• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare the ways in which the two film openings present their characters and themes, and set up the basis for the story of the whole film.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare the ways in which the two film openings present their characters and themes, and set up the basis for the story of the whole film. In the two versions of Romeo and Juliet that we have studied, the directors have had very different styles of production. The main difference is the setting. Luhrmann's version is set in the 21st century, and the characters are identified as modern gang style characters. Zeffirelli's version is much more traditional, set in the original setting and none of the extravagant special effects that we see in Luhrmann's version. The different characters have been portrayed in different styles. Benvolio in Luhrmann's version is wearing a very colourful and bright Hawaiian style shirt, which fits in with the image of the rest of the Montague boys. He drives into the petrol station in a bright yellow car, which creates the impression of confidence. He wears a dog tag which adds to his gang identity. The gold chain and large crystal hanging from it shows that he is reasonably rich. However, this gang image drops a little when you see his hair. It is cut in a kind of uniformed military style. This contrasts with the rest of the Montague boys who all have much more outrageous styles. ...read more.

Middle

The Luhrmann version includes several different prologues. The first is the news report style magical floating television, The second is newspaper headlines, the third is commentary as a helicopter zooms around the city with lots of cuts and zooms in the camerawork, and the forth a rapid series of flashing sentences. I think that this is put in as the film is aimed at a teenage audience. The repetition of the prologue helps people remember it. Zeffirelli's prologue is much more relaxed, with a slow pan across a sleepy city at dawn and peaceful music in the background, and a well spoken man reading the prologue. In the Zeffirelli version, the extra characters are usually a part of the scene, and they are used to give an onlookers impression of the story. Their reactions are filmed for the fight scene. There is one shot where the civilians are standing above a wall and the fight is going on beneath it. The focus of this scene is the wall, which represents a division between the feud going on between the two families and the outside world. In Luhrmann's version the extras are more used for comedy, for example the section just before the fight when one of the Montague boys licks his nipple in front of some convent schoolgirls and two nuns, who then drive off unrealistically quickly in a minibus. ...read more.

Conclusion

The main difference in the film is the fact that Baz Luhrmann's version is set in the late 20th century, whereas Zeffirelli has decided to stick to the more traditional scenery. The Luhrmann version has kept more of the original dialogue but it is not as noticeable as the repeated prologues acclimatise the viewer to the Shakespearian tongue. One of the similarities is the target audience, as both of the films are aimed at a teenage audience. The way that the films appeal to their target audiences is very different. Luhrmann has used well know characters and repetition to make the film appealing to young people however Zeffirelli has cast completely unknown actors in the main roles, but they are of the same age as the target audience. Zeffirelli's version is also very simplified and misses out a lot more of the original lines and the filming is easy to comprehend. I think that Luhrmann has been more successful in appealing to a young audience, but maybe young people when Zeffirelli made his film were different to todays. I think that the opening of the more modern version appeals to me more, as I find it very interesting to see the clashing of setting and language working so effectively. The repetition of the prologue was also very good, as it made the opening much more memorable than Zeffirelli's version, something which is key for a good film. ?? ?? ?? ?? Sarah Cooper 10Lat. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Miscellaneous section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Miscellaneous essays

  1. Analysis of Shrek the film

    by singing and telling stories which are irrelevant to the subject, he wants to stay with Shrek after only just meeting him. All this suggests that Shrek is harmless and not blood thirsty. In the scene of the fairy-tale creatures the three blind mice show up on Shrek's dinner table

  2. Romeo & Juliet 'I am fortune's fool' - to what extent is Romeo a ...

    The next day Romeo seeks out his spiritual adviser the friar, and he agrees to marry them. With the help of Juliet's Nurse and the Friar they marry each-other, meanwhile Juliet's cousin Tybalt is really angry that Romeo and his friends intruded the ball so he requests a duel and starts looking for him.

  1. Analysis of the short story Irregularities by Courtney Jones

    This is a complete contrast to Dr. Soleanders wife and it could perhaps be the reason why he seeks the company of the female narrator in the first place, because as he explains, when the narrator is examined for her irregular heartbeat, "True beauty lies in nature's mistakes"6.

  2. Are Footballers Paid Too Much

    If someone like an officer didn't do their job properly then they would not be given a second chance. I think footballers pay should be lowered before they get too full of themselves and want more. This comment is understandable.

  1. COMPARE ND CONTRAST TH CULTURAL STATUS OF TWO COUNTRIES UK ND CHINA

    adult world, are successfully negotiated. As they get older, people with intellectu?l disabilities will inevit�ably develop different perspectives from those of their parents. While people with intellectu?l disabilities will increasingly require assistance to access mainstream services where appropriate, carers need support ?nd sometimes respite from th? caring role (Decoufl� P, Autry A. 2002; pp 375-82).

  2. Stake holders report

    Local community The local community are a stakeholder in Chester Zoo; this is because they are affected by the Zoo. For example Chester Zoo has applied for planning permission to build a tropical rainforest for the Zoo where gorillas, chimpanzees and other tropical animals could move freely.

  1. My anlysis of the front page of a tabloid

    of events and is seen to be backing the soldier on the ground at the front. This to is typical of the Daily Mirror which since the 1930's has been a sensationalist left wing newspaper aimed at the working man.

  2. What has Baz lUhrmann done to Juliet?

    The first time we meet Juliet she is in a bath. The first time we meet Romeo he is on the beach. They are both associated with water. Juliet is obedient and respectful, and we first see this when Juliet calls her mother Madam.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work