• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast three media articles all depicting the same news item

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare and contrast three media articles all depicting the same news item People read articles everyday but opinions and form opinions based on what they read. Broad sheets, tabloids and newsmagazines will have their own angles and views about same events. Our opinions are biased on the type of language, text, layout, images, what is emphasised, and what is left out, and how biased the article is. The Mirror (a tabloid), The Times (a broad sheet) and Newsweek a news magazine have all reported on the cable car accident which took place on the slopes of Mt Cermis on the 3rd February 1998. A low flying U.S. military aeroplane cut the cable wire, which caused the car to fall 300ft to the ground killing everyone in it. The three articles are reported in the distinctive styles of their genres. There are many differences between broad sheets and tabloids. The most obvious difference is that the page size of a tabloid is A3, and that of a broad sheet is double this. Other differences are that tabloids use larger pictures and broad sheets more text. All broad sheet newspapers include business and financial news that give an in depth analysis of what is happening in domestic and international economies. Often this is a pullout section. Financial and economic news is reported in tabloids, but it is more of a report of information rather than an analysis. International news is also given more emphasis in broad sheets than tabloids. ...read more.

Middle

There is also a diagram, which visually explains how events unravelled and features the cable car, fighter jets, cable wire and map of Italy with a box indicating the geographical location captions serve as explanation of what happen. This diagram is a quick way for readers on the go to understand in a few moments what took place. If they are interested they can read the whole article. As before mentioned the intended reading age of a tabloid is quite low compare to broad sheets and a newsmagazine, so having a visual explanation which is easy to understand promotes a less intensive read. The maps in The Mirror are very small and easily missed amidst the other diagrams. It is labelled "Italy" and the Adriatic Sea is shown these are the only areas named. The location of the accident is boxed in with no labels. The 'simple minded' tabloid reader probably is not very interested in the specific location, a general idea is all that is needed. The map in The Time it has a scale shows the terrain lakes, and surroundings cities it is core detailed or a more intelligent reader. Where as The Mirror depicts the cable car. The Times has a photograph the EA- 6B Prowler jet that is "part of Nato's Bosnia force." The impact of the photograph can make readers realise that such a jet can easily slice a cable wire and cause fatal destruction; that the potential for damage behind reckless and unsafe flying is horrific. ...read more.

Conclusion

First they put the article under " WORLD AFFAIRS" which means the world needs to be aware of what has happened and mainly the fact that their heading is a big give away. "After a U.S. fighter jet clips a gondola's cable, killing 20, Europe questions America's character." This heading first tells us that the Americans have done something very wrong and second, it tells us that there are questions raised about the character of America by Europe. The tone of this article is biased. The meaning of this article is straightforward and the tone of this article shows that the American Army is irresponsible. In the NEWSWEEK article, it shows the Americans behaviour as reckless by "hot dogging by threading under the cables and high tension wire." There have been complaints to America by Italy; "a collective howl of protest." Newsweek's article tell us that because of the low flying "warplanes," there has been at least, "one miscarriage, made horses throw riders and prompted thousands of complaints to federal authorities." This adds to the part of being a biased article because it has just added all the effects the warplanes have done by flying low. It makes the reader think that the American Airforce is reckless and the actions of the warplanes are terrible. The main text in the NEWSWEEK where it shows that this article is biased is when the article said; "violence is as American as cherry pie." This means that the violence is such an integrated part of American culture. It is common and loved like cherry pie, Americas well known dishes. Tell me what else should I add. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Narrative section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Narrative essays

  1. Consider the similarities and differences Between a TV news report and a TV Documentary ...

    Warriors is not a horror movie, however. It is a drama documentary, so its power to shock is mainly based in the portrayal of events. For example, when the soldiers walk into a room to discover several burnt bodies. There is a limit to how much it can shock the viewers, however.

  2. Language investigation on two magazines, 'Top gear' and 'classic cars'

    The first line on the top of the page 'is the original always the best, ponders Clarkson?' Also gives it a sense of formality and seriousness, by posing a question which involves the reader, and clearly sets out to be controversial as this would bring divided opinions.

  1. Explain the concept of 'Moral Panics' and examine the claim that the media generate ...

    Crime is perhaps the most obvious example of regularly reported deviant behaviour. Criminal offending stimulates concern and is perceived as a threat because it challenges societal values and order. When the media use crime as news then, it draws a distinction between what is acceptable and unacceptable behaviour: "media coverage

  2. Analyse two leaflets of your choice. Compare the presentation content and language of each ...

    it doesn't look at first glance as if it has been aligned to a grid) whereas the first leaflet looks very square. However the colour scheme is similar, including lots of green and dark blue (like the black on the first leaflet).

  1. An Assessment of Bias and Objectivity in the News Media

    If journalists place a certain 'slant' or bias on particular facts, the public may perceive it as the truth. Despite the criticisms that objectivity cannot exist, it is imperative for the news media to strive for this goal. If objectivity is the 'cornerstone' of the 'professional ideology of journalism',39 it

  2. How might Marshall McLuhan's theory of hot and cold media be used to explain ...

    As phones differ widely in style and in what features they contain each person can be judged on the phone they own, or the phone they wished they owned. Someone who has a phone that looks good, rather than containing many features is clearly saying something about the way in which they want to present themselves.

  1. Explore, analyse and comment on the way the story of the conjoined twins has ...

    unarguably negative. I feel that The Sun has blown the event out of all proportion and has missed the point somewhat. It is clear to me that Laden and Laleh Bijani knew the risks and were willing to accept the consequences, however bad they may turn out to be.

  2. Using the film text "a clockwork orange"? Examine the effects of media violence and ...

    to be increasingly hard to form in later life Personal identity: This allows a viewer to identify with characters in a text, either by appearance, emotions, personality etc. They view common ideologies of stereotypes Surveillance: This allows the viewer to "keep up" with what is going on in the world,

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work