once the babies were reacting to that particular cube, Bower tried varying what the babies were shown.

  2. The woman is going to make a phone call costing any multiple of 10p. ...

    General Rule for General Rule (10p,np) Tx = T(x-1)+T(x-n/10) (20p,np) Tx = T(x-2)+T(x-n/10) When observing the table above, the two formulae have only one difference. The General Rule for (10p,np) has got (x-1) whereas the General Rule for (20p,np) has got (x-2)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work