• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare trading places and collateral

Extracts from this document...


Compare the ways in which genre is established in the opening sequences of Collateral and Trading places. The term film genre refers to the methods of film categorization based on similarities in the narrative elements from which films are constructed. In Collateral the use of dark and bleak mise-en-scene and camera techniques make Collateral suspenseful. The non-diegetic sound adds to this. In Trading Places the use of comic surprise, verbal humor and physical humor make Trading Places a comedy. The main codes and conventions of suspense thrillers are that of an intensive plot, set period of time or number of deaths and enigma codes. In Collateral you would find an intensive plot, you would also find a set period of time or number of deaths and a dark and bleak mise-en-scene. In the opening sequence of Collateral there are quite a few codes and conventions, which are mise-en-scene, enigma codes and that of the opening engages the audience and sets the tone of the film. The main codes and conventions of a comedy films are generation of laughter, comic surprise, verbal humor and physical humor. The opening sequence contains most of the codes and conventions like comic surprise, verbal humor, physical humor and surprise. The opening sequence of Collateral starts off with the introduction of Vincent in the airport, this then cuts to a montage of the taxi depot where we finally get introduced to Max. ...read more.


The whole montage is suspenseful as it includes the introduction of Max by slowly using camera techniques and codes and conventions to portray to the audience little information about the character and his habitat. Trading places starts off with a montage sequence which itself is humorous. The non-diegetic sound is from the comic based opera, the Marriage of Figaro which satirizes the French aristocracy. This pompous sounding does not mix with the poor lifestyles of the citizens. Alongside this we see the butler preparing breakfast for his "master", then the shot cuts to the homeless man who is using newspapers as a duvet. This is surprising as you would not expect this, and also this generates a smile or laugh. All these techniques create a comical effect. The difference between the montages in both films is that both films covey different messages to the audience by using a range of methods. In Trading places the montage effect contrasts the poor and rich lifestyles which we see different images of. The effect of the montage is satirical as the contrasting images cutting from one to the next allow us to satirize the rich Americans. However in Collateral we see the montage of different people who are somewhat isolated from each other. Its purpose is also to serve as a slow and suspenseful build up to the introduction of the protagonist, Max. When we get introduced to Max, we immediately ask questions on who this character is. ...read more.


The mise-en-scene of Billy-Ray is quite poor and informal but Vincent's mise-en-scene is quite sophisticated and formal, his sunglasses somewhat conceal his identity and cause an atmosphere of suspense. Billy-Ray causes a comical effect by his use of verbal and physical humor whilst Vincent's character creates suspense by the camera techniques like shallow depth of field and close ups. Furthermore Billy-Ray is like a petty criminal but Vincent is a sophisticated criminal, this is ironic as Billy-Ray makes us laugh when he does commit a crime but when Vincent commits a crime we get held in suspense. Likewise, Billy-Rays criminal nature is very obvious and Vincent's criminal nature is quite hidden, this is shown by Billy-Ray's verbal humor as he tries to get away from the officers, he uses religious gestures to lure himself out of trouble, however in Collateral we do not know that Vincent is a criminal until he does his first offense, his grayish formal suit and sunglasses hide his personality and criminal nature. Trading places and Collateral are good film choices to compare, as one is comical and the other suspenseful. In Trading places the characters and narratives are appropriate for the genre as they all have set roles, for instance Vincent in collateral has a mise-en-scene of a formal grayish suit and sunglasses to conceal his identity. All these create suspense, likewise Billy-ray's mise-en-scene is very colorful and bright, these of which create a feeling of humor. All these characters are suitable for their genres as the mise-en-scene, camera techniques, sound and editing techniques all blend with the genre. ?? ?? ?? ?? Qasid Ahmed 10WW ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Narrative section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Narrative essays

  1. The Camera Never Lies

    The photograph (Fig.4) alongside the article shows President Bush casually dressed in typical Texan fashion. It was very informal and displayed the idea of him and Tony Blair being chums. In the image Bush and Blair are seen to be united together, which reflects the text in the article.

  2. James Bond - Bond(TM)s female characters are fully liberated women. They use Bond. Consider ...

    A slightly similar character to Dink in 'The World Is Not Enough' is Doctor Molly Warmflash. She is seduced by Bond when she is giving him a check up and she gives in straight away, saying, 'you'll have to promise to call me this time.'

  1. Explain the opening sequence of Gladiator.

    It also explains important facts about the battle and puts things into context. The writing is in short blocks to make the audience read it. If it was just one continual piece of writing, then many people wouldn't bother. One of the first shots is a close up of Maximus' hand.

  2. bridget jones narrative and conventions

    The audience is constantly aware of Bridget's feelings throughout the film through her diary, which is read as voice-over by Bridget. This allows Bridget's character to discuss the conventions of the romantic comedy genre in an almost self-conscious way. The audience hears how she is lonely, vulnerable, unaware of her attraction to Mark, let down by Daniel and eventually happy.

  1. Both Spirited Away and Pan(TM)s Labyrinth represent the traditional family unit as an important ...

    This is very similar again, to Yubaba's role in Spirited Away. Laying out rules for Ofelia in each of the tasks that he sets her, forces her to independently mature and stick to the rules, very unlike the actions of a child, clearly benefiting her.

  2. The Untouchables - Train Station Scene

    Because of the size of union station, there is a lot of space to be covered. This adds tension to the scene because of there only being to people to cover the whole of the station. This builds more tension because the book-keeper could come in at any of the

  1. The purpose of this essay is to compare two advertising leaflets for christian aid ...

    They do this to exploit the reader's emotions and feelings making them feel horrified to see that people and animals are going through this much in their lives.

  2. Write a response to 'Embroidery' by Ray Bradbury from two different critical positions.

    This male character is the imperfection in the scene, destroying its simple and childlike preservation. "I'll just have to rip the whole pattern, practically, to fix it right." The man is ripped out entirely from the scene, rather then just having his face corrected.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work