• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Different Aspects Weakening the Presidency.

Extracts from this document...


Different Aspects Weakening the Presidency The presidency is commonly misperceived as a position of absolute power. On the contrary, presidential scholars Richard Neustadt, Presidential Power and the Modern Presidents, and Gary Rose, The American Presidency Under Siege, argue the presidency is better characterized in terms of weaknesses. Their identification of contributing factors to weakened presidency differ in degree, execution, and form. Neustadt and Rose focus on two separate areas affecting the presidency and its effectiveness, each taking into account different aspects of the presidency while ignoring others. Neustadt's view of a model president is one who is active, yet conservative of his power. The President should have knowledge, understanding and vision. He should measure each situation with cost-analysis mentality, only pursuing what can be accomplished successfully. The President is actively involved in acquisition of power. Using professional reputation and public prestige, the President can increase bargaining power. By building a record of success, the President can become more influential through presidential persuasion, in policy making, and conserve presidential power. According to Neustadt, persuasion measures power. The President is responsible for actions contributing to gaining and losing of presidential power. Presidential power is based upon skill and not upon circumstance. Neustadt tailors his argument to fit individualistic means of effectiveness. Rose shifts the increasing weakness problem away from the President and places it on outside factors, blaming the system of governing and party decline. ...read more.


It is obvious that Rose's views on the presidency are that it should be an office of unrestricted powers. Rose sites Hamilton as important to the study of presidential power. Hamilton was part of "the Radicals" group of constitutional framers which outline the presidency as strong and independent with broad power. Neustadt preaches conservation of power. If the President must act, he has failed. Both Neustadt and Rose emphasize the importance of being a Washington insider. Rose presents Carter as an example of failure due to being and outsider. Carter campaigned as a Washington outsider, and did not like Washington politics. These factors lead to low support for presidential agendas. Rose again attributes the decline of political parties to failure of presidential support. The shift from party based to candidate based campaigns has weakened presidential ties in Washington. When a candidate comes into office he does not bring with him a broad base of party support anymore. The President is thusly restricted in his abilities to produce policy changes. Neustadt stated Carter also as a weak president due to low professional reputation. Carter could not get what he wanted from Congress like tax on waterways and the National Energy Plan. Weakening party ties leads to and individual based campaign, which leads to outsider failure. Rose identifies the media as shaping public perceptions of the President. ...read more.


Clinton's loyalty to his soft money contributors is obvious in his health care plan. Lobby reform policies that Rose proposes will not work, because they need to be passed by people who are already benefiting from the system. Congress is not inclined to lose funding or perks given to them by outside influences. Although Rose's description of bureaucracy is exaggerated, his idea of reforming patronage is necessary. Presidents should appoint leaders of implementation who are more responsive to the executive office, and accountable to the President. Reforming the patronage system allows for better evaluation of the President. Repealing the twenty-second amendment adds to the power of the presidency by reducing lame duck views and increasing Washington affiliation. An outsider president can increase is ability to bargain if term limits are not imposed. Even a Washington outsider can eventually find his niche and be effective, but not if he is limited. Lame duck views of a second term president decrease his bargaining power and effectiveness. Neustadt and Rose identify factors which contribute to weaknesses of the presidency, but fail to recognize the big picture. Both analysis are narrow and focus on only specific issues. Neustadt's arguments are favorable, because they allow the President to take an active role in acquisitioning power. Rose's views of a helpless president, dependent on outside reform to function, are impracticable. It is hard to believe that the President is so debilitated that he can not on his own actively attain and retain power. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Conflict Analysis: Angola

    and distance to form between the opposing parties over the months before conflict seriously escalated. March passed and UNITA continuously failed to meet deadlines, appealing for more time. It became clear UNITA was employing delaying tactics and that an explosion of violent behaviour was on the horizon.

  2. Politics is a very emotive word and is used by different people to mean ...

    The rise in the standard of living is not attributed to capitalism, but precisely to the infringements which have been made upon capitalism. In addition, people have attributed to economic progress, labour unions and social legislation, and to what they consider to be improved personal ethics on the part of employers.

  1. Asylum seekers

    the European Union; * Those who are unsuccessful on appeal will be required to leave the UK. If necessary, they will be removed. * Those who are recognised as refugees will be granted immediate stay in the UK and will be helped to build a new life.

  2. Civil Service Reform.

    Policy and resourcing remain the responsibility of Departments. The Chief Executives are accountable to the Minister and, through the Minister, to Parliament. The pay of the Chief Executive is linked to the performance of the agency. Theakston points out that the Ibbs report argued that the civil service should be treated as a collection of separate businesses.

  1. The siege of the Iranian Embassy

    They blew out the armoured windows with a 'frame charge' (A long strip of C4 explosives). An eight-strong rear team abseiled down from the roof. This almost ended in disaster when one of the SAS men became entangled in his abseiling rope.

  2. “The US Presidency is utterly a-typical and cannot be used as a model of ...

    This influence over Southern American nations shows that it has been used as a model of executive authority, a model that should be admired and implemented. We can see since the fall of the Communist Eastern Bloc across Eastern Europe that there are still many new nations trying to follow

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work