• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How do these three posters persuade men to enlist?

Extracts from this document...


Haberdashers' Monmouth school for Girls Centre No: 68350 Name: Rory Giles GCSE History Coursework - June 2000 Entry Objective 3 1. How do these three posters persuade men to enlist? Source A defines the two main roles of men and women during the time of the War; Men were expected to go to work and earn money for his family and home, and fight in the War. Women were needed in the home to generally organise the household and look after the children. These three figures appear to be the wife and mother with her two children. There is a powerful expression on the wife's face; she looks helpless and weak and the children seem to be clinging on to her. This image would appeal to most men as they would love to be seen as the brave one, protecting their defenceless family. The wife wants to be proud of her husband as he goes off to defend Britain. The children are watching their brave father with admiration. There is a huge amount of emotional pressure put on men in this poster; a man would like to be seen as more of a man in the eyes of his wife and to fulfil the roles of husband and father. Source B is an extremely powerful poster. A father is being asked what part he played in the War by his children. I think it implies that he didn't fight in the War by his slightly ashamed and dumbfounded look. The poster makes a powerful contrast: Wouldn't it be wonderful to tell your children tales of your success and bravery but what would you tell them if you had cowardly not been involved, hadn't fought for your country? ...read more.


morale and posititvity up back home There is no doubt that the first day had been a complete disaster for the British, with many thousands of casualties. This is not a reliable source. 4. These two sources were written long after the war was over. How reliable are they as evidence of what it was like on the Western Front? Use the sources and your own knowledge of the First World War to explain your answer. Source I by BA Steward is a primary piece of evidence. It is reliable because it is factual and plays down the glamorised, patriotic view many people had. He states this forcefully and I can sense some bitterness towards the glamour and bravado portrayed in many sources. He describes the merciless shooting of German soldiers by two, young British soldiers; this is evidence that the War made young men find death and killing routine and free of emotion. Both men are key witnesses; B.A. Steward was sent over after the heavy bombardment to capture High Wood. B.A. Steward's account is unique from many others because he describes his own emotions; he was frightened and wanted to get away from High Wood as quickly as he could to protect himself: 'What I now had in my mind was to go as quickly as possible in the opposite direction, as soon as possible. Leaving the dugout I ran for it.' B.A.Steward wrote his memoirs over sixty years later. This emphasises the strength in which his experiences are imprinted in his mind. This is a reliable source. Source K is a primary source. Sassoon was a key witness as he was an infantry officer at the time. ...read more.


Source E demonstrates how serious censorship could have mislead the British public. The lack of information may have led relatives to believe that their loved ones were safe and healthy when this was often not the case. This is evidence to support the interpretation. Source F clearly implies that the first day of the Battle of the Somme had been a success for the British. This is a highly misleading cartoon because the information is very inaccurate; the first day had been a complete disaster for the British. This is particularly misleading because the public did not doubt the information's reliability, because it was printed in a reliable source, a newspaper. Again this indicates the control the Government had over the press. Source G encourages misunderstanding; the poem portrays life on the Western Front as heroic, gallant and courageous. Again this poem was printed in the national press and people presumed this to contain reliable information. This source is not as blatantly misleading as source F, however there is some, but not total, intention to deceive. Source I provides a clear indication that the soldiers thought the Government were misleading the British people. Source J is not directly intentionally misleading because the cigarette manufacturer had to use a type of advertising that the British Government would approve of. Source K does not directly imply that the government were misleading but in comparison to source E it is clear that the government were concealing vital information from the public. Most of the sources indicate that the government were misleading the people but some are more obvious than others. Sources E, F and G are clearly intending to deceive. Sources A, B and J are not as blatantly misleading but they have subtle implications of the benefits of enlisting for the War and life on the Western front. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Introduction and Company Background.

    It is a key channel for the come-and-go of people from all over the world. Its geographical proximity to the southeastern coast is convenient for shipping. * Availability of Transportation Due to 100% of our products are exporting for sale and we have several overseas suppliers.

  2. Using your own knowledge and the evidence of Sources 1, 3 and 5 what ...

    would be difficult for the Protectorate to continue to exist, it also another contributory factor to the conflicting aims.

  1. The American Civil War

    His cabinet was composed of nearly every major Northern political faction. He selected Free-Soilers, Liberal Whigs, Conservative Whigs, and nearly any other political group imaginable (Nevins 47). Although theoretically a good plan, in practice, having so many views presented made it difficult for anything to be accomplished.

  2. Child Soldiers - an evaluation

    This high figure of individuals includes the non-active participants which number around 5,000 and the remaining, around 14,000.Most of the children involved are in the 15-18 year old category with the rest mainly being under the age of 13. It would be irresponsible of us though to imagine just males

  1. Indian independence - source based work with the sources.

    He says he has two alternatives; the first one, 'strengthen British control in India' could not possibly happen because at the same time he says ' we were demobilising the British armed forces' from India and the East.

  2. "Keeping Nelson Mandela in Prison Between 1964 and 1990 was a mistake" Do Sources ...

    These results were published in a school textbook so we have no reason to believe the information is inaccurate. The source could be seen to suggest Mandela's release hastened the end of apartheid so blacks were able to vote. It doesn't tell us anything directly about Mandela's imprisonment but it

  1. Are conventions more than mere habits and do they serve a useful purpose?

    Dicey explains this as 'practices which, although they may regulate the...conduct of the several members of the sovereign power...are not reality laws at all since they are not enforced by the courts.' This purely states that too breach a convention is to act non constitutionally but not unlawfully.

  2. Thoughts on Trudeau’s Memoirs

    how he finally realized that he had to even though he was reluctant to do so (Trudeau, 138-9). Then because Trudeau did this, people such as Rene Levesque, thought he acted stupidly and said that he made a wrong decision (Trudeau, 149).

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work