• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Belfast Air Raid Investigation

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

ASSIGNMENT TWO: OBJECTIVE THREE 1. Source A suggests that the air-raid on Belfast had relatively little effect. There were few casualties and defences coped well. However, there is no specific content. This is probably due to it being a censored government publication, which does not want to ruin morale. It also mentions fires being extinguished very quickly and anti-aircraft fire being maintained by ground defences. 2. (i) Sources C and D differ from A and B in numerous ways. Firstly, source A is describing the first raid on Belfast, whereas sources B, C and D are describing the second raid. Sources A and B are released to the public by the government, whilst C and D are confidential reports. The sources quite clearly differ over the effects of the raid. Sources A and B are more vague; to make raids sound light. This is due to them being censored by the government, to ensure they have little impact on the people and in fact raise their morale. Sources C and D however, are more factual containing precise figures and details. Source B says 'some districts, shops and houses were damaged' and a 'small number' were killed. Conversely, source C has more specific content saying, 'big fires in the Crumlin Road' and they are far from light. Source A describes how fire services dealt well. However, source D describes the fire fighting as, 'completely inadequate.' Therefore, we can say sources A and B are trying to give an appearance of calm, but sources C and D are giving a more realistic picture. 2. (ii) I think the origin of the source explains why the sources are different. ...read more.

Middle

He claimed one hundred lives were taken, and source J showed no sign of the shelter suggesting severe damage was inflicted. However, this source was printed in a newspaper; of course censored by the government. It could be another example of propaganda, obviously intended to boost morale. In this photograph, houses are still standing; suggesting the bombs had little effect upon the people of Belfast. Furthermore, there are no dead bodies, or any emergency services. We have no idea if this is the full picture. Since this was censored it clearly does not show the full impact of the raid and is therefore less useful than sources G and H in indicating how the raids affected people in Northern Ireland. 5. Source L was clearly intended to raise morale. It was printed in a censored newspaper, so contained no sensitive information, or specific facts. It is clearly patriotic, praising the courage, determination and strength of the people of Belfast. It was possibly part of a British propaganda programme, attempting to show that all was well. This source justifies the 'noble cause' and talks of the need for sacrifice. It praises the character of the people throughout, saying, 'our growing courage.' The source is negative only once when it mentions 'wrecked homes' but does not account for damage or number of fatalities. Source A was an official statement released by the government to the press, describing the affects of the first raid. This information was censored to firstly, prevent information getting into enemy hands and also to maintain the morale of the Northern Irish people, and gain their support. The content shows this; there are no specific details of impact of the raid, does not mention areas of damage, and plays down the number of casualties - describing them as 'small'. ...read more.

Conclusion

There is a clear difference between those sources controlled by the government and those which are not, it is difficult to decide which can be used with the greatest degree of reliability. Source F shows that in September 1939 Belfast had only 16 anti-aircraft fighting guns. McGimpsey in 'Bombs on Belfast' stated that 'the defences of the city, without search lights and with few anti-aircraft guns, offered little resistance.' However, in source A, the official statement says that 'a heavy barrage of anti-aircraft fire was maintained by the ground defences.' Therefore, such obvious contradictions induce difficulty in creating an accurate reconstruction. An additional problem of the time was the government's censorship of the media for its own purposes. This can be seen in sources B and L where the impact of the raid is clearly concealed. Source B says a 'small number of people were killed;' but source G puts the figure at 500. Thereunto, Brian Barton says 745 dead and McGimpsey states it to be as high as 900 dead. To conclude, it is extremely difficult to interpret and understand events from the past without having a wide range of sources available. It is possible to construct a fairly accurate picture by cross-referencing sources and by using a mixture of primary and secondary sources, always being aware of the possible strengths and weaknesses within each source. However, it is difficult to produce a full and accurate reconstruction when all the facts are not known. Added to this, there is the problem of reliability, bias, censorship, exaggeration, memory loss, and hindsight. We can see then why historians must be aware of these factors in examining sources and use the appropriate techniques to produce the best reconstruction possible and uncover the mysteries and secrets of our past. THE BELFAST BLITZ COURSEWORK ASSIGNMENTS By Adrian Scott ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Using your own knowledge and the evidence of Sources 1, 3 and 5 what ...

    The Instrument of Government had been proposed by Lambert and other army officers thus held certain values that were beneficial to the army. In addition, the constitution made provision for army officers in the Council of State, which consisted of 7 army officers; their consent was needed on all major issues.

  2. The Impact of Electoral Design on the Legislature.

    Their votes do not help elect anybody and so are wasted, they could have stayed at home and the result would not have been altered. * In 1997, in Great Britain, 14.7 million voters cast ineffective votes - that is 48.2% of those who voted.

  1. British History Coursework: The Irish Famine 1845-1849

    The state refused to do anything in terms of economic protectionism, arguing that they had just spent ten painful years campaigning for the lifting of protection on corn. Were they to throw that away because the Irish were hungry? It was only the potato crop that had failed in Ireland:

  2. Are conventions more than mere habits and do they serve a useful purpose?

    and those which aid control of legal rules would either not exist or would have to be made into law. It may mean that the UK would require a written constitution and as already mentioned this would create ridged rules and may prevent any evolution of the practices of government.

  1. Using the evidence of Sources 2, 3 and 5, and your own knowledge explain ...

    army "depended wholly upon him and his greatness" as implied in Source 3, with hindsight we can see this is incorrect as was reflected by the failure of Richard Cromwell's government. Therefore, the internal conflicts with the Protector and the disputes among the various groups meant that reaching a lasting settlement was less probable.

  2. personal exercis programme

    to see how many I could do in one minute. This allowed me to see how long my muscles were able to sustain the physical demand of push-ups. I lied on a mat, keeping my legs straight. I was then timed for one minute.

  1. HUMANITIES COURSEWORK

    The conflict has also had a health effect on the Palestinian people. This can be seen in the statement by Ruchana Marton (who was also interviewed by the Guardian, in the 'Portrait of a war') stating that 'The Palestinian ambulances are not allowed to move in the west Bank and people just don't know about this.'

  2. citizenship data task

    * Our research also told us that we needed to give our full attention to each child, and that we should make sure we let every child know that they are being listened to (see Reference List), and so we divided up the classroom into different groups, and each one

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work