• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The reaction to Boris Johnson's article about Ken Bigley and resulting implications for the media

Extracts from this document...


The reaction to Boris Johnson's article about Ken Bigley and resulting implications for the media. When Boris Johnson's article in The Spectator1 caused controversy a week ago, it raised questions not only about the ethical position of politicians involved in journalism, but also about the freedom of the media and its relationship with regulators and governmental bodies. Boris Johnson is a much- derided figure, often attacked for his looks and manner rather than his views and actions. In a radio interview for the BBC, for example, Paul Bigley (Ken's brother) accused him of being a "self- centred, pompous twit"2 and belittled him for his appearance and waffling manner despite the valid points in the article, and subsequent apology.3 This tact was followed by newspapers almost without exception; The Times, for example, started their article with a quote from Michael Howard denouncing Johnson's writing as "nonsense from beginning to end,"4 a comment in the Liverpool Daily Post recommended that he 'got life insurance,'5 and an article on the BBC website6 provided quotations only from those against the MP. This is in direct contrast to what the same website suggested was the general public opinion. On the 'Your Views'7 section, nineteen out of twenty- two comments support Johnson's opinion, ranging from those in general support to people from Liverpool criticising their fellow Liverpudlians; suggesting that the media was either being sensationalist or deliberately opposing a Conservative- who, it should be noted, did not even write the article. ...read more.


In the United Kingdom The Times is typically seen as a left- wing paper, The Telegraph as right- wing, and The Independent as the most unbiased paper. These stereotypes rarely hold true, however, with The Times' editorial often being more lenient towards the Conservatives. This may have more to do with the fact that the media often opposes whoever is in power, whoever they are, with no regards to traditional stance. Of the articles about Johnson, the most balanced viewpoint was from The Guardian Student. From the very start it offers views for and against the article; even the headline, "Boris is 'sorry' for tactless own goal"14 presents Johnson as apologetic whilst also implying he made a blunder. Throughout, it keeps this balanced viewpoint with quotations from those supporting him followed by those against; contrasting articles in The Times15 which present tirades of criticism. The Guardian Student article is an exception, however. Though often not as transparent as headlines in tabloids such as The Sun or The Daily Star, broadsheets in the Western world show clear bias without obvious governmental controls. This may be seen to affect politics. In a poll conducted in America in 1992, for example, 89% of 1400 members of the national media surveyed voted for Clinton in that same year.16 Though it is certain this would have influenced the journalists' articles, it is debateable whether the media dictated the public's mood or vice versa. In 1997 when The Sun declared "It's The Sun Wot Won It" due to its support of the Labour party, it was questionable whether they actually influenced the public or merely responded to what the public was urging them to print. ...read more.


Therefore though the media, in particular in Britain, is supposedly free from constraints, in reality there are numerous limits on what journalists are willing to write. 1 Bigley's Fate, The Leader in The Spectator, 16/10/04 2 [As quoted in] Midgley, Carol, ' "Where are you Boris?" "Erm, erm, I don't know where I am. I've got to go,"' The Times, 21/10/2004 3 Johnson, Boris, Statement of The Spectator article, www.boris-johnson.com, 19/10/2004 4 Charter, David, 'Boris Johnson falls foul of leader over Liverpudlians', The Times, 16/10/2004 5 'Editor promises Bigley apology,' Liverpool Daily Post, 16/10/2004 6 " 'Sorry' Johnson sent to Liverpool", BBC website, 16/10/2004 7 'Your Views,' BBC website, 20/10/2004 8 Woolcock, Nicola, 'Offending copy penned by Heffer,' The Times, 21/10/2004 9 Herbert, Ian, 'Why Boris Johnson is in hot water in Liverpool', The Independent, 16/10/2004 10 Shrimsley, Robert, 'Boris Bows Down', Financial Times, 19/10/2004 11 'Press Freedom on the Precipice,' New York Times, 16/10/2004 12 'Walk Alone: Boris bends knee to Liverpool', The Times, 17/10/2004 13 www.cultsock.ndirect.co.uk/MUHome/cshtml/media/media/mediaown.html 14 Carter, Wintour and Ward, 'Boris is "sorry" for own goal,' The Guardian Student, 21/10/2004 15 'Walk Alone: Boris bends knee to Liverpool', The Times, 17/10/2004 and Charter, David, 'Boris Johnson falls foul of leader over Liverpudlians', The Times, 16/10/2004 16 Freedom Forum sponsored poll, 1992 17 e.g. 'Huntley's Voodoo Rituals,' The Sun front page, 19/10/2004 18 Thacker, Amy, 'Sticks and Stones,' The Warwick Boar, 18/10/04 19 Karlekar, Karin, 'Press Freedom in 2003,' www.freedomhouse.org 20 Yurkovsky, Andrew, 'Russia: Freedom Gained,' World Press Review 21 Litovkin, Viktor, 'Russia Modernizes Nuclear Weapons,' Moscow News 20- 26 October 2004 22 e.g, 'MP backs guide dog users' pleas,' Maidenhead Advertiser, 15/10/2004 ?? ?? ?? ?? Introduction To Politics 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Narrative section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Narrative essays

  1. The mass media has played a major role in structuring public perceptions of crime ...

    The questionnaire should be anonymous. Reliability and validity, as the terms are used in scientific study, are characteristics of the dependent variable and the specific operational definition. In analyzing a study, after the dependent variables and their operational definitions are identified, their reliability and validity must be established.

  2. Allen Ginsberg once said "Whoever controls the media; the images; controls the culture."

    Nightly news programs are the most popular TV programs, as they are watched by the most viewers, which has secured news programs places in primetime TV positions.

  1. Yr 11 Media Studies- Discuss the Representation of Youths in Contrasting films.

    In 10 Things I Hate About You friendship is divided up into stereotyped groups: popularity, geeks, jocks, ect. This is very similar to most American teenage movies. Although in Stand By Me the four youths are very close and like everyone else they wind each other up.

  2. Literary Linguistics and Critical Appreciation - Stylistic analysis of a fragment from novel and ...

    The verbal phrase 'log on' immediately connects our thoughts with the world of computers and Internet. Thus, the reader presupposes what the article is about, people who commit crimes using computers and the Internet. An important psychological factor is the choice of layout and script.

  1. An Analysis of an Article in the Big Issue called Sun Vampires.

    We all know the adverts on television in which 'scientists' in white coats are used to impress upon us the wonderful properties of toothpastes or headache cures. We naturally believe what we are told by experts. So Doctor Bishop is brought into the argument and a consultant dermatologist.

  2. James bond review

    (continue to write about gadgets) Another Bond characteristic is his endless supply of catchphrases, such as when he is in a posh bar or restaurant he will order a "dry martini, shaken not stirred", which is now one the most famous lines of all time in films.

  1. top gear review

    things which make car enthusiasts and professionals excited aren't the things which make Mr Average Motorist excited. In an era when people are being encouraged to drive less (a stance which Clarkson is infamous for vehemently opposing) then banging on about the appropriately-monikered Reasonably Priced Car is not interesting to

  2. John Keane (1991) suggested,

    (Curran. J, Gurevitch. M, Mass Media and Society. Pg. 23) Even though News international seems to hold such a big position in the UK, it is just a local player, and not yet the biggest global player. Due to all of the government's regulations on holding too much of the market place, it will probably not get much bigger in the UK.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work