• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"An Institution in decline." Discuss this view of the contemporary House of Commons.

Extracts from this document...


"An Institution in decline." Discuss this view of the contemporary House of Commons. The House of Commons has seven main functions; legitimating, Scrutinising, Accountability, Legislating, Law-making, Redressing of grievances and deliberating. If the contemporary House of Commons were in decline, we would see this by a decline in the effectiveness of the House of Commons when carrying out these functions. Looking at the functions of the House of Commons will help to assess whether or not the House of Commons is "an institution in decline." Legislation has to be approved by the House of Commons in order to give the consent of the people for the laws that they will be expected to follow. This is achieved in the function of legitimating in the House of Commons. No decline in effectiveness seems to be shown in this function. MPs are becoming more representative of the population as the House of Commons is slowly changing from being predominantly white, middle aged and middle class men to more representative of females and ethnic minorities; there are now 118 female MPs and the number of ethnic minority MPs has risen for the fourth time since 1945. ...read more.


However, there are many cases in which the House of Commons has made sure that people are accountable for their actions and example of this is the July 2001 AS Examination debate that asked questions to education ministers and gave the Opposition a chance to criticize the government; this acts as a deterrent for ministers as they don't follow any bad policies if there is a chance that they will have to fully justify their reasons for it. Legislating is passing laws. The House of Commons aren't expected to defeat government laws as the government has the majority. A problem of legislating is that the government usually gets what it wants as it dominates the House of Commons and MPs are unlikely to rebel; Tony Blair said in a speech "Look at the Tory party...They were all swept away, rebels and loyalists alike...you are here because of the Labour party under which you fought." This was to tell MPs that they had to be united or they would lose power like the Conservatives had. They were told that they should rely on their party because it was the only reason they had a job. MPs aren't willing to risk losing their salary for a rebellion. ...read more.


a "right to rule" to introduce the policies they were elected for. The statement that the House of Commons in an "Institution in decline" isn't correct because there is no evidence to show that the House of Commons isn't carrying out its roles effectively. There has been no decline in the effectiveness of the way in which the House of Commons carries out its roles of scrutiny, accountability, legislation, law making and redressing of grievances; as they are still carried out as well as they always had been. There have been improvements in the legitimating functions of the House of Commons as there is better representation and there is still a great deal of respect for other MPs as they represent their public constituency by the use of the title "honourable member." Another function that is being carried out ,ore effectively by the commons is deliberation due to better representation and an elected government. There are minor problems with the functions of the House of Commons that prove rather ineffective e.g. MPs are unlikely to rebel so they may be agreeing with their party rather than speaking to represent their constituents, but overall, the functions of the House of commons are carried out as effectively or if not, more effectively than in previous times. Siobhan Kiely October 2003 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. For my creative piece I have written a short story set in the future, ...

    I have posted many letters to magazines, even yours, all of which have not been published through fear of breaking the law." "Wait a minute. Something doesn't add up! What happened to the wig you bought?" "Erm, well you see. Oh what the heck I'll just tell you the truth.

  2. How effective are M.P.'s at scrutinising the Government?

    This allows for an open government, through which M.P.'s can effectively scrutinise the government. Although some critics speculate that Select Committees have limited resources. Therefore they have insufficient funds to commission independent research into government, which would effectively allow them to scrutinise the government more meticulously.

  1. Malta at the turn of the 19th Century.

    This system blockaded all the British trade in Europe and brought discontent around Europe. However, for Malta this brought prosperity, in fact Malta had become the main artery of contraband gods in the Mediterranean. Many ships were coming to Malta buying goods, thus more warehouses were needed, together with an

  2. Legislators have three essential functions: representation, law-making and control of the executive. How does ...

    p.28 and control of the performance of the government ( Leistungskontrolle). The former means that the Bundestag can try to ascertain government policy or, having ascertained it, to criticise that policy. It can do so by menas of the Question Time(Fragestunde)

  1. The House of Commons

    exposure of MPs private life, the threat of de-selection which means that an MP will be unable to stand in the next election and physical threats this type of threat is rarely used. These happen when MP's act against the wishes of their party The whip can also make promises

  2. Distinguish between the different functions of the House of Lords and House of Commons

    The House of Commons represents the nation and as debates are made, the nation are indirectly involved as everyone in the House of Commons is elected, although only 10 per cent of these are women and many MPs distort their constituencies wishes.

  1. 'The House of Commons most important function is to participate in the law making ...

    Law making in the House of Commons is also the most important function as any MP can influence the legislation content, they can put forward their ideas and debate them in order to put forward a suitable bill to the House of Lords, trying to make sure there are no flaws.

  2. The debate over immigration and French identity is one of the most controversial questions ...

    Significantly, most of the attacks involved French workers, a group whose patience with France's war effort was clearly being strained by the spring of 1917, and generally the attacks were aimed against colonial workers, a group that was perceived a negative symbol of all those, especially shirkers, who profitted at the expense of the average French person.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work