• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How effectively and by what means can the legislatures in the UK and the USA hold the executive accountable?

Extracts from this document...


How effectively and by what means can the legislatures in the UK and the USA hold the executive accountable? The assemblies in the UK and the USA are bi-cameral in order to create checks and balances on the government and prevent executive dominance. There is a fusion of powers in the UK and so the government is in theory a parliamentary one as the executive is not separately elected. However, the idea of a parliamentary government is now largely a chimera as executive dominance of the legislature has created, in Hailsham's words, 'elective dictatorship'. The US government however is presidential and based upon Montesquieu's principle of separation of powers with the legislature and executive being separately elected and independent of each other. ...read more.


Butler et al have highlighted the failure of Conservative MPs to effectively oppose the poll tax due to the party whips "backed by the bloated pay roll vote embracing more than a third of all Tory MPs."1 The poll tax further demonstrates the barriers in the way of the legislature when trying to hold to account a government with a large majority. The Thatcher government was only defeated on the 1986 Shops Bill - the third time in the twentieth century that a government with a majority has been defeated on the second reading. Indeed 95% of government legislation gets through due to lack of parliamentary scrutiny. ...read more.


Watergate affair. A weak whip system coupled with the fact that career advancement is not dependent on party loyalty as the appointment of a politician to the chair of a committee often marks the zenith of their career. However, Newt Gingrich Speaker of the House of Representatives (1995-1998) tried to strengthen party ties by placing new members of Congress who were the most committed to conservative principles on the most important committees. At the same time, Gingrich and other Republicans structured the work of the committees around the policies outline in the Contract with America and so ensured the passage of nearly all the proposals included in it. Furthermore there has been an increase in 'party votes' in recent years. 1 Butler, D., Adonis A. and Travers, T. - Failure in British Government: The Politics of The Poll Tax Lucy Frith ~1~ ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. The Word 'Hacker' To the popular press, "hacker" means someone who breaks into ...

    But two guys who thought Multics excessively complex went off and wrote their own. They gave it a name that was a joking reference to Multics: Unix. The latest intellectual property laws impose unprecedented restrictions on the sort of poking around that leads to new ideas.

  2. “The US Presidency is utterly a-typical and cannot be used as a model of ...

    a unique system and country there are clearly similarities with Western Parliamentary democracies such as Britain, Germany and France (the last two are essentially mixed but with the German president having no direct power). Neustadt's main analysis on being a President is the power to persuade.

  1. The Impact of Electoral Design on the Legislature.

    should be decisive for the outcome. The leading party should be empowered to try to implement their programme during their full term of office, without depending upon the support of minority parties. The government, and individual MPs, remain accountable for their actions to the public. And at periodic intervals the electorate should be allowed to judge their record, and vote for alternative parties accordingly.

  2. What is Politics UK politics revision notes

    provided affects quality * Pluralism - Freedom of Association * PG's serve as vital links between Government and Social * Assist in the dispersal of Political Power * Social Progress * New issues to be debated i.e. environmentalism * Social Cohesion * Safety Values for grievances * Opposition * Expose Information, Improving accountability Do Pressure Groups make the UK democratic?

  1. Analyse the relationship between the executive wing of the UK government and the legislative ...

    of Commons and a select committee of the House of Lords appointed to meet as one committee under one chairman: its procedure follows that of House of Lords select committees. A select committee chooses its own chairman, although there is usually an informal understanding about the party from which each chairman will be chosen.

  2. To what extent does executive dominance over parliament prevent M.P.'s from carrying out their ...

    These include through debates, asking questions on behalf of their constituency during Question Time, and through the use of Private Members Bills. However these Private Members Bills are profusely unsuccessful because of hostile tactics such as filibustering, lack of government support, and lack of time.

  1. Free essay

    Outline the principal sources of authority available to US presidents. How similar is executive ...

    He also learnt about the limitations of executive power on the job as governor of Texas. There is never a guarantee that election by a wide margin ensures a powerful president throughout his term in office. Likewise, having high public approval ratings doesn't necessarily ensure a free rein for the President.

  2. Malta at the turn of the 19th Century.

    The fights between France and Britain began to diminish and by 4th September 1800 after the agreement between Pigot, Ball and Vabois, the French surrendered. The real French capitulation was signed a day later, on 5th September 1800. With this capitulation the Maltese gained nothing, however the French had to

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work