• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A Comparison between the film of the Scarlet Tunic and the Melancholy Hussar of the German Legion by Thomas Hardy

Extracts from this document...


A Comparison between the film of the Scarlet Tunic and the Melancholy Hussar of the German Legion by Thomas Hardy The main change in the film to the short story is how they had changed the ending of the story to something completely different, changing the effect of the end. Instead of living to tell the story of her tragedy as said in the short story, the film made it so Phyllis ended up being shot with Matthaus; therefore the story was not told by her (since she was dead) but a narrator. In the social background of the film it shows how the soldiers were prepared to fight to reclaim land or die in the process. In the short story it says how Phyllis had no social life and her father was not a good doctor. The short story gave an impression that Phyllis and her father not well off but neither poor, but in the film it was shown that she was well off and her and her father were highly respected people. The character of her father, Mr Grove, was shown as a patient caring man in the film; where as in the short story it portrayed him as a demanding man with no consideration for his daughter. In the story Mr Grove was only brought in when it was describing Phyllis and what he was telling her to do, but in the film he had his own leading role and a separate story along with Phyllis', and Matthaus' brother, Christophe. ...read more.


In the short story her father, Mr Parson, also had a minor role in the film. Mr Parson was mentioned in the short story and the film. It showed him telling Mr Grove that it was rumoured Mr Gould had another woman. In the film it gave a small part to the soldiers Matthaus was with, where in the book nothing was said about them. The soldiers cause Matthaus a lot of problems but obviously care for one another. It portrayed them more as brothers and how they looked after each others well being. In the film it is better to have many more characters with their story lines, because unlike the short story, you can't make up the other characters and you have to be shown how they are like. If there was only 2 main characters the film would have been boring, but in the short story it was ok since it took less time to read than watching the film, giving you less time to get bored. Mr Humphrey Gould's part in the film was nearly the same as it was in the short story. In both he is engaged to be married to Phyllis. It was Mr Gould who had told the commander that Matthaus and his comrades were trying to flee the army, again changing the end of the short story. ...read more.


We learn about the appearances of the characters in the film by the way they are dressed, the way the talk and act, and the way they are treated. The setting in the short story was not very detailed and left a lot to the imagination. In the short story it describes how Phyllis' house was near the soldiers as in the film, but there was a wall blocking her from the soldiers, whereas is the film there wasn't. There were a lot of field and hills shown in the film. Also the house was not on a hill as imagined in the short story. I do not think this had much effect on the story. The music in the film related to the scenes. Trumpets and drums and other "royal" instrument were used to give a good musical piece for the soldiers. Where as when ever a scene between Matthaus and Phyllis occurred, romantic music would be played. It influences the way the story is told because it gives tension to the film and sets the scene. The camera had mostly close up shots, to show the expression on the faces of the character, so you would know what they were thinking without them saying it. There were not many long shots for most of the scenes were 2 people so there was no need for them. The camera shots stayed on the same shot for quite along time, so you could focus on something without them moving the camera all the time. ?? ?? ?? ?? Shilan Raza 10.2 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Marketing section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Marketing essays

  1. Is there scope for a new business in the local area?

    The place where you put your shop is how you get your product to your customers, when looking for a place for my business these facts must be considered: * Competition * Parking * It must be in a area where the income is around ?15000+ (for my shop)

  2. An analysis and comparison of James Bond Film posters.

    This essay will be closely analysing, comparing and contrasting two well known James bond posters. Firstly I will be analysing the James bond "Thunderball" poster. The mis-en-scene of this poster is initially the images of James bond. We can see James Bond in a variety of different activities which connotes

  1. A comparison of the animated films

    The villain hates and is jealous of Snow White, she also has special powers. She has the traditional witch-like features with black hair and pale skin and has a raven bird which is a symbol of death. "Shrek" often subverts the typical stereotype of a princess.

  2. What does John Huston make of the Film Noir conventions in his film The

    on Spade, this as with the others makes him look innocent, which in this case he is, but with the twists you are not sure. Outdoor lighting is quite similar, outside scenes are usually lit by headlights and street lamps.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work