• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Do you agree that cohabitation has made for a weaker President but a more balanced system of government?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Ian Bishop Do you agree that cohabitation has made for a weaker President but a more balanced system of government? The constitution of the French Fifth Republic, as with most constitutions, was drawn up in the light of previous experience. Thus its authors sought to accommodate governments constituted form relatively unstable coalitions through the creation of new institutional glue in the form of reformed parliamentary procedure, greater executive powers, an overseeing Constitutional Council and a supervisory President. Within this framework, it was assumed that it would fall to the President to benignly observe events and intervene to protect the country from the dangers of instability associated with weak coalition government. However, the evolution of the French constitution soon belied this image of the President. With the institution of direct election to the office of President, the legitimacy of the office holder was affirmed, and thus allowed successive Presidents to develop the presidential role as they saw fit. As long as a President could command a majority of the votes in Parliament on the basis of a majority of votes won in general elections, he had the political legitimacy to interpret the constitutional role of the President. This process continued for some twenty-eight years , and in France it seemed that the electorate had come to accept the logic of a strong President aided by a parliamentary majority. This trend shaped the evolution of the Constitution, making it difficult to answer in constitutional terms what would happen in the absence of a majority. ...read more.

Middle

During periods of cohabitation the President remains a key figure in French political life. He maintains his crucial role as head of state, and the dignity which accompanies this role is by no means diminished in periods of cohabitation. The power of the President in foreign and defence matters remains great, and his assent is still required to make law. The great importance of Presidential elections demonstrates well how the Presidency remains a core component in the French Political system, and the parties still seek the office of President above all else. In periods of cohabitation, the executive effectiveness of the President and his staff is obviously weakened. In the first period of cohabitation the staff of the President were excluded from close contact with the ministries1. In the second period of cohabitation this deliberate limitation was less evident, but the effectiveness of the Elys�e was still limited. It is important to differentiate in this way between the three cohabitations. The different circumstances surrounding each of them, and the varying political climate of the day shaped the nature of the different cohabitations in distinct ways. In the first cohabitation of 1986 - 1988 the concept was a new one, and no one was entirely sure how the system might continue to function. The strong left-right animosities of the period led to a particularly adversarial atmosphere between the Prime Minister and the President. In contrast, the latest and current cohabitation of 1997 has seen not only the full acceptance of cohabitation as a norm of the French political system, but also a more co-operative relationship between President and Prime Minister. ...read more.

Conclusion

The continuation of stable government with strong leadership throughout the majority of the 1990s has demonstrated that the President can still take a very active lead in politics, and the advent of cohabitative governments is not a precursor to a decline in Presidential power in France. In conclusion, the advent of cohabitation has made weakness in the Presidency more easily noticeable. In effect, a cohabitative government is a structural manifestation of a weak President who has at least not fully convinced the electorate of the validity of his programme. However, the President is not rendered impotent by cohabitation, and rather than in indictment of the office of the President, a cohabitation represents a constitutional shot off the bows from the electorate. The President has not been robbed of his ability to exercise strong executive power, but he has lost the ability to do so when the public do not endorse his parliamentary party. The system of government as a whole, if not made more balanced by the occurrence of cohabitation has certainly become more constitutionally aware in nature as a result. Increased faith in, and attention to the wording of the Constitution of the Fifth Republic has been a result of cohabitation, and the way in which the constitution has so well risen to the challenge is in itself a factor that has contributed to stability and balance in the French political system. 1 Ministerial staff were instructed by the Prime Minister to refuse telephone calls from the Elys�e, since all contact was to be routed through the Prime Minister's office. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. British Government and the Constitution "Government without a Constitution is power without a right."

    My opening paragraph described Britain as a Monarchy with a democratically elected government, but is this strictly accurate? We now see the power officialdom as the Executive (government), the Legislature (parliament) and the Judicature (the court system). All considered the Separation of Powers, but in reality, all working juxtapose.

  2. Parliamentary government and Presidential government

    Parliamentarism is praised, relative to presidentialism, for its flexibility and responsiveness to the public. It is faulted for its tendency to sometimes lead to unstable governments, as in the German Weimar Republic and the French Fourth Republic. Parliamentary systems usually have a clear differentiation between the head of government and

  1. Explain and evaluate Locke's theory of government

    soon historical backup came when the parliamentary elections were won by the bourgeois block. In his theory, he concretizes this position as the theory of division of the authority. According to principle of differentiation of prerogatives, supreme power, the legislation belongs to bourgeois parliament that decides according to 'the will of the majority'.

  2. The United States uses a presidential system of government and is a stable democracy; ...

    While the American president is much restricted, the Brazilian president is allowed to deal with Congress in many ways. He can declare decrees which are provisional regulations with the force of law. He can also declare bills to be urgent therefore forcing Congress to make prompt decisions on his proposals.

  1. The Advent of Imperialism

    The races of Africa it has been possible to regard as savages or children, "backward" in their progress along the same general road of civilisation in which Anglo-Saxondom represents the vanguard, and requiring the help of more forward races. It is not so easy to make a specious case for

  2. Was the Provisional Government fatally weakened from the first? Notes

    As war minister, he urged that Russia should embrace the conflict with Germany as a struggle to save the Revolution, requiring the total dedication of the nation. He made a number of personal visits to the front to deliver passionate speeches to the troops.

  1. Some have noted the weak role of Dail Eireann within the Irish political system. ...

    It's a welcome example of substance before style in politics. "Irish governments try to find a consensus within parliament for their proposals and are willing to take on board constructive suggestions from the opposition" (ibid pp. 219-220). However, it is pragmatism rather than the D�il itself that compels ministers to accept amendment proposals.

  2. Prospects for India's development

    and 98, labor force will grow by more than 60 basis points). To India, this gap represents an increasing challenge because six million jobsv will have to be created every year for the next two to five years in addition to the number of jobs that have already been created in past years.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work