• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Extracts 1 and 2 disagree about weather China should host the 2008 Olympic games. How do you account for the differences? Explain your answer using the sources and the knowledge from your studies.

Extracts from this document...


Extract 1 says "China's appalling record on human rights should have disqualified it from hosting this or any other Olympics until it has put its house it order" Extract 2 says hosting the Olympics would "greatly inspire the patriotism of the Chinese people" and promote China's "reform and opening up". Extracts 1 and 2 disagree about weather China should host the 2008 Olympic games. How do you account for the differences? Explain your answer using the sources and the knowledge from your studies. The Olympic games are the biggest sporting event in the world, and for a country to be awarded the honour of hosting the event will bring them great prestige. The country will also receive a lot of publicity because all the world's media will be covering the event. The Olympics have been used to make political stands through out its history. In 1936 Adolf Hitler used the Olympic games to show the superiority of the Arian race, but black athlete thwarted his plan. In 1972 in Munich Israel terrorists killed Palestine athletes because they knew it would be publicised over the whole world. Also in Moscow in 1980 USA boycotted the Olympic games because they were protesting over Russia invading Afghanistan. ...read more.


A problem with this policy was that if a family had a girl the parents would murder her so they could boy for a boy. This was because Chinese traditionally value sons more than daughters. As there would have been less people there should have been an improvement in living standards but there wasn't. This source links in with sources A and B because they all show a lack of personal freedom. This source is portraying the facts and the information is fairly accurate because it comes from a text, which will be used in schools. I will now move on to look at the sources, which look at China in a positive way. I will start with source A, this is a picture showing a students protesting in Tiananmen Square in 1989. The source states that China's soldiers exercised the 'highest degree of restraint' and that if they wanted to the soldiers could have moved past the 'lone scoundrel'. This image and the commentary were broadcasted on Chinese T.V and so would have been controlled by the Chinese government. All the media in China, including the Internet, newspapers, magazines, radio and the government controlled television. ...read more.


Where as the sources written by the East have been censored by the Chinese Government, or written by the government and also only exaggerate the good points of China. Here is only one source which has a balanced opinion on China and that's source C. But again this source is also unreliable because it's from a charity organisation, so they do not want to upset the Chinese government by criticising the country because they want money from them. The sources, which could be used to argue for China hosting the Olympic games, are A, D, F and H. These sources are all written by the Chinese government or under their control and only have a one sided opinion, which makes them unreliable to use. The sources, which could be used to argue against China hosting the Olympic games are A, D, F, and H. But these sources are not entirely accurate or reliable because they are written by the West and focus mainly on the bad points. Certain places in the West do not agree with China hosting the Olympic games and so have tried to damage Chinas credibility. The Chinese believe that many other improvements have been made in their country E.g. increased literacy levels, improved health care, reduced infant mortality etc, and their human rights should not be the only issue considered. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Sharpeville Massacre Sources Question

    If the protestors had only been throwing stones, surely it was not necessary for the police to shoot them? Again, it is just one source against another. More evidence is needed. Source D is an eyewitness account of the event, told by Humphrey Tyler.

  2. The Negative Impact Of World War 1 On Italy: Weaknesses Of The Liberal State, ...

    The Fascists secured 7% of the total vote and won so won 35 seats. Fascism had gained an air of respectability and a foothold in parliament. As squadrismo violence increased so the authority of the government was undermined, their policies destabilised.

  1. When disputing over international borders of relations it is very common for history to ...

    The average rural income was around 20 U.S. dollars per year (R. Barnett, lecture at Copenhagen Ecology Seminar, 1994). All the new wealth that Tibet is gaining is going directly into the Chinese hands. The Tibetan people are seeing little or none of it. This can be shown by the announcement by the Chinese that a Tibetan railway will be built.

  2. To what extent are the experiences and attitudes of Yang Digong and Li Zucui ...

    Both of these problems were overcome reasonable quickly by the government who I feel dealt with it well. Grasping this information I think that China would be a good place to live as long as you observe and agree with the governments methods.

  1. Economic Changes after the 1949 Communist Revolution in China

    Soviet economic and technical assistance was expected to play a significant part in the functioning of the plan, and technical agreements were signed with the Soviets in 1953 and 1954. These agreements pledged 300 million U.S dollars over 5 years as well as thousands of soviet Technicians to help construct large industrial plants in china.

  2. Tiananmen Square

    Many roadblocks and battles against the army slowed them down a bit, but the roadblocks were not enough to stop tanks from entering the square. On June 4th the square was cleared of the protestors after a most gruesome event.

  1. Select And Explain The Most Important Turning Points In Nelson Mandela's Life

    The Black political organisations were banned and their leaders went into exile or were arrested. In this climate, the ANC and PAC abandoned their long-standing commitment to non-violent resistance and turned to armed struggle, combined with underground organisation and mobilisation as well as mobilisation of international solidarity.

  2. Since the inception in 1896 the Olympic Games have been used by nations and ...

    This is what De Coubertin believed the Olympics should be about. From the Nazi Olympics in 1936 to the Cold War boycotts in Moscow and Los Angeles lots of great political moments have dominated the Games. China who r the host of the 2008 Olympics has got a history of

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work