• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent does or is it possible for television to continue to act as a 'voice for the nation'? Discuss with reference to specific TV texts.

Extracts from this document...


Belinda Clarke Student No: 9505215 To what extent does or is it possible for television to continue to act as a 'voice for the nation'? Discuss with reference to specific TV texts. Throughout the world both commercial and public service broadcasting has been active in the construction of national identities. In Britain for example, the state sponsored BBC has been most closely associated with being a 'voice of the nation'. Lord Reith the first director general of the BBC established its central role of fostering national identity from its outset in the 1920s, and by the establishment of the BBC's television service in 1936 the corporation was, as Reith put it, committed to "making the nation as one man". (Goodwin & Whannel, 1990, p.23) To this day the BBC still subscribes to this philosophy, and much of its output still reflects this commitment. However, since Reith's departure, the television industry has undergone dramatic change because in recent years the world has been becoming increasingly organised by globalisation. Television is now broadcast on a global scale which it is theorised is having consequences on the formation of collective identities. It is for this reason that I will use the BBC to illustrate how television acts as a 'voice for the nation', and also to show the effects that global television has had on this role and in turn national identities. In order to explore these issues this essay will begin with a review of an established model for understanding this debate, the cultural imperialism thesis. Next it will give a brief explanation of nation and national identities with a focus on the British nation. This will then allow an appraisal of the position that sees global television as phasing out the voice of the nation and thereby weakening national identity, or as strengthening the voice of the nation as a consequence of the backlash to globalisation. ...read more.


It follows that a nation is not only a political entity but something which produces meanings- a system of cultural representation."(Hall, 1992, p.292) He illustrates that Britain's national identity is inextricably bound up with issues of race, gender and sexuality. British national identity is represented as southern, white heterosexual masculine and middle class which is unfairly representative of the different genders, sexuality's, ethnicity's and cultures that exist within Britain. It places white English men as the superior race and any one else as the inferior other in varying degrees. In Modernity and its Futures Hall illustrates that continuity, tradition and timelessness are key ingredients in constructing a national identity. Education, national histories, literature, popular culture and more explicitly the media have all become tools of telling the national discourse. "They provide a set of stories, images, landscapes, scenarios, historical events, national symbols and rituals which stand for or represent, the shared experiences, sorrows, triumphs and disasters which give meanings to the nation." (Hall in Hall, Held and McGrew, 1992, p.293) In this process, subjective truths are told in the hope that they will be absorbed. The intention is that the national discourse will be naturalised to establish a general universal truth about the nation. This is the way hegemonic regimes surreptitiously construct and represent common sense understandings of national identity, as though they were an inherent part of humanity. Television (especially public service broadcasting) has been a primary site for the construction and reproduction of the national identity. The BBC in Britain has felt it their duty to unite the nation by fostering a sense of national identity. Consider how many times it displays nationalistic symbols (flags, red roses, lions, and beefeaters) in television programmes. The Union Jack is displayed wherever they cover a sporting event featuring British players. During every football 'World Cup' spectators are seen to wave, wear and paint Union Jacks on their faces whilst singing patriotic songs, such as 'God Save the Queen'. ...read more.


However, this makes a number of key assumptions - firstly that an individual in society has these convictions of belonging to a nation, and secondly that the transfer of information from television will be able to influence an individual's beliefs. The very volume of media images and experiences, to which many societies are now exposed, can lead to an advanced critical faculty in many viewers. They are not just blind consumers, who can be subjected to an "ideology transplant" - rather many are conscious and accustomed of the need to filter messages from the medium and many others will make their own readings, at counterpoint to the inherent western ideologies of global television. Conversely it is also true that for some countries the 'voice of the nation' has become stronger because of a backlash to globalisation and therefore for certain individuals, their national identity can be strengthened. It is also true that alongside national identities being both weakened and strengthened by global television they are also being transformed and new hybrid identities are emerging. The growth in the ability of individuals within society to travel both nationally and internationally, have wider access to information, and to be able to communicate in many new ways, has led to the creation of a myriad of new communities, which can stretch across borders, or be contained as microcosms within them. These can be communities of shared ideology, religious belief, common interest and a thousand other connections - and these hybrid identities often can be as strong if not stronger than an individual's sense of nation. Therefore for those countries who fear that they will lose their national identity, it has and will continue to be useful for television to still act as 'a voice for the nation'. The 'voice of the nation' can also be useful in counteracting the influx of western imported and satellite television images that pervade many countries. However, it may no longer have as powerful or pervasive an effect as in previous years because of the changing nature of collective identity. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Audience and Production Analysis section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Audience and Production Analysis essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Analyse an advertisement and discuss the imagery it contains. Evaluate the success of the ...

    4 star(s)

    The target audience is everyone that is considered young. It can be aimed at both genders if you look at them in two different perspective views. It is clearly targeted at the female audience. This is due to the celebrity model and the shape and colour of the model.

  2. Marked by a teacher

    How the film Shrek parodies the traditional Disney fairytale

    3 star(s)

    This was quickly changed when he overhears Princess Fiona and donkey talking. He misinterprets what they were actually saying. This tells the audience that Shrek is unlucky. The audience could always tell that Shrek like Princess Fiona but could not physically show it because it was probably a long time

  1. Compare the way cultural difference is represented in two films (East is East and ...

    In 'East is East', the main targets of racism are the Khan family as they live in Salford in Manchester - a predominantly 'white' area. This makes them more prone to discrimination as they are the only coloured family in the local area.

  2. Define the meaning of the term 'Globalisation' in terms of media impact. How has ...

    The world wide web has brought the global to the local. Chat rooms enable people to communicate on a global scale. News and sport can be obtained instantaneously. Internet banking eradicates time and space. The internet can give positive opportunities, 'giving voice' so democratizing the world, providing there is free access.


    is surprising to viewers as we know ogres don't talk to other characters, the characters are actually afraid of ogres. Donkey also acts as Shrek's advisor because throughout the film Donkey was the only story book character who used to talk to Shrek and sometimes he used to advise him

  2. The lyrical, slow-moving opening sequence is a dazzling combination of cinematography, music and hallucinatory ...

    The French planter Hubert de Marias (Christian Marquand) welcomes them after learning that they lost one of their men. He explains that generations of his family have been at the plantation site in Cambodia for 70 years. He also asserts: "And it will be such until we are all dead."

  1. PSB vs Commercial Broadcaster

    a great need of commercial television to broadcast the advertisements of the time's greatest companies. The 1954's Television Act established the regulation policy which must govern ITV's actions, despite being a commercial broadcaster. At the beginning, ITV operated under license from the Postmaster General.

  2. The Effect of Television Violence Upon Society

    Many believe that its introduction by Congress was merely to allay public concerns relating to the content on television, as opposed to any inherent belief that it would make a real difference. Further research and surveys into the impact of television on children were carried out by Hilde Himmelweit in Britain3 and by Wilbur Schramm in Amercia4.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work